Featured Post

In Defense of the West

When I first began this site, it was with the intention of arguing politics, evolution, and Christian apologetics, topics I found myself add...

Monday, March 13, 2006

A Crusade for the survival of Western Civilization

If the Western world continues to wallow in ignorance of its own great Christian heritage, who will stand to resist the barbarian horde?

And it should be noted that those "revising" history distort, suppress, and deny the truth about our past, making the West blind not only to its own worth, but also to its old enemy now seeming new.

An informative Q&A on the Crusades from Jihad Watch:
Q: The Crusades are often portrayed as a militarily offensive venture. Were they?

Spencer: No. Pope Urban II, who called for the First Crusade at the Council of Clermont in 1095, was calling for a defensive action -- one that was long overdue.

As he explained, he was calling the Crusade because without any defensive action, "the faithful of God will be much more widely attacked" by the Turks and other Muslim forces.

"For, as most of you have heard, the Turks and Arabs have attacked them and have conquered the territory of Romania [the Greek empire] as far west as the shore of the Mediterranean and the Hellespont, which is called the Arm of St. George," Pope Urban II said in his address. "They have occupied more and more of the lands of those Christians, and have overcome them in seven battles. They have killed and captured many, and have destroyed the churches and devastated the empire.

"If you permit them to continue thus for a while with impunity, the faithful of God will be much more widely attacked by them."

He was right. Jihad warfare had from the seventh century to the time of Pope Urban conquered and Islamized what had been over half of Christendom. There had been no response from the Christian world until the Crusades.

Q: What are some popular misconceptions about the Crusades?

Spencer: One of the most common is the idea that the Crusades were an unprovoked attack by Europe against the Islamic world.

In fact, the conquest of Jerusalem in 638 stood at the beginning of centuries of Muslim aggression, and Christians in the Holy Land faced an escalating spiral of persecution.

Early in the eighth century 60 Christian pilgrims from Amorium were crucified; around the same time the Muslim governor of Caesarea seized a group of pilgrims from Iconium and had them all executed as spies -- except for a small number who converted to Islam.

Muslims also demanded money from pilgrims, threatening to ransack the Church of the Resurrection if they didn't pay.

Later in the eighth century, a Muslim ruler banned displays of the cross in Jerusalem. He also increased the tax on non-Muslims -- jizya -- that Christians had to pay and forbade Christians to engage in religious instruction of their own children and fellow believers.

Early in the ninth century the persecutions grew so severe that large numbers of Christians fled for Constantinople and other Christian cities. In 937, Muslims went on a rampage in Jerusalem on Palm Sunday, plundering and destroying the Church of Calvary and the Church of the Resurrection.

In 1004, the Fatimid Caliph, Abu 'Ali al-Mansur al-Hakim, ordered the destruction of churches, the burning of crosses, and the seizure of church property. Over the next 10 years 30,000 churches were destroyed, and untold numbers of Christians converted to Islam simply to save their lives.

In 1009, al-Hakim commanded that the Church of the Holy Sepulcher in Jerusalem be destroyed, along with several other churches, including the Church of the Resurrection. In 1056, the Muslims expelled 300 Christians from Jerusalem and forbade European Christians from entering the rebuilt Church of the Holy Sepulcher.

When the Seljuk Turks took Jerusalem in 1077, the Seljuk Emir Atsiz bin Uwaq promised not to harm the inhabitants, but once his men had entered the city, they murdered 3,000 people.

Another common misconception is that the Crusades were fought to convert Muslims to Christianity by force. Glaringly absent from every report about Pope Urban's address at the Council of Claremont is any command to the Crusaders to convert Muslims.

It was not until over 100 years after the First Crusade, in the 13th century, that European Christians made any organized attempt to convert Muslims to Christianity, when the Franciscans began missionary work among Muslims in lands held by the Crusaders. This effort was largely unsuccessful.

Yet another misconception revolves around the Crusaders' bloody sack of Jerusalem in 1099.

The capture of Jerusalem is often portrayed as unique in medieval history, and as the cause of Muslim mistrust of the West. It might be more accurate to say that it was the start of a millennium of anti-Western grievance mongering and propaganda.

The Crusaders' sack of Jerusalem was a heinous crime -- particularly in light of the religious and moral principles they professed to uphold. However, by the military standards of the day, it was not actually anything out of the ordinary.

In those days, it was a generally accepted principle of warfare that if a city under siege resisted capture, it could be sacked, and while if it did not resist, mercy would be shown. It is a matter of record that Muslim armies frequently behaved in exactly the same way when entering a conquered city.

This is not to excuse the Crusaders' conduct by pointing to similar actions. One atrocity does not excuse another. But it does illustrate that the Crusaders' behavior in Jerusalem was consistent with that of other armies of the period -- since all states subscribed to the same notions of siege and resistance.

In 1148, Muslim commander Nur ed-Din did not hesitate to order the killing of every Christian in Aleppo. In 1268, when the jihad forces of the Mamluk Sultan Baybars took Antioch from the Crusaders, Baybars was annoyed to find that the Crusader ruler had already left the city -- so he wrote to him bragging of his massacres of Christians.

Most notorious of all may be the jihadists' entry into Constantinople on May 29, 1453, when they, according to historian Steven Runciman, "slew everyone that they met in the streets, men, women and children without discrimination."

Finally, it is a misconception that Pope John Paul II apologized for the Crusades. He did not.

There is no doubt that the belief that Pope John Paul II apologized for the Crusades is widespread. When he died, the Washington Post reminded its readers "during his long reign, Pope John Paul II apologized to Muslims for the Crusades, to Jews for anti-Semitism, to Orthodox Christians for the sacking of Constantinople, to Italians for the Vatican's associations with the Mafia and to scientists for the persecution of Galileo."

However, John Paul II never actually apologized for the Crusades. The closest he came was on March 12, 2000, the "Day of Pardon."

During his homily he said: "We cannot fail to recognize the infidelities to the Gospel committed by some of our brethren, especially during the second millennium. Let us ask pardon for the divisions which have occurred among Christians, for the violence some have used in the service of the truth and for the distrustful and hostile attitudes sometimes taken toward the followers of other religions."

This is hardly a clear apology for the Crusades.

Q: How have Muslims perceived the Crusades then and now?

Spencer: For centuries, when the Ottoman Empire was thriving, the Crusades were not a preoccupation of the Islamic world. They were, after all, failures from a Western standpoint.

However, with the decline of the military power and unity of the Islamic world, and the concomitant rise of the West, they have become a focal point of Muslim resentment of perceived Western encroachment and exploitation.

Q: To what extent are false ideas about the Crusades being used by extremists to foment hostility to the West today?

Spencer: The Crusades may be causing more devastation today than they ever did in the three centuries when most of them were fought -- but not in terms of lives lost and property destroyed. Today's is a more subtle destruction.

The Crusades have become a cardinal sin not only of the Catholic Church but also of the Western world in general.

They are Exhibit A for the case that the current strife between the Muslim world and Western, post-Christian civilization is ultimately the responsibility of the West, which has provoked, exploited, and brutalized Muslims ever since the first Frankish warriors entered Jerusalem.

Osama bin Laden has spoken of his organization not as al-Qaida but of a "World Islamic Front for Jihad Against Jews and Crusaders," and called in a fatwa for "jihad against Jews and Crusaders."

Such usage is widespread. On November 8, 2002 -- shortly before the beginning of the Iraqi war that toppled Saddam Hussein -- Sheikh Bakr Abed Al-Razzaq Al-Samaraai preached in Baghdad's Mother of All Battles mosque about "this difficult hour in which the Islamic nation [is] experiencing, an hour in which it faces the challenge of [forces] of disbelief of infidels, Jews, crusaders, Americans and Britons."

Similarly, when Islamic jihadists bombed the U.S. Consulate in Jeddah, Saudi Arabia, in December 2004, they explained that the attack was part of larger plan to strike back at "Crusaders": "This operation comes as part of several operations that are organized and planned by al-Qaida as part of the battle against the crusaders and the Jews, as well as part of the plan to force the unbelievers to leave the Arabian Peninsula," the jihadists said in a statement.

They also said that jihad warriors "managed to enter one of the crusaders' big castles in the Arabian Peninsula and managed to enter the American consulate in Jeddah, in which they control and run the country."

In the face of this, Westerners should not be embarrassed by the Crusades. It's time to say, "enough," and teach our children to take pride in their own heritage.

They should know that they have a culture and a history of which they can and should be grateful; that they are not the children and grandchildren of oppressors and villains; and that their homes and families are worth defending against those who want to take them away, and are willing to kill to do so.

Resist evil. Read Spencer's The Politically Incorrect Guide to Islam (and the Crusades), Bostom's Legacy of Jihad, and Fregosi's Jihad in the West for more on Islam's war against Christendom (and rest of the non-Muslim world).

Friday, March 10, 2006

The perpetual war

Like many people, before 9/11 I was unaware of the nature and imminence of Jihad.

