Featured Post

In Defense of the West

When I first began this site, it was with the intention of arguing politics, evolution, and Christian apologetics, topics I found myself add...

Thursday, November 29, 2007

In response to the Annapolis Atrocity and another ignorant and gullible Infidel advancing Islam

Why do so many who would be among the first to be forced into conversion or decapitation defend the ideology of their demise?

From here:
I sent the following to the Saudi embassy and Cc'd it to President Bush, Vice-President Cheney, Rush, Hannity, Glenn Beck, and Hugh Hewitt.

This is the reason there will be no peace between Islam and Israel. It is an infidel state on land once controlled by Allah, and once Allah's, always Allah's:
Sirs,

No decent, rational human being can consider the evil cited below to be the will of a god.

Inexplicably, the President of the United States of America -- a man who claims for himself the title "Christian" -- appeases and calls "ally" some of those who consider such excrement to be "divine." He defends their depravity, even equating such vile filth with the Ten Commandments and the Sermon on the Mount in an Inaugural Address!

(Jefferson and Adams -- two men whose Islamic counterparts were much more honest about their "sacred" right to Infidel blood than are today's Muslim leaders -- would be disgusted to see such craven dishonesty from the leader of the nation they helped create.)

No less shamefully, those pretend defenders of Western Civilization -- lions behind microphones except when it comes to telling the truth about Qur'an and Sunnah -- do the same.

This is the will of Allah and the example of Mohammed. This is what you defend:
"...fight and slay the Pagans wherever ye find them . . . " (Qur'an 9:5).

"Fight in the name of Allah and in the way of Allah. Fight against those who disbelieve in Allah. Make a holy war . . . When you meet your enemies who are polytheists, invite them to three courses of action . . . Invite them to (accept) Islam . . . If they refuse to accept Islam, demand from them the Jizya . . . If they refuse to pay the tax, seek Allah's help and fight them . . . " (Muslim Book 019, Number 4294).

"Fight those who believe not in Allah . . . nor acknowledge the religion of Truth, (even if they are) of the People of the Book, until they pay the Jizya with willing submission, and feel themselves subdued" (Qur'an 9:29).

"Allah's Apostle said: 'I have been ordered (by Allah) to fight against the people until they testify that none has the right to be worshipped but Allah and that Muhammad is Allah's Apostle . . . '" (Bukhari Volume 1, Book 2, Number 24).

"Allah's Apostle said, 'I have been made victorious with terror. The treasures of the world were brought to me and put in my hand'" (Bukhari Volume 4, Book 52, Number 220).

"My mother came to me while I was being swung on a swing between two branches and got me down. My nurse took over and wiped my face with some water and started leading me. When I was at the door she stopped so I could catch my breath. I was brought in while Muhammad was sitting on a bed in our house. My mother made me sit on his lap. The other men and women got up and left. The Prophet consummated his marriage with me in my house when I was nine years old" (Tabari 9:131).

"Allah's Apostle told Aisha [his six-year-old bride and nine-year-old sexual "partner"], 'You were shown to me twice in my dreams. I beheld a man or angel carrying you in a silken cloth. He said to me, "She is yours, so uncover her." And behold, it was you. I would then say to myself, "If this is from Allah, then it must happen"'" (Bukhari Volume 9, Book 87, Number 139-140).

"War is deceit" (Bukhari Volume 4, Book 52, Number 268).
One who likes to indulge in logical fallacies responded. Here's my answer:
That's impressive, Norman Blitzer.

A false moral equivalence between YHWH and Allah easily refutable by anyone who can read, a tu quoque argument, and an appeal to authority contradicting your previous point -- all in one brief post.

The passages from Qur'an and Sunnah I cited make "divine" pedophilia, lying, terrorism, and offensive warfare against all non-Muslims who refuse to submit to the tyranny of Allah.

The Biblical passages you cite do not.