In researching several years ago information on whether or not the United States could be called a "Christian nation," I happened upon the misattribution at the beginning of the article excerpted below. Happily, I was enlightened by this essay as to the real context in which the statement was made (and by whom). At the time, I had no sense of the other, vital understanding to be derived from this article; namely, that the United States had been the victim of Jihad before, and that our greatest leaders fought against the tyranny of Allah then just as they struggled against the tyranny of the British king decades earlier.

Preserving and restoring in the minds of the American people the faith of our Founding Fathers in the God of the Bible is still paramount for that will determine the fate of our nation; Islam's endlessly bloody march toward the domination of all mankind can only be halted and reversed by a people who know for Whom and for what they fight.

Rejecting the God of the Bible only aids the enemy by leaving our nation open to false ideologies; such faithlessness will leave men without the courage to resist Islam's will to conquer.

From Wallbuilders.com, on the Treaty of Tripoli (footnotes omitted):
Those who advance the notion that this was the belief system of the Founders often publish information attempting to prove that the Founders were irreligious. One of the quotes they set forth is the following:
The government of the United States is in no sense founded on the Christian religion. GEORGE WASHINGTON
The 1797 Treaty of Tripoli is the source of Washington’s supposed statement. Is this statement accurate? Did this prominent Founder truly repudiate religion? An answer will be found by an examination of its source.

That treaty, one of several with Tripoli, was negotiated during the "Barbary Powers Conflict," which began shortly after the Revolutionary War and continued through the Presidencies of Washington, Adams, Jefferson, and Madison. The Muslim Barbary Powers (Tunis, Morocco, Algiers, Tripoli, and Turkey) were warring against what they claimed to be the "Christian" nations (England, France, Spain, Denmark, and the United States). In 1801, Tripoli even declared war against the United States, thus constituting America’s first official war as an established independent nation.

Throughout this long conflict, the five Barbary Powers regularly attacked undefended American merchant ships. Not only were their cargoes easy prey but the Barbary Powers were also capturing and enslaving "Christian" seamen in retaliation for what had been done to them by the "Christians" of previous centuries (e.g., the Crusades and Ferdinand and Isabella’s expulsion of Muslims from Granada).

In an attempt to secure a release of captured seamen and a guarantee of unmolested shipping in the Mediterranean, President Washington dispatched envoys to negotiate treaties with the Barbary nations. (Concurrently, he encouraged the construction of American naval warships to defend the shipping and confront the Barbary "pirates"—a plan not seriously pursued until President John Adams created a separate Department of the Navy in 1798.) The American envoys negotiated numerous treaties of "Peace and Amity" with the Muslim Barbary nations to ensure "protection" of American commercial ships sailing in the Mediterranean. However, the terms of the treaty frequently were unfavorable to America, either requiring her to pay hundreds of thousands of dollars of "tribute" (i.e., official extortion) to each country to receive a "guarantee" of safety or to offer other "considerations" (e.g., providing a warship as a "gift" to Tripoli, a "gift" frigate to Algiers, paying $525,000 to ransom captured American seamen from Algiers, etc.).

The 1797 treaty with Tripoli was one of the many treaties in which each country officially recognized the religion of the other in an attempt to prevent further escalation of a "Holy War" between Christians and Muslims. Consequently, Article XI of that treaty stated:
As the government of the United States of America is not in any sense founded on the Christian religion as it has in itself no character of enmity [hatred] against the laws, religion or tranquility of Musselmen [Muslims] and as the said States [America] have never entered into any war or act of hostility against any Mahometan nation, it is declared by the parties that no pretext arising from religious opinions shall ever produce an interruption of the harmony existing between the two countries.
This article may be read in two manners. It may, as its critics do, be concluded after the clause "Christian religion"; or it may be read in its entirety and concluded when the punctuation so indicates. But even if shortened and cut abruptly ("the government of the United States is not in any sense founded on the Christian religion"), this is not an untrue statement since it is referring to the federal government.

Recall that while the Founders themselves openly described America as a Christian nation (demonstrated in chapter 2 of Original Intent), they did include a constitutional prohibition against a federal establishment; religion was a matter left solely to the individual States. Therefore, if the article is read as a declaration that the federal government of the United States was not in any sense founded on the Christian religion, such a statement is not a repudiation of the fact that America was considered a Christian nation.

Reading the clause of the treaty in its entirety also fails to weaken this fact. Article XI simply distinguished America from those historical strains of European Christianity which held an inherent hatred of Muslims; it simply assured the Muslims that the United States was not a Christian nation like those of previous centuries (with whose practices the Muslims were very familiar) and thus would not undertake a religious holy war against them.

This latter reading is, in fact, supported by the attitude prevalent among numerous American leaders. The Christianity practiced in America was described by John Jay as "wise and virtuous," by John Quincy Adams as "civilized," and by John Adams as "rational." A clear distinction was drawn between American Christianity and that of Europe in earlier centuries. As Noah Webster explained:
The ecclesiastical establishments of Europe which serve to support tyrannical governments are not the Christian religion but abuses and corruptions of it.
Daniel Webster similarly explained that American Christianity was:
Christianity to which the sword and the fagot [burning stake or hot branding iron] are unknown—general tolerant Christianity is the law of the land!
Those who attribute the Treaty of Tripoli quote to George Washington make two mistakes. The first is that no statement in it can be attributed to Washington (the treaty did not arrive in America until months after he left office); Washington never saw the treaty; it was not his work; no statement in it can be ascribed to him. The second mistake is to divorce a single clause of the treaty from the remainder which provides its context.

It would also be absurd to suggest that President Adams (under whom the treaty was ratified in 1797) would have endorsed or assented to any provision which repudiated Christianity. In fact, while discussing the Barbary conflict with Jefferson, Adams declared:
The policy of Christendom has made cowards of all their sailors before the standard of Mahomet. It would be heroical and glorious in us to restore courage to ours.
Furthermore, it was Adams who declared:
The general principles on which the fathers achieved independence were. . . . the general principles of Christianity. . . . I will avow that I then believed, and now believe, that those general principles of Christianity are as eternal and immutable as the existence and attributes of God; and that those principles of liberty are as unalterable as human nature.
Adams’ own words confirm that he rejected any notion that America was less than a Christian nation.
Our fighting men and women are heroic and glorious. Would that our leaders would share a measure of that heroism and glory by telling the truth about the religion of Mahomet.

Rebelling against the God-ordained civil authority, or defending certain unalienable Rights?

God commands His people obey the governing authorities since they are established by Him. What exceptions does He allow? When the civil authority requires a believer to sin, he or she is to obey God, not men.

What possible argument can be made in defense of the American rebellion against its sovereign? Perhaps self-defense against those violating the laws of both man and God, but nothing else. From Wallbuilders.com
: Was the American Revolution a Biblically Justified Act (footnotes omitted)?
The second factor which the Framers believed gave them Biblical justification for their actions was the fact they did not initiate the conflict. The Framers had been fully committed to peaceful reconciliation and had pursued that course for 11 consecutive years before the separation from Great Britain. There was no desire to raise arms against England, their mother country and the land of their birth. Nevertheless, in the last two years of their peaceful reconciliation attempts (e.g., as in May 1776 with their Olive Branch Petition), their entreaties and appeals were met solely by military force. In fact, King George III dispatched 25,000 British troops to invade his own Colonies, enter into the homes of his own citizens, take their private possessions and goods, and imprison them without trials — all in violation of his own British common law, English Bill of Rights, and Magna Carta.

When their peaceful entreaties were met with armed attackers, the Framers cited full Biblical justification to defend their own homes, families, properties, and possessions — an important point to them. In their understanding of the Scriptures, God could bless a defensive war but not an offensive war. This was their great point of spiritual appeal: they had not attacked Great Britain; they had never fired the first shot — not in the British Massacre of 1770, nor in the Lexington and Concord engagements of 1775, nor in the bombing of Boston in 1774. Yet, now fired upon, they could defend themselves. In fact, so reticent were they to separate from Great Britain that it was a full three years after King George III had drawn the sword and sent armed troops against his own citizens in America before they announced their separation. As signer of the Declaration John Witherspoon confirmed:

On the part of America, there was not the most distant thought of subverting the government or of hurting the interest of the people of Great Britain; but of defending their own privileges from unjust encroachment; there was not the least desire of withdrawing their allegiance from the common sovereign [King George III] till it became absolutely necessary — and indeed, it was his own choice.

When the decision for a separation was finally made, however, the Founders continued to maintain their strong entreaty to God for the justness of their actions. For example, in a letter to British officials, Samuel Adams, the “Father of the American Revolution,” declared:

There is One above us who will take exemplary vengeance for every insult upon His majesty. You know that the cause of America is just. You know that she contends for that freedom to which all men are entitled — that she contends against oppression, rapine, and more than savage barbarity. The blood of the innocent is upon your hands, and all the waters of the ocean will not wash it away. We again make our solemn appeal to the God of heaven to decide between you and us. And we pray that, in the doubtful scale of battle, we may be successful as we have justice on our side, and that the merciful Savior of the world may forgive our oppressors.

Adams also authored a manifesto for the Continental Congress which reflected a similar tone of submission to God:

We, therefore, the Congress of the United States of America, do solemnly declare and proclaim that. . . . [w]e appeal to the God who searcheth the hearts of men for the rectitude of our intentions; and in His holy presence declare that, as we are not moved by any light or hasty suggestions of anger or revenge, so through every possible change of fortune we will adhere to this our determination.