The first was a limited, one-time command in the context of Israel's on-going wars under their first king against a nation that had harmed it, not a command for offensive warfare to make the world Hebrew.

The second, the punishment for Hebrews under the Mosaic Covenant, not a command for offensive warfare to make the world Israel.

The third, protections for a daughter in a world in which slavery was commonplace. No commands to enslave Gentiles nor for offensive warfare to make the world Hebrew.

The last, more accommodations reflecting the ubiquitous nature of slavery, not commands to enslave non-Hebrews nor for offensive warfare to make the world Hebrew here, either.

As for Rudy, which is it? Is Islam "just as bad" and Judaism, or is it a "great religion"? Or are you saying that Judaism is also a great religion?
Next,
Norman,
"All you're doing is splitting hairs and defending your god."
It's called "reading."

That and a little intellectual integrity will go a long way.
"Whether an evil act is committed once or several times; against one person or many, it's still evil."
A Divine judgment may offend your amoral sensibilities, and certainly it is terrifying, but that doesn't justify calling it "evil."

Commanding an entire religion to kill all who refuse to convert or submit to Allah is evil on a scale incomprehensible. That you are unable to admit that says a lot about you.
"As for your ridiculous explanations of slavery"
Perhaps re-reading for comprehension would help.

I was not "explaining" nor justifying slavery (neither were the Biblical texts you cited); I was pointing out that what you misrepresent as commands to enslave (or as "God's rules, not man's") were in fact concessions made to corrupt people in a sin-sick world.

This same principle is evident in allowing divorce under certain circumstances. Though YHWH says He hates the practice, yet He set boundaries on it because of the "hardness of men's hearts."

Neglecting the numerous New Testament passages regarding Liberty and emancipation calls into question your willingness or ability to tell the truth.
"Your God's "protection" for a daughter amounted to making her a sex slave."
Your historical illiteracy is showing. Why do you think the commands were given? Because otherwise ordinary, decent people would refrain from enslaving their children, or because without such limitations even worse would occur against them?

By the way, I've checked three different translations of the Exodus 21 passage. None of them render it the way you do.

Here's the way the ESV says it:
"When a man sells his daughter as a slave, she shall not go out as the male slaves do. If she does not please her master, who has designated her for himself, then he shall let her be redeemed. He shall have no right to sell her to a foreign people, since he has broken faith with her.

"If he designates her for his son, he shall deal with her as with a daughter. If he takes another wife to himself, he shall not diminish her food, her clothing, or her marital rights.

"And if he does not do these three things for her, she shall go out for nothing, without payment of money."
Without such restrictions, what do you suppose happened to a female sold into slavery?
"Morally speaking, there's little difference between the OT and the Koran."
"Little difference" is better than, "no better," I suppose. It looks like we're making progress! :)

So, in your opinion, limitations on the evil of an institution foundational to the ancient world is little different than universal, open-ended commands to genocide.
"Maybe Christopher Hitchens is on to something..."
Yes, if you consider intellectual dishonesty, moral inversion, and logical fallacies fashionable.
Finally,
"I've never ever expressed any anti-Semitic sentiments"
In response to a religion sworn to the enslavement or death of Israel you condemn -- Israel's God.
"if someone is going to post negative excerpts from the Koran then be prepared to see similar excerpts from the Bible posted."
A logical fallacy in first place, and a false moral equivalence in the second.
"There's no excuse for God to order the killing of children and infants or to uphold the institution of slavery. It's still evil."
The command to Israel to wipe out certain Canaanites was a Divine judgment limited to only that time, place, and target. Yes, it was brutal and terrible, but it is in no way comparable to the universal, open-ended commands to wage offensive warfare against all non-Muslims who refuse to submit to Allah.

How many Hebrews are going around slaughtering Canaanites?

As for slavery, surely a good pagan like you also hates Classical Greece and Rome, for did they not also practice it?

What ancient civilization did not?