It was the fact that they had been attacked which — in their understanding of the Bible — completely changed their status in the eyes of God, for the Bible clearly authorized and justified self-defense against an aggressor as righteous before God. But some object that the American Revolution resulted in a loss of life, and therefore cannot be justifiable in the eyes of God. This position demonstrates a lack of Biblical understanding about life.

Clearly, protecting innocent life is a key and recurring theme in the Bible. Life is God-given; He formed us, made us, and breathed life into us. Therefore, He gave clear commands both on preserving innocent life and on punishing those who take it (See, for example, Exodus 23:7, Deuteronomy 27:25 & 21:8-9 & 19:10, Proverbs 6:16-17, 2 Kings 24:4, Psalm 10:2,8, et al.) Since God is the author of life, and since He alone holds the keys of death (see 1 Samuel 2:6), He – not man – is to determine when life is to end.

However, the taking of life is not always the taking of innocent life. God allows man justifiably to take human life on three occasions.

The first occasion is for the cause of civil justice (e.g., Deuteronomy 19:11-13, Numbers 35:16-27, 2 Samuel 4:11, etc.). The shedding of blood in such cases is not the shedding of innocent blood. The second justifiable cause is general military conflict (e.g., Numbers 32:27, 2 Chronicles 32:8, 1 Samuel 4:1). The third cause is in defense of one’s life, family, or property (e.g., Nehemiah 4:13-14 & 20-21, Zechariah 9:8, 2 Samuel 10:12). In these three situations, the taking of life is not viewed by God as the shedding of innocent blood.

Similarly, Jewish scholars point out that the prohibition in the Sixth Commandment is not against killing but rather is against murder. That is, they assert that the proper translation from the Hebrew is not “Thou shalt not kill,” but rather “Thou shalt not murder.” Murder is the taking of innocent life, while killing may not be (e.g., the three Biblically justified examples given above).

Therefore, the fact that the American Revolution was a defensive rather than an offensive war made all the difference in whether it could be a righteous war before God. The Framers’ writings emphasized this fact. For example, Francis Hopkinson, a signer of the Declaration of Independence (and a church choir leader, musician, noted poet and literary figure), made this clear in his 1777 work “A Political Catechism”:

Q. What is war?

A. The curse of mankind; the mother of famine and pestilence; the source of complicated miseries; and the undistinguishing destroyer of the human species.

Q. How is war divided?

A. Into offensive and defensive.

Q. What is the general object of an offensive war? . . .

A. [F]or the most part, it is undertaken to gratify the ambition of a prince, who wishes to subject to his arbitrary will a people whom God created free, and to gain an uncontrolled dominion over their rights and property. . . .

Q. What is defensive war?

A. It is to take up arms in opposition to the invasions of usurped power and bravely suffer present hardships and encounter present dangers, to secure the rights of humanity and the blessings of freedom, to generations yet unborn.

Q. Is even defensive war justifiable in a religious view?

A. The foundation of war is laid in the wickedness of mankind . . . . God has given man wit to contrive, power to execute, and freedom of will to direct his conduct. It cannot be but that some, from a depravity of will, will abuse these privileges and exert these powers to the injury of others: and the oppressed would have no safety nor redress but by exerting the same powers in their defence: and it is our duty to set a proper value upon and defend to the utmost our just rights and the blessings of life: otherwise a few miscreants [unprincipled individuals] would tyrannize over the rest of mankind, and make the passive multitude the slaves of their power. Thus it is that defensive is not only justifiable, but an indispensable duty.

Q. Is it upon these principles that the people of America are resisting the arms of Great Britain, and opposing force with force?

A. Strictly so. . . . And may Heaven prosper their virtuous undertaking!

Q. But it has often been said, that America is in a state of rebellion. Tell me, therefore, what is Rebellion?

A. It is when a great number of people, headed by one or more factious leaders, aim at deposing their lawful prince without any just cause of complaint in order to place another on his throne.

Q. Is this the case of the Americans?

A. Far otherwise.

James Wilson (a signer of the Declaration and the Constitution, an original Justice on the U. S. Supreme Court and the father of the first organized legal training in America), explained in to his law students more about defensive rights:

I here close my examination into those natural rights, which, in my humble opinion, it is the business of civil government to protect, and not to subvert, and the exercise of which it is the duty of civil government to enlarge, and not to restrain. . . . The defence of one’s self, justly called the primary law of nature, is not, nor can it be abrogated by any regulation of municipal law. This principle of defence is not confined merely to the person; it extends to the liberty and the property of a man: it is not confined merely to his own person; it extends to the persons of all those, to whom he bears a peculiar relation — of his wife, of his parent, of his child, of his master, of his servant: nay, it extends to the person of every one, who is in danger, perhaps, to the liberty of every one, whose liberty is unjustly and forcibly attacked. It becomes humanity as well as justice. . . . As a man is justified in defending, so he is justified in retaking, his property, or his peculiar relations, when from him they are unjustly taken and detained. . . . This long investigation concerning natural rights and natural remedies, I conclude by answering the question, with which I introduced it: Man does not exist for the sake of government, but government is instituted for the sake of man.

A final indication that the Framers believed they were engaged in a defensive war was the fact that throughout the course of the struggle, the conflict was often described by the Americans as a civil war rather than a revolution. Only in later years was it consistently called a revolution rather than a civil war. Very clearly, the Framers did not view the American Revolution as an act of anarchy or of rebellion against God, the Bible or any of its teachings. Under the view of Romans 13 as understood by the Framers, the American Revolution was indeed a Biblically-justifiable act.

Thursday, March 9, 2006

It's time to put this one in the refrigerator

From EO:

Boonton,

Of course because at that moment the focus was on the upcoming battle. It is not clear, though, that those commands must apply for all of time after that one battle.

Without textual evidence limiting the command, it is intellectually dishonest to claim the command is limited.

Besides, Allah said, "...fight them on until...there prevail justice and faith in Allah altogether and everywhere..." (Qur'an 8:38, 39).

...why were other commands such as for Muslims to behave peacefully when they find themselves in non-Muslim lands that are not abusing Muslims left in the Koran?

The early "revelations" on cooperation with non-Muslims came to Mohammed while the (false) prophet was militarily weak. Later, after he and his forces were strong enough for open war, the commands came for offensive jihad to make the world Islam.

But that was noted already.

...except the quoting of famous scholars of Islam tells us that this way is not quite as new as you would imply when you write "a way in which has never been understood"

What "famous scholars"? An apostate or two do not a major school of Islamic thought make.

I'll ask again, what major schools of Islam reject offensive warfare against the Infidel? The implication that non-violent readings of Qur'an have been popular throughout Islam's history (except with heretics) is false.

Again you play into the Islamists hands when you reinforce their contention that suicide bombing, attacks on civilians etc. are nothing new. Yes civilians have always ended up getting killed in wars and the ancient world worried less about 'collateral damage' than our modern world does but it is a disservice to the truth (as well as Islam & good policy in general) to give terrorists a credibility they don't really have.

Stop pretending.

-Denying the source and sustenance of Jihad does nothing to slow it; it only aids the enemy by keeping witless Infidels ignorant of its intentions until it is too late.
-Implying that telling the truth about the enemy helps them is false and foolish.
-Misrepresenting the exposing of Allah and his apostle's support for Jihad as "a disservice to the truth" is a disservice to the truth.

(Here's a new Boontonian "argument" I don't recall seeing before: attributing to me the deception in which he indulges. That's worthy of Jihad's most skilled apologists.)

That the jihadists have credibility with Muslims is because they have the words of Allah and the example of Mohammed on their side. You have only logical fallacies, half-truths, and bad analogies.

Your chief characteristic of the difference supposedly between God and Allah is that God has a son but Allah does not.

Another (intentional?) distortion.

YHWH is not Allah. Jesus said of Himself that He is the Son of God. Allah said he had no son.

Except in Boontonia, those two claims are mutually-exclusive. Both cannot be true, unless YHWH and Mohammed's Allah are different deities.

Several other clear contradictions between the two were provided earlier.

...let's make it one shared characteristic; creating the universe at the beginning of time. Now tell me again about the 'mountain' that you're going to stack up in front of that?

You cannot see the mountain for the pebble, so a pebble is enough: YHWH is Allah is Chiconahuiehecatl?

Hmmmm, so if God also has two thumbs (after all, it says humans are made 'in his image') Am would assert that God shares the 'essential qualities' of a monkey?

Another false statement, another false conclusion.

"Boonton is a monkey" is the conclusion required using your logic, not mine.

I have pointed out your reading does not appear to match the behavior of a significant portion of Muslims. Your explanations for this discrepancy are unconvincing.

No, you've demonstrated that words mean whatever you want them to mean until the false assertion in which they've been used is demolished.

As noted previously, your "significant portion of Muslims" is a "tiny minority of extremists" compared to the millions of Muslims who support Jihad with their bodies, words, wealth, ballot, and will.