I encourage *you* to take your own advice and actually read the Old Testament. The commands regarding slavery were not exhortations to enslave, they were limits on what could be done within that ubiquitous, global institution.

It wasn't until over three millennia after Moses that a significant movement to abolish slavery finally took hold.

Who was behind that? Christians.

You refuse to address the numerous New Testament passages speaking of Liberty and encouraging slaves to gain their freedom peacefully, if possible because doing so would make your libelous, vomitous mass a little harder to issue.
"'Yes, if you consider intellectual dishonesty, moral inversion, and logical fallacies fashionable.' Sounds like something you did."
Impressive retort. Isn't that the Comment Board equivalent of "I know you are, but what am I?"?

Telling the truth will do more to enhance your credibility than perseverating error.
"'Ignore efforts to make peace between the Israelis and the Palestinians? Not to create a Palestinian state? Seems to me most people here rather see continuing violence.'

"Thank you for your insightful post 13 Martyrs."
We see the violence continuing, but not because we want it. It's because Islam's god and prophet command it.
An addendum,
"In other words it reaks of man's attempt to structure man's evil qualities that one can have if one chooses not to attempt the path of good."
That is a perceptive analysis, ArloRay.

In the early years of Mohammed's career as a prophet of Allah, his revelations were of a cooperative and respectful nature.

Later, as he grew in military and political might, the revelations concerning non-Muslims evolved into allowing war in self-defense, then demanding war in self-defense, and then finally requiring offensive warfare against all mankind to establish the tyranny of Allah.

Couple this with the fact that many of Mohammed's other later revelations justified his most base, vile impulses. He received from Allah statements that justified his murder, thievery, polygamy, even his raping of little Aisha from the time she was nine until his death.

And Allah calls Mohammed a "beautiful pattern of conduct" for all who want to please him, making the violation of every commandment under the sun "divine" in Mohammed.
"What was it about Christians that gave Muslims the idea that they could achieve that spread of domination in the first place?"
One God says, "Love your enemies." The other says, "kill the unbelievers wherever you find them."

Jewish, Christian, Buddhist, Zoroastrian, and other non-Muslims failed to halt the expansion of Islam in ancient times; I suppose they didn't have the means to communicate and coordinate, and they didn't know what they were facing.

Today, we have no excuse.

Muslims decapitating schoolgirls for Allah is exactly like a teacher naming a teddy bear

Or alternatively, "Don't say Islam is violent or we'll kill you!"

Cry me a river. In response to one feeling sorry for Islam, from here:
"Muslims certainly feel under daily attack from the West"
Yes, Muslims ripping schoolgirls' heads from their bodies to shouts of "Allahu akbar!" is exactly like a teacher naming a teddy bear.
"from Mitt Romney saying there would be no room in his White House cabinet for a Muslim to the conservative bloggers who ridicule the Prophet and mock the religion."
Does not a lying, thieving, enslaving, raping, heretical, murderous, genocidal pedophile deserve some sort of public evisceration?

Why would you want in any non-Muslim land someone who believes it is the duty of the ummah to war against all who refuse to submit to the rule of Allah?
"Gibbons' arrest is a strike back at those who mock Islam."
Yes, in the West we regularly imprison those who insult deity. It's all perfectly natural.

So, is such a reaction justified? You say, "Prophet." That's awfully reverential toward the monster described in Qur'an and Sunnah, is it not? Does that come from religious devotion, or a precious self-image of enlightenment and tolerance?

If the former, how can you worship such a beast? If the latter, what is enlightened about defending the most barbarous, tyrannical, and intolerant ideology in the history of Man?
"The tragedy here, though, is that it hurts Islam. This severe reaction holds Islam up to more ridicule. It further divides Christians and Jews from Muslims."
Wow. A woman goes to prison for naming a teddy bear, and the damage to Islam is the tragedy?

Here's the essential point. It is what Islam teaches, preaches, and practices that hurts Islam, not what teachers, presidential candidates, or conservative bloggers might say.