I have pointed out respected scholars of the religion who have taken a radically different reading than you have throughout history. You have not addressed how this can be if your reading is so obviously the correct one.

Cherry-picking from a Wikipedia article statements convenient for your "argument" and ignoring the rest is not as strong a position as you'd like to imply.

What major schools of Islam reject Jihad against the Infidel to make the world Islam, again?

I have pointed out that all major religions require that their texts be read in context of the understandings and traditions that have built up around them. You have dismissed this objection and continue to embrace the idea that a 'sterile reading' can be accurate.

All religions consider certain doctrines beyond question. Heresy is defined as deviation from those clear doctrines. You've not provided any major Islamic tradition that rejects Jihad, Shari'a, and Dhimma.

Chris wrote:

This is especially true in Islam since the Koran is a confused document. And what do virtually all of the commentators claim about jihad warfare? They claim that it is required. They just provide different sets of when, where, and how it is allowed. History proves how it was originally interpreted.

Which Boonton characteristically distorted into:

Thank you for making my point. I agree that the Koran is a much more difficult document than the Bible both to read and understand.
Let's not forget, though, that our argument is whether or not a non-violent reading of Islam is possible.

Changing the argument again.

The argument has been whether or not Islam requires Jihad. That this is clear from Islam's "sacred" texts and history is dubious only to the ignorant and the deceitful.

Those who wish for a "non-violent reading of Islam" will always be disappointed by passages like: "...fight and slay the Pagans wherever ye find them, and seize them, beleaguer them, and lie in wait for them in every stratagem (of war)..." (Qur’an 9:5), "Fight those who believe not in Allah...nor acknowledge the religion of Truth, (even if they are) of the People of the Book, until they pay the Jizya with willing submission, and feel themselves subdued" (Qur'an 9:29), and, "A single endeavor of fighting in Allah’s Cause is better than the world and whatever is in it" (Bukhari Volume 4, Book 52, Number 50).

...historically both types of readings have prevailed at different times and places.

That Jihad has varied in intensity depending upon a variety of circumstances should not be confused for a justifiably "peaceful" reading of Islam.

Christianity was quite intolerant up until maybe a few hundred years ago...

That some Christians at some times and in some places were unjust is true. That their behavior was against Christ's commands is clear from--Christ's commands. (Or will you lie and say that some "Christians" were right in reading His command to "Love your enemy" as "Do whatever you want to your enemy, even if it causes him pain and humiliation"?)

...and the bulk of the effort to make it less intolerant did not come from good Christians themselves but ones that were either quite borderline (such as Thomas Jefferson) or openly hostile (our friend Voltaire).

That the (allegedly) "borderline" and "openly hostile" can change a religious body to which they belong only nominally (if at all) is silly. Christians practicing Christ's commands made the changes.

...All the major religions are consistent with those basic desires. If they were not then they would never have become a major religion. The religion of the terrorist, endless hate, endless violence against just about everyone (because even faithful Muslims will be ideologically impure in some way to the typical Islamist) does not make for a self-sustaining religion that is capable of handling millions of faithful.

But Allah says, "...kill the unbelievers wherever you find them" (Qur'an 9:5).

Am's "their either all terrorists or all ignorant of their faith" argument...

That false dichotomy is Boonton's argument.

...essentially fails no matter how much he quotes the Koran because a religion is always more than its scripture. Scripture must be read in context of how its believers follow it.

No, one can interpret a religion in the "context of how its believers follow it" (but that doesn't look good for Allah either).

Scripture must be read the way it is written, and Allah says, "Fight those who believe not in Allah nor the Last Day, nor hold that forbidden which hath been forbidden by Allah and His Messenger, nor acknowledge the religion of Truth, (even if they are) of the People of the Book, until they pay the Jizya with willing submission, and feel themselves subdued" (Qur'an 9:29).

Simply because it never says Jesus got married does not prove in itself that he never did.

Boonton's willing to speculate about what the Bible does not say, but unwilling to admit what Qur'an and Hadith do say. That's curious.

I wrote, "...you've demonstrated that words mean whatever you want them to mean until the false assertion in which they've been used is demolished," to which Boonton replied:

If I demonstrated that then there would be no point in debating the issue with you.

There is no point in debating since Boonton is unwilling to admit basic facts, and he repeatedly attributes to me his own (intentionally?) flawed arguments, employs a variety of logical fallacies, and redefines words mid-thread.

The best I could do is say words mean what you want them to mean and words mean what I want them to mean. You like coke and I like pepsi, there can be no real debate about subjective evaluations.

That is the best he can do.

What I demonstrated is that words, especially from ancient scriptural texts, have meaning that is not easy to derive.

No, Boonton has demonstrated "that words have meaning that is not easy to derive" for him. He is unwilling to approach the texts (and simple statements of fact) in an honest, consistent, and logical manner.

Even things that may seem simple are not necessarily so. We saw this with your assertion that seperation of Church and state is endorsed in the Bible....

Another misrepresentation. My assertion was that Christ taught of a distinction between the spiritual and civil realms. The "seperation of Church and state" to which Boonton refers is another matter.

...yet it oddly took Christian thinkers nearly two thousand years to realize it (and then only at the prompting of those hostile to orthodox Christianity).

Though I would prefer to discuss the doctrines of Christ (in this context, the Two Kingdoms), since Boonton appears eager to continue misusing the "Separation of Church and State," I will address that instead.

The "wall of separation" between Church and State was an assurance by Jefferson to some Danbury Baptists that the Federal government was prohibited from denying or limiting their God-given, unalienable right to religious Liberty. The wall was in place to limit the Federal government, not the Church.

On the subject of Church and State Jefferson also wrote:

"[N]o power over the freedom of religion...[is] delegated to the United States by the Constitution" (Kentucky Resolution, 1798).

"In matters of religion, I have considered that its free exercise is placed by the Constitution independent of the powers of the general [federal] government" (Second Inaugural Address, 1805).

"[O]ur excellent Constitution...has not placed our religious rights under the power of any public functionary" (Letter to the Methodist Episcopal Church, 1808).

"I consider the government of the United States as interdicted [prohibited] by the Constitution from intermeddling with religious institutions...or exercises" (Letter to Samuel Millar, 1808).

And neither was Jefferson "hostile to orthodox Christianity," as evidenced by his response to the Danbury Baptists and his reflection on the Source of American Liberty:

"I reciprocate your kind prayers for the protection and blessing of the common Father and Creator of man, and tender you for yourselves and your religious association assurances of my high respect and esteem."

"And can the liberties of a nation be thought secure if we have lost the only firm basis, a conviction in the minds of the people that these liberties are the gift of God? That they are not to be violated but with His wrath?"

That the Founding Fathers never intended free religious expression to be separated from public life is obvious also from the many official State Churches throughout America's early history. (And Jefferson also wrote, "...power to prescribe any religious exercise. . . . must rest with the States.")

Thanks to Americans ignorant of their own history and the subversion of Liberty by America's enemies within, the "Separation of Church and State" has come to mean the opposite of its original intent.

Cherry picking is sufficient to counter your argument.

That says a lot.

You're argument is...namely that no reading of Islam can both be Islamic and anti-violence.

Allah's argument is: "Fighting is prescribed for you, and ye dislike it. But it is possible that ye dislike a thing which is good for you, and that ye love a thing which is bad for you. But Allah knoweth, and ye know not" (Qur'an 2:216).

Traditional, Qur'anic Islam is "anti-violence" for the faithful Muslim. It is "anti-violence" for the subdued and humiliated Infidel living obediently as a dhimmi (if you don't include public humiliation and oppression as "violence," but watch out if you get out of line!). It is "anti-violence" (well, at least "non-violent") when in a position of weakness.

To refute such a point I only have to show that at least one respected Islamic thinker maintained as much.

To refute his own (false) point.

No, Boonton would have to show that the majority of traditional Islamic thought agreed with him, which it does not. The exception proves the rule.

And his lonely "respected Islamic thinker" (respected by whom?) is no match for Allah's (false) prophet who said, "A single endeavor of fighting in Allah’s Cause is better than the world and whatever is in it” (Bukhari Volume 4, Book 52, Number 50).

In other words, if you tell me there are no white elephants I only have to show you a single white elephant. That the book I pulled it out of may have twenty other pictures of gray elephants is of no importance.

Boonton has argued there are no white elephants. I've argued, "The book has twenty other pictures of gray elephants" (or, for the irony-impaired, "What does Allah and his apostle say?")

At least Boonton's finally admitted that mountains of contradictory evidence are irrelevant to him!

So Jefferson and Voltaire were not important contributors to our modern thinking of religious tolerance and respect for free speech?

Boonton's changed his argument--again. He earlier described them as reforming Christianity (despite all those pesky, ignorant, rebellious, intolerant Christians); now they're "important contributors to our modern thinking of religious tolerance and respect for free speech" (at least he's getting closer to the truth on this point).

I wonder, if Boonton keeps typing will he eventually end up admitting that Allah and his apostle require the fighting against, subduing and humiliating, and killing of non-Muslims to make the world Islam?

Or are you saying that these two were 'Christians practicing Christ's commands'?...If you do then you have, through the back door, allowed text to mean just about anything you want it to mean yourself.