An Irish Trojan defending the Religion of Death

From here, on Hillary's special friend:

Dismissing concerns about the trustworthiness of a woman described as a "conservative" Muslim, whose father was an Indian who moved to Saudi Arabia to teach Islam, and whose mother is from Pakistan hardly seems prudent.

What do you know of Islam? It is morally good to reject prejudice as a matter of principle, but what if in this case you've judged Islam without knowing anything of it?

Do you know that Qur'an is considered the perfect word of Allah?

Do you know that Allah calls Mohammed a "beautiful pattern of conduct"? That Mohammed is therefore considered the "Ideal Man" in Islam whose command and example is to be followed by the faithful without question, so that even what he saw and allowed is determinative for life and law?

Do you know that Mohammed said, "War is deceit" (Bukhari Volume 4, Book 52, Number 268)?

Do you know that Allah commands the faithful Muslim to, "fight and slay the Pagans wherever ye find them, and seize them, beleaguer them, and lie in wait for them in every stratagem (of war) . . . " (Qur’an 9:5)?

Do you know that Jews and Christians are also targets? Allah requires his people to, "Fight those who believe not in Allah nor the Last Day, nor hold that forbidden which hath been forbidden by Allah and His Messenger, nor acknowledge the religion of Truth, (even if they are) of the People of the Book, until they pay the Jizya with willing submission, and feel themselves subdued" (Qur'an 9:29)?

Do you know that, "Allah's Apostle said: 'I have been ordered (by Allah) to fight against the people until they testify that none has the right to be worshipped but Allah and that Muhammad is Allah's Apostle . . . '" (Bukhari Volume 1, Book 2, Number 24)?

Do you know that "the Messenger of Allah . . . would say: 'Fight in the name of Allah and in the way of Allah. Fight against those who disbelieve in Allah. Make a holy war. . . . When you meet your enemies who are polytheists, invite them to three courses of action. . . . Invite them to (accept) Islam . . . If they refuse to accept Islam, demand from them the Jizya . . . If they refuse to pay the tax, seek Allah's help and fight them . . .'" (Muslim Book 19, Number 4294)?

In light of this -- all facts easily found by the Inquisitive Infidel with an ISP -- shouldn't you reconsider your uncritical trust in Allah's servants?

With murderous deceivers, talking is either a distraction or a stalling for time

The Pope wants to talk with people who persecute the Body of Christ, who are sworn to his conversion, enslavement, or death. From here:
Pope Benedict XVI invited a delegation of senior Muslim personalities, who signed an appeal for greater dialogue between religions, to a meeting at the Vatican, according to a letter released Thursday.

The pope praised the "positive spirit" behind the October 11 message signed by 138 top Muslims from around the world and sent to Christian leaders, said Vatican Secretary of State Cardinal Tarcisio Bertone in the letter sent in Pope Benedict's name.

The pope wanted to meet a representative group of the signatories at the Vatican, he added in the letter sent to Prince Ghazi bin Muhammad bin Talal, head of the Institute for Islamic Thought in Amman.

"The Pope has asked me to convey his gratitude to Your Royal Highness and to all who signed the letter," Bertone wrote.

"He also wishes to express his deep appreciation for this gesture, for the positive spirit which inspired the text and for the call for a common commitment to promoting peace in the world.
Is that spirit "positive" in the sense we would use the word, or is it positive in the sense of, "whatever aids Islam"?
"Without ignoring or downplaying our differences as Christians and Muslims, we can and therefore should look to what unites us, namely, belief in the one God, the provident Creator and universal Judge who at the end of time will deal with each person according to his or her actions. We are all called to commit ourselves totally to him and to obey his sacred will."
What a grave theological error. Is this the thinking of Benedict? Of his secretary? How in the world can one equate the God of, "Love your enemies," with the spawner of, "kill the unbelievers wherever you find them"?