At least this time Boonton had the decency to ask (even if it was rhetorical) before attributing his own non-sensical statement to me.

Of course, he's tried to slip in through the back door all along, which is why I've felt the need to point out the deceptions in his arguments.

The refrigerator door is closed, the lights are out, the eggs are cooling, the butter's gettin' hard, and the Jell-O's jigglin'.

Tuesday, March 7, 2006

Still denying the truth

Which can only mean trouble for the Infidel and Apostate. Here's more:
The reality of language is that while it is very hard to squeeze definite meaning from text it is also very hard to declare a text meaningless. Hence two sects can both have ideas about the meaning of their sacred texts that are contradictory.

It can be difficult to squeeze definite meaning from some text, but it is not too hard to find some texts meaningless.

So, we can't know what meaning(s) an author intends to convey? If so, then all attempts at communication are useless.

That some are unwilling or unable to accurately represent a particular text does not reflect on the text itself; it does reflect on those misrepresenting that text. The contradictory teachings within Christendom are not due to any sort of deficiency in the Biblical texts or to God's inability to express Himself coherently; they are the fault of those who (for their own reasons) add to or delete from His word. Jesus said, "Father...Your word is truth."

In the example cited here it was argued that the Sura 9 was a historical 'prep talk' to troops before an upcoming battle.

Maududi makes the point that the Jihad waged in conquering Arabia was expanding to the non-Muslim world.

More importantly, there is nothing in the text to limit the command to only that battle. That Mohammed and his followers understood the command was to conquer the non-Muslim world for Allah is evident from Islam's explosive expansion into non-Muslim lands upon the (false) prophet's death.

The apparent lack of violence in which some so desperately want to put their hope is only a lull between storms and only in lands where at this moment Islam is too weak to fight openly.

The objection you mounted was when do we know something is only in there for historical reference versus being an eternal commandment. The fact is we don't...

The clear words of Allah, the example of his (false) prophet, and one and one-half millennia of global jihad would indicate the "objection...mounted" comes from "moderate" Muslims and gullible Infidels wishing to re-interpret Islam in a way in which has never been understood.

if we did easily there would be no need for theologians, philosophers, commentators or educators in any of the three great monotheisms. You'd just have to give students the book and let them go.

Need for instruction is not evidence of ambiguous documentation. If learning any subject were as easy as "give the students the book and let them go," there would be no teachers.

Hmmmm so what to make of Jewish belief in the Old Testament? They do not believe God has a son so are they worshipping a different God?

Jews who believe the Old Testament but reject Jesus of Nazareth are, in spite of the clear testimony of the Law and Prophets, rejecting the promised Messiah. Jesus told His fellow Jews in response to their question, "Where is your father?" this: "You know neither me nor my Father. If you knew me, you would know my Father also" (John 8:19).

We've been down this road before. The best way to determine if one is referring to the same person is to note the most important qualities of the person in question. In Islam Allah is the God who created the universe and revealed himself to Abraham as the one and only God. These are the essential characteristics of God shared by all three major mono-religions (Judism, Christianity and Islam).

So, two shared characteristics mean the same identity, and the mountain of contradictory characteristics, words, and actions matter not at all? That's some careful analysis!

Limiting "essential qualities" to only two similarities (and ignoring hundreds of other contradictions) in order to arrive at one's predetermined outcome does not a strong argument make: "Boonton has thumbs and can use a keyboard. A monkey has thumbs and can use a keyboard. Therefore, Boonton is a monkey."

Since Christ said He is the Son of God, and Allah said he has no son, it is silly to claim that both Christ and Allah are the same god.

When Christians protest something they find offensive are they 'subduing' non-Christians?

Of course! Christians are always rioting, burning, and killing over cartoons!

Since subdue means to "conquer and subjugate; vanquish, quiet or bring under control by physical force or persuasion; make tractable," if Christians were to successfully intimidate others into silence using death threats, promises of terrorism, and actual violence, then "subdue" would be an appropriate term.

Since Islam commands the subduing and humiliating of the People of the Book, and Muslim violence and the threat of violence are clearly intimidating Western non-Muslims into silence over the cartoons, "subdue" is rightly applied here.

Our point of concern is violence, not advocacy. As I pointed out one has a right to advocate that everyone should be a particular religion, or even that the law should be changed to be religious rather than secular.

Again, Muslim threats of murder and terrorism being excused as "advocating" civil rights, when in fact they are threats of murder and terrorism is immoral.

On whether Am is smarter than Muslims: More ad hominem.
First an ad hominem attack is one that is based on personal insult. My "On the strange fact that Am. seems to know more about Islam than Muslims" is not a personal insult.

When speaking of logical fallacies, argumentum ad hominem refers to attacking the person rather than their argument in an attempt to discredit the argument. It in no way reflects on the merits of the argument itself.

It applies here because there's been no addressing Islam's "sacred" texts commanding (and praising) Jihad against the Infidel or its fourteen hundred years of carrying out those commands.

Second it is perfectly fair to ask this point. Does Am really speak with authority on Islam? It is not unreasonable to note that one must do more to know a religion than simply read its sacred text (or selected parts of it) and go from there. All major religions have built up a huge volumn of traditions and commentaries that make such simple readings hazardous.

How can one accuse me of falsehood when one unacquainted with Islam's authoritative texts, history, and tradition hasn't engaged in even "simple (but hazardous) readings"?

There's been no demonstration that I've misrepresented Qur'an, Hadith, or fourteen hundred years of Jihad, Shari'a, and Dhimma.

At this point one needs to remind ourselves what the argument is. The argument is not that there are violenct schools of Islamic thought. The argument put forth is that any Islamic school of thought must be violent because the violence i fundamental to Islam and no school of thought could be both non-violent and Islamic.

Says Boonton. But Mohammed said, "O ye who believe! what is the matter with you, that, when ye are asked to go forth in the cause of Allah, ye cling heavily to the earth? Do ye prefer the life of this world to the Hereafter? But little is the comfort of this life, as compared with the Hereafter. Unless ye go forth, He will punish you with a grievous penalty..." (Qur'an 9:38, 39).

What major schools of Islam reject Jihad against the Infidel as heresy? What major schools of Islam reject Surah 9 as false revelation?

In that case the fact that the US Muslim population is only a small portion of the world's Muslims is irrelevant. 2 million is more than enough to not be some bizaar splinter group.

So, two million people are enough to make their truth claims on Allah's will valid.

Using that logic, the millions of Muslims around the world who support (even lionize) bin Laden are "not some bizaar splinter group." Neither are the millions of Muslims who democratically aid Islamic terrorists to power in "Palestine" and Egypt. And the millions of Muslims who in poll after poll express their desire for more terrorism against the United States and Israel must also be an accurate representation of Islam.

Allah's word and his messenger's example are clear. The Infidel dismisses it to his own harm (and the harm of those he loves).

Then they would be leaving Islam but your suggestion is positively bizaar. They keep going to services, keep reading the Koran...yet don't want to know what their religion is?

Making unsupported claims about Western Muslims and attributing them to me is not sportsmanlike. I have not suggested Western (especially American) Muslims attend mosque and read Qur'an regularly. Even if they did (what evidence of this exists?), there are a number of other reasons for refraining from open violence here.

Ok, but this would be like Christian ignorance that Christ rose from the dead. Imagine a Christian that was ignorant of this but reads the Bible and attends Church services and even reads Christian articles/commentary but for some reason 'avoids' that fact because it makes him uncomfortable. Out of the hundreds of millions of Christians I'm sure you might find such a creature but millions of them? Nope, not on your life.

Here again is the false implication that Western Muslims who refrain from violence do so only because they are ignorant of Islam's texts, traditions, and history.

There are also commands not to use violence, are they irrelevant simply because they came before Sura 9 and were 'repealed' by it?

What commands? Surah and ayah, please. Does Wiki "delve" that deeply?

There are Qur'anic commands for cooperation with non-Muslims. There is a verse that speaks of "no compulsion in religion."

Unfortunately for Infidel and Apostate, as Mohammed's political and military power grew, so did Allah's belligerence. Over the course of Allah's revelations to Mohammed warfare evolved from cooperation, to allowing defensive war, to requiring defensive war, to finally requiring offensive war. This explains why Mohammed said things like:

"Fighting is prescribed for you, and ye dislike it. But it is possible that ye dislike a thing which is good for you, and that ye love a thing which is bad for you. But Allah knoweth, and ye know not" (Qur'an 2:216).
“A single endeavor of fighting in Allah’s Cause is better than the world and whatever is in it” (Bukhari Volume 4, Book 52, Number 50).
"Not equal are those believers who sit (at home) and receive no hurt, and those who strive and fight in the cause of Allah with their goods and their persons. Allah hath granted a grade higher to those who strive and fight with their goods and persons than to those who sit (at home)...But those who strive and fight Hath He distinguished above those who sit (at home) by a special reward..." (Qur'an 4:95).
“A man came to Allah’s Apostle and said, ‘Instruct me as to such a deed as equals Jihad in reward.’ He replied, ‘I do not find such a deed’” (Bukhari Volume 4, Book 52, Number 44).
"Say to [those]...who lagged behind: "Ye shall be summoned (to fight) against a people given to vehement war: then shall ye fight, or they shall submit. Then if ye show obedience, Allah will grant you a goodly reward, but if ye turn back as ye did before, He will punish you with a grievous Penalty. No blame is there on the blind, nor is there blame on the lame, nor on one ill (if he joins not the war)...and he who turns back, (Allah) will punish him with a grievous Penalty" (Qur'an 48:16, 17).
"O ye who believe! what is the matter with you, that, when ye are asked to go forth in the cause of Allah, ye cling heavily to the earth? Do ye prefer the life of this world to the Hereafter? But little is the comfort of this life, as compared with the Hereafter. Unless ye go forth, He will punish you with a grievous penalty, and put others in your place; but Him ye would not harm in the least. For Allah hath power over all things" (Qur'an 9:38, 39).