How can the Christ Who died for His confession that He is the I AM, the Son of YHWH be the same deity as the one who condemns as a blasphemer all who say Allah has a son?
The letter said the pope "was particularly impressed by the attention given in the letter to the twofold commandment to love God and one's neighbour."
One's Muslim neighbor, that is. Per the command of Allah and the example of Mohammed, Infidels get only submission and slavery or death.
It recalled Pope Benedict's statement in August 2005 soon after he took office that "we must not yield to the negative pressures in our midst, but must affirm the values of mutual respect, solidarity and peace. "The life of every human being is sacred, both for Christians and for Muslims. There is plenty of scope for us to act together in the service of fundamental moral values."
Considering that Allah requires the torture, rape, enslavement, and slaughter of non-Muslims and the fact that "Allah's Apostle . . . said: No Muslim would die but Allah would admit in his stead a Jew or a Christian in Hell-Fire . . ." (Muslim Book 37, Number 6666), neither "sacred" nor "both . . . Christian" seem true.

When did Mohammed's core values -- rape, slavery, slaughter, greed, blasphemy, and pedophilia -- become fundamental to Christianity?

None of this is mutual.

Saturday, November 24, 2007

+ Word of the Day +

TI don't worry about how it ends; I've read the book.

From Life of the World, for the Last Sunday in Pentecost (Trinity):
Revelation 21:1-7

Now I saw a new heaven and a new earth, for the first heaven and the first earth had passed away. Also there was no more sea. Then I, John, saw the holy city, New Jerusalem, coming down out of heaven from God, prepared as a bride adorned for her husband. And I heard a loud voice from heaven saying, "Behold, the tabernacle of God is with men, and He will dwell with them, and they shall be His people. God Himself will be with them and be their God. And God will wipe away every tear from their eyes; there shall be no more death, nor sorrow, nor crying. There shall be no more pain, for the former things have passed away."

Then He who sat on the throne said, "Behold, I make all things new." And He said to me, "Write, for these words are true and faithful." And He said to me, "It is done! I am the Alpha and the Omega, the Beginning and the End. I will give of the fountain of the water of life freely to him who thirsts. He who overcomes shall inherit all things, and I will be his God and he shall be My son."

Matthew 25:1-13

"Then the kingdom of heaven shall be likened to ten virgins who took their lamps and went out to meet the bridegroom. Now five of them were wise, and five were foolish. Those who were foolish took their lamps and took no oil with them, but the wise took oil in their vessels with their lamps. But while the bridegroom was delayed, they all slumbered and slept.

And at midnight a cry was heard: 'Behold, the bridegroom is coming; go out to meet him!' Then all those virgins arose and trimmed their lamps. And the foolish said to the wise, 'Give us some of your oil, for our lamps are going out.' But the wise answered, saying, 'No, lest there should not be enough for us and you; but go rather to those who sell, and buy for yourselves.' And while they went to buy, the bridegroom came, and those who were ready went in with him to the wedding; and the door was shut. Afterward the other virgins came also, saying, 'Lord, Lord, open to us!' But he answered and said, 'Assuredly, I say to you, I do not know you.' Watch therefore, for you know neither the day nor the hour in which the Son of Man is coming."

Isaiah 65:17-19 [20-22] 23-25

"For behold, I create new heavens and a new earth; and the former shall not be remembered or come to mind. But be glad and rejoice forever in what I create; for behold, I create Jerusalem as a rejoicing, and her people a joy. I will rejoice in Jerusalem, and joy in My people; the voice of weeping shall no longer be heard in her, nor the voice of crying.

["No more shall an infant from there live but a few days, nor an old man who has not fulfilled his days; for the child shall die one hundred years old, but the sinner being one hundred years old shall be accursed. They shall build houses and inhabit them; they shall plant vineyards and eat their fruit. They shall not build and another inhabit; they shall not plant and another eat; for as the days of a tree, so shall be the days of My people, and My elect shall long enjoy the work of their hands.] They shall not labor in vain, nor bring forth children for trouble; for they shall be the descendants of the blessed of the LORD, and their offspring with them.

"It shall come to pass that before they call, I will answer; and while they are still speaking, I will hear. The wolf and the lamb shall feed together, the lion shall eat straw like the ox, and dust shall be the serpent's food. They shall not hurt nor destroy in all My holy mountain," Says the LORD.

Wednesday, November 21, 2007

Naming the "tiny minority of unidentified extremists possessing no particular ideology"

Do any of the major American presidential candidates from either party have the knowledge and courage to do so? Will any one of them "call a spade a spade," or will they continue to go the way of the craven UN in capitulating to Islamic intimidation and violence?

From here, in response to a recent interview of Fred Thompson:
While it may be true that some of those Muslims who engage in the slaughter of non-Muslims are ignorant of many things, it is not true that ignorance leads one to carry out jihad.

On the contrary, since the word of Allah (Qur'an) and the example of Mohammed (Sunnah) demand the faithful Muslim to war against all who refuse to convert or submit to the rule of Allah, it is the knowledgeable, devout Muslim who does so.

I want to vote for Fred, but I fear that he too is ignorant of the Source and Sustenance of our enemy's bloodlust:
"the Messenger of Allah . . . would say: 'Fight in the name of Allah and in the way of Allah. Fight against those who disbelieve in Allah. Make a holy war. . . . When you meet your enemies who are polytheists, invite them to three courses of action. . . . Invite them to (accept) Islam . . . If they refuse to accept Islam, demand from them the Jizya . . . If they refuse to pay the tax, seek Allah's help and fight them . . .'" (Muslim Book 19, Number 4294).

"fight and slay the Pagans wherever ye find them, and seize them, beleaguer them, and lie in wait for them in every stratagem (of war) . . . " (Qur’an 9:5).

"Fight those who believe not in Allah nor the Last Day, nor hold that forbidden which hath been forbidden by Allah and His Messenger, nor acknowledge the religion of Truth, (even if they are) of the People of the Book, until they pay the Jizya with willing submission, and feel themselves subdued" (Qur'an 9:29).

"Allah's Apostle said: 'I have been ordered (by Allah) to fight against the people until they testify that none has the right to be worshipped but Allah and that Muhammad is Allah's Apostle . . . '" (Bukhari Volume 1, Book 2, Number 24).

“Allah’s Apostle said, ‘I have been made victorious with terror. The treasures of the world were brought to me and put in my hand’” (Bukhari Volume 4, Book 52, Number 220).
To which RiverCocytus replied,
As the spokesperson for our nation, it does not good to fuel the fire of our enemy's hatred. If there is a good way to do it, it is to call all Muslims haters (even if it is directed in their religion) EVEN if they individually or as groups have no intention to do so.

Yours tends towards an ideological polemic, which is what Fred purposely avoided. I believe he is probably aware of the implications of what the Koran teaches. He's also aware of the sensitivity of the subject. Unless we really go to war with the whole, entire Muslim world, such things will remain unsaid.

Some need be and will need to continue to be our allies, hopefully permanently.

In the ideological black-and-white world your position makes sense, but it does not make workable policy.

It's one thing to not attack Muslims as whole. It is another thing to do what the British do and cede powerful positions to radicals.
Here's my response:
I'd like to respond to a few of the points you raise.

First, the enemy already hates us.

Second, if there are Muslims who would ally themselves with us out of principle and not expediency against those waging jihad, how would telling the truth about what their god commands "radicalize" them? Wouldn't they want to reject or revise their interpretations of such texts?

A person's accurately quoting my religion's Scriptures never makes me want to kill. In fact, I've never wanted to bomb or burn down anything in response to someone's misrepresenting Biblical texts.

If all it takes to enrage Muslims is accurately citing the will of Allah and his apostle's example, how were they ever truly our allies in the first place?