Boonton continued...

If so then why were they even put in the Koran? Wouldn't putting such no longer relevant orders in it serve to confuse those trying to follow it?

Yes. This question exemplifies a dangerous misunderstanding under which many Westerners operate: Islam is not like Christianity. The Bible is consistent. Qur'an is not. (And this inconsistency is another evidence of Christ and Allah being very different deities.)

It is confusing until the Doctrine of Abrogation is understood. (Ordering Qur'an's surahs by length and not by topic or in chronological order can also be difficult for the novice).

And this was not the only time Allah gave certain "revelations" that just happened to fit Mohammed's circumstances (and lusts): divorce for wives who complained about a new "interest," one-fifth of all the spoils of war going to him, and Allah ordaining his raping of his nine-year-old "wife" Aisha are three examples.

Or perhaps the orders apply in certain situations, such as in a religious war. Situations that do not necessarily have to happen (in other words, a Muslim must fight for other Muslims in a religious war but there is no obligation to start a religious war when non-exists).

But what does Allah say? What did his apostle say and do?

Allowing for defensive war and commands for offensive war are both found in Qur'an.

Monday, March 6, 2006

Logical fallacies do nothing to slow Jihad

The latest round from EO:

Rather than address the facts in this discussion, Boonton has misrepresented my (and others') positions, employed logical fallacies (including, but not limited to: ad hominem, tu quoque, non sequitur, red herring, and straw man arguments), and resorted to false analogies and unsubstantiated allegations to support his claims.

This is so frequent as to seem intentional.

In response to, "Western 'leaders' denounced the cartoons. Western editors have been fired and major media have refused to print or air the cartoons (out of "respect" for Islam)," Boonton replied,

This is not terrorism....

A non sequitur (and redundant), since, I cited the Cartoon Jihad as a means other than terrorism by which Islam seeks to accomplish its goal of subduing non-Muslims and making the world Islam.

But if you're going to have laws prohibiting insulting people's races or religions then one cannot be offended that Muslims want their cut of identity politics.

Excusing rabid charges of "Death to those who insult Islam!" and "...your 9/11 is coming!" as the reasonable expression of the desire for equal treatment under the law is immoral (and suicidal).

On the strange fact that Am. seems to know more about Islam than Muslims:

More ad hominem.

Again the argument that since millions of Muslims are not currently engaged in actual warfare and/or terrorism against non-Muslims, Allah must not require it and Jihad must not be a central part of Islam. This in spite of Allah's clearly commanding it, Islam's history of violence against the Infidel and Apostate, and the millions of Muslims expressing support for Islamic terrorism/jihad at the ballot box and in opinion polls.

“A man came to Allah’s Apostle and said, ‘Instruct me as to such a deed as equals Jihad in reward.’ He replied, ‘I do not find such a deed’” (Bukhari Volume 4, Book 52, Number 44).

No, you did not say that this was some obscure passage in the Koran that many Muslims might be ignorant of. You said this was 'obvious' and even a person totally unschooled in Islam could catch it from reading translated passages. Not only that, you've previous argued that Sura 9 is one of the most important passages being one of the later ones! If this was the only rational meaning then mass ignorance is simply not a viable argument.

Actually, I wrote, "...I have not argued that all Muslims believe a certain way, I have argued that Islam's god and prophet require Jihad against the Infidel, which is obvious when you examine their texts."

As far as "mass ignorance" in concerned, in an October 29, 2001 article Daniel Pipes wrote, "...two authoritative studies carried out by scholars found that American Muslims number under 2 million - less than a third of the hitherto-consensus number." If that figure is doubled for 2006, the percentage of the world's 1.2 billion Muslims in the United States is only 0.33%.

Assuming all U.S. Muslims are ignorant of Allah's commands for Jihad in Qur'an and Hadith (which most assuredly is untrue), is it unreasonable to suggest that less than half of one percent of the adherents of a religion are unfamiliar with their religion's authoritative texts? What percentage of American Christians are Biblically-illiterate? Ten-percent? Fifty-percent? How many more are willing to compromise on essential Biblical teachings regarding Creation, abortion, and homosexuality?

I do not doubt that many American Muslims want to avoid knowing Qur'an and Hadith. After watching a news story about more Islamic terrorism with a man who came to the U.S. from Iran two decades ago, he lamented, "I don't know why they do that." I replied, "Because Qur'an commands it. And they would consider you an unbeliever." He said nothing more, but looked pained.

This would indeed be like Jews being ignorant of Moses or Christians Christ.

Muslim ignorance of Mohammed would be equivalent to Christian ignorance of Christ.

You're telling me that Muslims could be so ignorant of what you're saying is so essential to their texts?

That Jihad is essential to traditional Islam is a matter of fact established by the clear words of Allah, the words and deeds of his apostle, and the history of Islam.

Here again is the effort to make the lack of widespread Muslim violence in the West evidence of Allah's not requiring it, despite clear textual evidence to the contrary. Boonton's taken one (charitable) explanation for why decent, Western Muslims follow such a god (ignorance of Qur'an and Sunnah) and twisted it into an argument that the commands don't exist.

What's next? Christian sin as proof that Christ doesn't command holiness?

Bin Laden is not a stupid man, he even visited Western nations. He did not expect any mass conversion to islam. He most likely wanted what you're giving him. A war on Islam by the west that he could exploit to unite Arabs under a single banner.

I'm giving him? I wish I had known sooner I was president.

Mohammed is not around to ask.

Actually, “Muhammad said, ‘A single endeavor of fighting in Allah’s Cause is better than the world and whatever is in it’” (Bukhari Volume 4, Book 52, Number 50).

I've provided you with a long list of various Muslim's who have written about what Jihad means....

Long list? Where? I must have missed it since I was citing what Allah and Mohammed said.

Even for those inclined to your meaning of Jihad....

Allah's meaning of Jihad, as is clear from his Qur'an and Mohammed's exposition and example.

...there's a much broader meaning that includes both advocating Islam to non-believers as well as the internal struggle against sin in one's own life.

That there are other meanings does not negate the fact that the martial use is the one found throughout Qur'an and Hadith.

You nicely illustrate how the same text can be read in two different ways...On the other hand obeying 'God-ordained authorities' was used to argue for the 'Divine right of Kings'. As I pointed out if "seperation of Church and State" was obvious from the Bible it certainly took Christians a long time to figure it out.

Boonton nicely illustrates how the same text can be misread (or ignored altogether) to suit one's purposes.

The two [Allah and YHWH] are one in the same.

Only one ignorant of either the Bible or Qur'an (or both) can make such a statement.

If you read a Bible in Arabic (and there are Arabic Christians who, believe it or not, read Arabic Bibles just as we read English ones) the word used for God will be Allah...But for someone who chides me for not doing enough research I'd think you'd do better than deploy the old Jack Chick argument here.

There are Arabic Christians? They have Bibles? They read? Christ and Allah must be the same deity because Arabic-speaking Christians and Arabic-speaking Muslims use the same noun for both? What's next, Baal is Vishnu is Donald Trump? But they're all 'gods' in English!

It appears that not only does Boonton possess an intricate knowledge of ancient Middle Eastern religious texts, he is also an Arabic grammarian. Or, he is confusing the most simplistic and superficial explanation for the truth.

A little "delving" on this topic might reveal that using the same noun in two different contexts for two different deities does not mean the deities are the same one. The proper name for God in any Bible translated into English is YHWH. His Son's name translated into English is Jesus, the Messiah. That Mohammed used the traditional Arabic word for god (used by Christians centuries before Mohammed) does not mean they are the same God, just that Mohammed spoke Arabic (and perhaps, that he was trying to make his new religion palatable to Jews, Christians, and the pagans of Arabia).

The two religions' authoritative texts reveal the two cannot be the same god:

-Christ says He is the Son of God. Allah said he has no son and that anyone who says he does is a blasphemer.
-Christ says, "Love your enemies." Allah said, "...kill the unbelievers wherever you find them."
-Christ never sinned. Allah justified Mohammed's murdering, thieving, enslaving, and raping (even of a nine-year-old girl).

If Boonton is right, his god is either intentionally deceitful, so mentally unstable as to be unable to keep his story straight, or unable to preserve the integrity of his revelations.

The argument that was asserted is that Muslims who take their religion serious must believe their duty to God is to kill non-believers....