Third, what evidence do you have that Fred -- or any major presidential candidate -- has any understanding of what actually motivates our enemies?

Fred's reference to "ignorance" is not inconsistent with the UN's announcement this week that any combination of the words "Muslim" and "terrorism" in the same calendar year is offensive, their utterance justifying the "re-education" of the person(s) responsible.

Lastly, whether or not we war against "the entire Muslim world" (and again, how does accurately citing Islam's commands regarding non-Muslims "incite" to violence the faithful unless that is to what their religion predisposes them?), Islam is at war with us.

Imagine Winston Churchill claiming that it was a "tiny minority of unidentified extremists possessing no particular ideology" waging war against the civilized world rather than Nazi Germany. Would he deserve our admiration for his courage, or would he have been rightly despised for his Chamberlainian cowardice?

Justifying lying about Islam by calling it "workable policy" is craven appeasement and rewards Islamic intimidation and violence.

Instead, we ought to "call a spade a spade."

Sunday, November 18, 2007

Giving thanks for America

From the great Mark Steyn.
Speaking as a misfit unassimilated foreigner, I think of Thanksgiving as the most American of holidays.

Christmas is celebrated elsewhere, even if there are significant local variations: In Continental Europe, naughty children get left rods to be flayed with and lumps of coal; in Britain, Christmas lasts from Dec. 22 to mid-January and celebrates the ancient cultural traditions of massive alcohol intake and watching the telly till you pass out in a pool of your own vomit. All part of the rich diversity of our world.

But Thanksgiving (excepting the premature and somewhat undernourished Canadian version) is unique to America. "What's it about?" an Irish visitor asked me a couple of years back. "Everyone sits around giving thanks all day? Thanks for what? George bloody Bush?"

Well, Americans have a lot to be thankful for. Europeans think of this country as "the New World" in part because it has an eternal newness, which is noisy and distracting. Who would ever have thought you could have ready-to-eat pizza faxed directly to your iPod? And just when you think you're on top of the general trend of novelty, it veers off in an entirely different direction: Continentals who grew up on Hollywood movies where the guy tells the waitress "Gimme a cuppa joe" and slides over a nickel return to New York a year or two later and find the coffee now costs $5.75, takes 25 minutes and requires an agonizing choice between the cinnamon-gingerbread-persimmon latte with coxcomb sprinkles and the decaf venti pepperoni-Eurasian-milfoil macchiato.

Who would have foreseen that the nation that inflicted fast food and drive-thru restaurants on the planet would then take the fastest menu item of all and turn it into a Kabuki-paced performance art? What mad genius!

But Americans aren't novelty junkies on the important things. The New World is one of the oldest settled constitutional democracies on Earth, to a degree the Old World can barely comprehend. Where it counts, Americans are traditionalists.

We know Eastern Europe was a totalitarian prison until the Nineties, but we forget that Mediterranean Europe (Greece, Spain, Portugal) has democratic roots going all the way back until, oh, the mid-Seventies; France and Germany's constitutions date back barely half a century, Italy's only to the 1940s, and Belgium's goes back about 20 minutes, and currently it's not clear whether even that latest rewrite remains operative.

The U.S. Constitution is not only older than France's, Germany's, Italy's or Spain's constitution, it's older than all of them put together. Americans think of Europe as Goethe and Mozart and 12th century castles and 6th century churches, but the Continent's governing mechanisms are no more ancient than the Partridge Family. Aside from the Anglophone democracies, most of the nation-states in the West have been conspicuous failures at sustaining peaceful political evolution from one generation to the next, which is why they're so susceptible to the siren song of Big Ideas – communism, fascism, European Union. If you're going to be novelty-crazed, better the zebra-mussel cappuccino than the Third Reich.