Allah commands the fighting against, subduing and humiliating, and killing Infidels "until all religion is for Allah." Mohammed fought against, subdued and humiliated, and killed Infidels in obedience to Allah. A devout Muslim must obey Allah and imitate Mohammed.

...therefore we must assume Muslims 'guilty until proven innocent'

No, we should expect that Muslims will obey their god and (false) prophet. To imply that Muslims are "guilty" for obeying Allah is not very tolerant, is it?

The problem with this is that ample evidence has been presented that many Muslims share alternative readings of their texts than one would take at first glance....

A couple of lines from a questionable article containing a good deal of contradictory material (as noted by Chris) is ample evidence?

This is relevant because it does not show that a serious Muslim must abide by the readings of Bin Laden and Amillennialist (I wonder if our friend realizes that his stuff would make excellent literature for Al Qaeda; "want to be a good Muslim, then you must help us kill people").

Again, it's not my "stuff," it's Allah's: "...fight and slay the Pagans wherever ye find them, and seize them, beleaguer them, and lie in wait for them in every stratagem (of war)...." (Qur’an 9:5).

What is important here is that there is nothing special about the Muslim religion that makes it any more dangerous than any other.

Nothing but the universal command to "...fight them on until...there prevail...faith in Allah altogether and everywhere...." (Qur'an 8:39).

So Chris and Amillennialist know more about Islam than Ijaz does?

Allah's words, Mohammed's example, and Islam's history are all available to the Infidel with an ISP. Even Mansoor admits the Qur'anic texts on Jihad and Jew-hating. He just wants to limit those passages in a way traditional Islam has never limited them.

The text(s) for any serious religion are complicated and often interpreted in manners that often seem to contradict a common sense first glance reading.

Which has not been demonstrated with Qur'an and Hadith. Indeed, Boonton's only demonstrated that for him, English is "complicated and often interpreted in manners that often seem to contradict a common sense first glance reading."

Without getting into a debate over whether we should be reading the author's intent or our response to the text...

Yes, since a subjective approach to 9:5 would sound something like, "What does '...kill the unbelievers wherever you find them' mean to you?"

the fact remains if these were repair manuals then the job of theologians would have been done in two or three weeks. Yet, in fact, thousands of years later they still type away.

Which of course does not mean that those theologians are necessarily contradicting their religion's authoritative texts.

If, as Boonton would have us believe, their work implies a continued reinterpretation of established meaning, then Augustine, Luther, and Graham must be contradicting Christ's commands also, right?

In Judiasm the commentaries of the theologians (Rabbis) have even become their own type of sacred scripture. Needless to say the Catholic tradition has its own clear understanding that one needs to do more than just read the Bible to avoid error. While many non-Catholics may scoff at this the Protestant tradition hardly dispenses with the work of great commentators whether you're talking about Saint Augustine or just Billy Graham.

Of course, Augustine, Luther, and Graham are essential for understanding that when Jesus says, "Obey My commands," He really means, "Do whatever this really means to you."

Actually it nicely demonstrates my case. No doubt those sects will tell you that they are faithful to the text of the Bible.

But they're demonstrably wrong.

They almost certainly will be honest in the sense that they honestly believe their view is endorsed by the text.

But they're honestly wrong.

...Yet you're shocked at the suggestion your reading of jihad....

Allah's reading of Jihad, since he says, "O ye who believe! fight the unbelievers who gird you about, and let them find firmness in you: and know that Allah is with those who fear Him" (Qur'an 9:123).

...any Muslim who doesn't agree must either be ignorant of the Koran or secretly be rejecting it?

Or waiting. Or afraid. Or any number of other reasons. It depends on the individual. None of which changes the words of Allah and the example of Mohammed.

Except for the fact that the vast bulk of Muslims do not seem to be supporting offensive jihad, seem to refrain from exercising it even when they could do so with minimal chance of getting caught or suffering harm.

"Seem." As noted previously, there are a number of ways to aid Jihad, and a number of reasons for not acting at a particular time. (Not to mention the support expressed for Jihad/terrorism by millions around the world.)

It strains credibility to excuse this disconnect of your theory with the facts by saying they just may not have realized what the Koran says or may be waiting for the 'right time' to pounce.

"Allah's" theory. This alleged "disconnect" does not change his words or Mohammed's example.

I'm pointing out that there are perfectly valid readings of the Koran that do not reach the conclusions you say they do.

No valid alternative readings of 9:5 and others have been demonstrated. All that has been noted (and I've not seen anyone disagree with this) is that the word "jihad" does have alternative meanings. Amazingly enough, there are a few English words that also have more than one meaning.

Perhaps Boonton can "delve" into his Wiki and consult his "long list" of Muslim scholars on what major schools of Islamic thought reject Surah 9 and the call for offensive warfare against the Infidel to make the world Islam as a false revelation?

Unlike his conspiracy theories, there is nothing secret about Allah's commands and the example of his (false) prophet. Qur'an, Hadith, and Sira are all freely available to Muslim and non-Muslim alike.

More to the point have you shown us that the Wikipedia quotes came from scholars who were not writing for Muslim audiences?

Chris noted the contradictions to Boonton's selective citations. More to the point, instead of addressing Allah's commands for Jihad against the Infidel, Boonton resorts to setting up straw men and red herrings.

I'm not sure what you're complaining about. You get all huffy because I point out it is pretty hard to believe many Muslims are ignorant of the Koran.

Qur'anic-illiteracy was offered as one of several explanations for the relative lack of Islamic violence in the West (in America, at least).

Apparently, Boonton would rather interpret the (relative) absence of violence as the absence of the Commands, a belief so contrary to the evidence as to be inexplicable.

The assertion that Jihad is not an essential doctrine in Islam is clearly and forever discredited by Allah and his apostle.

If those that are don't talk about it how do they go about converting people?

"Hi, Infidel. Become a Muslim. By the way, you'll have to kill for Allah when called upon." That will appeal to prospective converts.

If those educating others about Islam neglect to mention a key doctrine then it will cease to be part of Islam.

Unfortunately, many of those educating others about Islam do mention it. Even worse (for the Infidel), they have the clear words of Allah and his apostle to justify their teaching. Qur'an and Sunnah always leads to Jihad.

It's interesting, when presented in digest form, how your words dovetail with the agenda of people like Bin Laden.

It's interesting how Boonton's words dovetail with Jihad's apologists practicing taqiyya to deceive gullible Infidels. To anyone who's "delved" into Qur'an, Hadith, and Sira, the reason for the similarity should be obvious.

Note above the implication; if a person of good will will be so disgusted then logically they would have to give up being a Muslim.

Many people endure, excuse, ignore, rationalize, or deny unpleasant truths. It doesn't seem unreasonable that decent Muslims might also do this.

I could buy this except for the fact that secret conspiracies fall apart as you add more people.

Apart from stubbornly ignorant and morally-blind Infidels, the West's ignorance of Jihad is crumbling. More and more non-Muslims are becoming aware of Allah's will for them.

The 'secrets' of Scientologists and Freemasons, for example, can be plucked for free from hundreds of web sites.

The words of Allah and his (false) prophet are available for free from hundreds of Islamic web sites. All it takes is the courage to examine them.

Avenging the Ummah

But I thought you had to be poor and oppressed to take up Jihad. Islamic terrorism at the University of North Carolina (thanks to Chris):
"Mohammed Reza Taheri-azar, 22, is charged with nine counts of assault with a deadly weapon with intent to cause bodily injury. Police say he drove an SUV through a crowd of students gathered at The Pit. Six people were treated at the hospital for minor injuries. Three others refused treatment at the scene.

Derek Poarch, chief of the university's police department, confirmed Saturday that Taheri-azar, a native of Iran, told investigators he wanted to 'avenge the deaths or murders of Muslims around the world.'

A group of UNC students plans to rally at The Pit from 11 a.m. to 1 p.m. Monday to protest the attack. They will hand out small American flags. Speakers are scheduled to condemn religious violence. College Republicans, Americans for an Informed Democracy and the Foundation for the Defense of Democracies are the main sponsors of the event."

Wednesday, March 1, 2006

Moderate Muslim Media Manipulation

Hoping to present a "moderate" Islamic face to America, Mansoor Ijaz discusses the possibility of reformation within Islam.

The only problem is that, like the Christian Reformation, an Islamic reformation will only result in a return to Qur'an, Hadith, and Sira, and that is always bad for the Infidel and Apostate.

From EO:

Gordon,

...I see no inherent conflict in taking the Koran--as you do the Bible--as a system of spiritual guidance under the laws of the United States of America....

Christ makes clear a separation between the civil and spiritual kingdoms; Islam requires rule over every aspect of life. This is why Christianity can exist peacefully under every form of just government; Islam will only exist peacefully when it is the government.

...the problem with Islam today is a failure of its true believers to stand up for the message on its principles....

Principles like these?

"...fight and slay the Pagans wherever ye find them..." (Qur’an 9:5)
"Fight those who believe not in Allah nor the Last Day, nor hold that forbidden which hath been forbidden by Allah and His Messenger, nor acknowledge the religion of Truth, (even if they are) of the People of the Book, until they pay the Jizya with willing submission, and feel themselves subdued" (Qur'an 9:29).
"...fight them on until there is no more tumult or oppression, and there prevail justice and faith in Allah altogether and everywhere...." (Qur'an 8:39).
“A man came to Allah’s Apostle and said, ‘Instruct me as to such a deed as equals Jihad in reward.’ He replied, ‘I do not find such a deed’” (Bukhari Volume 4, Book 52, Number 44).
"O ye who believe! what is the matter with you, that, when ye are asked to go forth in the cause of Allah, ye cling heavily to the earth? Do ye prefer the life of this world to the Hereafter? But little is the comfort of this life, as compared with the Hereafter. Unless ye go forth, He will punish you with a grievous penalty...." (Qur'an 9:38, 39).
“Allah’s Apostle said, ‘I have been made victorious with terror....’” (Bukhari Volume 4, Book 52, Number 220).
"The punishment of those who wage war against Allah and His Messenger, and strive with might and main for mischief through the land is: execution, or crucifixion, or the cutting off of hands and feet from opposite sides, or exile from the land: that is their disgrace in this world, and a heavy punishment is theirs in the Hereafter..." (Qur'an 5:33).
"Whoever changed his Islamic religion, then kill him" (Bukhari Volume 9, Book 84, Number 57).
"War is deceit" (Bukhari Volume 4, Book 52, Number 268).
“Allah’s Apostle told Aisha [his six-year-old bride and nine-year-old sexual "partner"], ‘You were shown to me twice in my dreams. I beheld a man or angel carrying you in a silken cloth. He said to me, “She is yours, so uncover her.” And behold, it was you. I would then say to myself, “If this is from Allah, then it must happen”’” (Bukhari Volume 9, Book 87, Number 139-40).

Are these the "teachings and life examples given by Islam's Prophet Muhammed" Mansoor doesn't want anyone misinterpreting?

I wonder why?

Islam does not need reformation, its followers do. It is their hypocrisy in politicizing Allah's message....

Islam is a political message. It divides the world into two lands: Dar al-Islam and Dar al-Harb, the Lands of Islam and of War. (Guess where we are?)

...Muslims...cannot get past their own internal demons of anger and animosity when they see how we treat them in our press and how we portray their religion and their prophet in our judeo-Christian world.

Blame the victim.

That's why:

-Muslims behead Indonesian Christian schoolgirls.
-Muslims rape and massacre schoolchildren in Beslan.
-Muslims blow up tourists in Bali, worshipers in Tel Aviv, commuters in Madrid and London, and people going about their business on sunny New York mornings.
-Muslims go into a village, ask the women if they're Christian or Muslim, then rape, slice off the breasts of, and leave for dead in the middle of town Sudanese Christian women.
-Muslims kidnap, rape, forcibly convert, and then tell the fathers of Egyptian Copts their daughters are "safe in the arms of Islam now."
-Muslims kidnapped, enslaved, and forcibly converted to Islam European boys for centuries.
-Muslims kidnapped, emasculated, and enslaved untold numbers of African boys for over a millennium.
-Muslims committed genocide against millions of Armenians and Hindus.

It's all because we are so insensitive!

They--who have nothing--then feel they have no alternatives left but to rise up against us with anger and hatred on that "NO WAY OUT" road to paradise.

The road provided by Allah, by the way.

This need not be, but it is us with the greater understanding and knowledge, and the material resources to do something about it, that will have to help reformist Muslims spark the reformation of Islam from within....

In other words, "Give us your money and maybe we'll not kill you."

Almost every single passage in the Koran...that has to do with the killing/maiming/go kill the Jews stuff, or whatever other phraseology there is in the Koran which non-Muslims believe is derogatory and anti-human....

We only "believe" that "kill the Jews stuff" is "derogatory and anti-human." At least he admits it's there (someone tell Boonton).

...the bin Laden's and Zawahiri's and Zarqawi's of the world have succeeded in dredging up the anger harbored inside otherwise docile Muslim followers by harking back to a time that has no relationship whatsoever to modern day realities....

He's setting limits Allah doesn't set. Allah will not be pleased.

...but what God has ordained in the Koran (some of which was only for that time and some of which was for all times), they turn around and blame us, and then use the only tool they have available that has any authority whatsoever, the Koran, to fan their flames of hatred. On top of that, they misuse modern technology fueled by the petrodollars of Wahhabists who seek to turn the clock back to spread their hatred like wildfire.

At least he acknowledges that Qur'an does teach warfare against the Infidel. The problem is, since Allah's commands for fighting against, subduing and humiliating, and killing the Infidel do not have the expiration dates he claims they do, this "moderate" is going to have a hard time convincing his co-religionists of his position.

In short, there is such a thing as a moderate/reformist muslim, who looks to the more irenic principles in the Quran and nuslim traditions more widely, for his inspiration. The use of the idea of temporal relevance vs principles for all time may be a way forward.

How will the "reformers" ("apostates"?) be able to convince their fellow Muslims when Islam's "sacred" texts do not limit Jihad to the seventh century?

I suspect that the issue of the principles of interpretation that led more radical muslims to their hard line stance, on the strength of a lot of muslim history, are more flexible than either the UBLS or this world or some of those who are inclined to take the statments on the strength of UBL etc's reading, perceive.

Allah doesn't allow for flexibility. You cannot have Islam apart from Qur'an, Hadith, and Sira. You cannot have Islam apart from Mohammed.

To encourage reform rather than radicalisation is the challenge before us. On that I submit that defeat of the radicals, backed up by sustained will to hold such militancy in check is where it's at.

Mohammed said Islam cannot change. Since Allah's commands for warfare are clear and immutable, whom do you think the general Muslim population will find more persuasive, Mohammed or the "reformers"?

Then, encouragement of democratisation will give hope for a better future -- ordinatry people are seldom radicals and so whent hey are empowered it will moderate the tendencies to militancy.

Islam allows only for the rule of Allah, not the rule of men. Democracy will succeed in the Muslim world only to the degree that a particular population rejects the rule of Islam.

One step in that is the consistent exposure and shaming before the world of the indefensible acts of the militants.

That will persuade Muslims-In-Name-Only, but not the devout, since Allah commands those acts.

That should be linked to a deliberate encouragement of a debate on reformation.

"I heard the Prophet saying...'Far removed (from mercy), far removed (from mercy), those who changed (the religion) after me!'" (Bukhari Volume 9, Book 88, Number 174).

A true Muslim

In the religious sphere, one can determine one's orthodoxy by comparing that person's words and actions to what their authoritative texts say and to what their religion's founder said and did.

In Christianity, the Ideal is Christ. Christians will say and do what Jesus said and did. In Islam, it is Mohammed. Muslims will do what he said and did.

More on what makes a "true" Muslim:

Eric & Lisa,

Rather confusing, I had hoped for more clear talk from you. On the one hand you say that your opinion matters not at all, on the other hand you tell us your opinion of Joseph Smith's teachings by calling them imaginings.

You asked my opinion on whether or not your relatives were Christians. Who can speak to that authoritatively, Christ or me? Obviously, Christ.

Since Joseph Smith's religion contradicts Christ's Word, his must be in error. Rather than attribute intentional, deliberate evil to him, I gave him the benefit of the doubt and characterized his heresy as gently as I could.

We agree on that but maybe you attempted to dodge the question because you see where I am going with this?

It seemed you were fishing, but since I would not presume to know where you were going, I answered only what you asked.

Many people who would call themselves Christian, like Mormon's, do not follow after the same Christ that me and you do.

How do you know? By comparing their (and our) words and actions to the Word of Christ.

Nevertheless, for whatever reason, they wish to be known as Christians. Their are those who call themselves Christian, but they are prostitutes and not willing to repent, the same for homosexuals, adulterers, idoloters, etc.

Every Christian breaks God's law.

The same is true for those who would call themselves Muslim.

What we call ourselves matters little in questions of what we are. A person's orthodoxy can only be determined by comparing their doctrine and deeds to their religion's authoritative texts.

They do not follow after Mohammed's teachings, instead, they try and co-opt his teachings to fit their own worldview. They ignore the lines they disagree with, or re-interpret them in order to make the belief system more palatable. These Muslims we would call Moderate. In my view, this is the majority of Muslims.

I hope you are right.

Many Christians also do this.

The ones we call Radical muslims are the ones who are actually following after the teachings of Mohammed, the teachings that you have so convincingly shared with us here.

That is one point I've been trying to make.

But one thing ive learned as a Christian. Just because Christ told us what to do does not mean that those who would claim to be His followers will do as He has commanded.
The same must be true for Mohammedism.

I agree. The trouble for Infidels is that some "moderate" or nominal Muslims will, under the proper set of circumstances, "radicalize."

How can you determine who will do this? How can you prevent it from occurring? How many who would not actually take up arms still aid their co-religionists against us? Who among the "moderates" will resist the implementations of Shari'a and Dhimma?

Apart from a clear, public renunciation of Jihad, Shari'a, and Dhimma, in what can an Infidel put their confidence?

ANNO DOMINI 2003-2026

the Amillennialist Contra Mundum