Even in a supposedly 50/50 nation, you're struck by the assumed stability underpinning even fundamental disputes. If you go into a bookstore, the display shelves offer a smorgasbord of leftist anti-Bush tracts claiming that he and Cheney have trashed, mangled, gutted, raped and tortured, sliced 'n' diced the Constitution, put it in a cement overcoat and lowered it into the East River. Yet even this argument presupposes a shared veneration for tradition unknown to most Western political cultures: When Tony Blair wanted to abolish, in effect, the upper house of the national legislature, he just got on and did it.

I don't believe the U.S. Constitution includes a right to abortion or gay marriage or a zillion other things the Left claims to detect emanating from the penumbra, but I find it sweetly touching that in America even political radicalism has to be framed as an appeal to constitutional tradition from the powdered-wig era.

In Europe, by contrast, one reason why there's no politically significant pro-life movement is because, in a world where constitutions have the life expectancy of an Oldsmobile, great questions are just seen as part of the general tide, the way things are going, no sense trying to fight it. And, by the time you realize you have to, the tide's usually up to your neck.

So Americans should be thankful they have one of the last functioning nation-states. Europeans, because they've been so inept at exercising it, no longer believe in national sovereignty, whereas it would never occur to Americans not to. This profoundly different attitude to the nation-state underpins, in turn, Euro-American attitudes to transnational institutions such as the United Nations. But on this Thanksgiving the rest of the world ought to give thanks to American national sovereignty, too.

When something terrible and destructive happens – a tsunami hits Indonesia, an earthquake devastates Pakistan – the United States can project itself anywhere on the planet within hours and start saving lives, setting up hospitals and restoring the water supply. Aside from Britain and France, the Europeans cannot project power in any meaningful way anywhere. When they sign on to an enterprise they claim to believe in – shoring up Afghanistan's fledgling post-Taliban democracy – most of them send token forces under constrained rules of engagement that prevent them doing anything more than manning the photocopier back at the base.

If America were to follow the Europeans and maintain only shriveled attenuated residual military capacity, the world would very quickly be nastier and bloodier, and far more unstable. It's not just Americans and Iraqis and Afghans who owe a debt of thanks to the U.S. soldier but all the Europeans grown plump and prosperous in a globalized economy guaranteed by the most benign hegemon in history.

That said, Thanksgiving isn't about the big geopolitical picture, but about the blessings closer to home. Last week, the state of Oklahoma celebrated its centennial, accompanied by rousing performances of Rodgers and Hammerstein's eponymous anthem:
"We know we belong to the land

And the land we belong to is grand!"
Which isn't a bad theme song for the first Thanksgiving, either. Three hundred and 14 years ago, the Pilgrims thanked God because there was a place for them in this land, and it was indeed grand.

The land is grander today, and that, too, is remarkable: France has lurched from Second Empires to Fifth Republics struggling to devise a lasting constitutional settlement for the same smallish chunk of real estate, but the principles that united a baker's dozen of East Coast colonies were resilient enough to expand across a continent and halfway around the globe to Hawaii.

Americans should, as always, be thankful this Thanksgiving, but they should also understand just how rare in human history their blessings are.

Sunday, November 11, 2007

Decent, peaceful Muslims exist despite the command of Allah, the example of Mohammed, and the Islamic traditions derived from them

There may be decent, peaceful Muslims, but their existence is in spite of the command of Allah, the example of Mohammed, and the Islamic traditions derived from them.

From Spencer:
Michael van der Galiën is a 23-year-old American Studies student at the Rijksuniversiteit Groningen in the Netherlands, and correspondent in the Netherlands for Pajamas Media. In a post entitled "Islamic Law and Violence," he commented over a week ago on a response written by a student at Brown, Jebediah Koogler, to my Islamo-Fascism Awareness Week talk there. Since van der Galiën articulates so many common responses to and common misunderstandings of the work I am doing, I thought it might be useful to respond.
Jeb Koogler explains the obvious: Islamic law isn’t static. It changes over time. I also get a bit tired of people who say that the Koran preaches much more violence than the Bible and Torah do. I’ve read the Koran and I disagree; it doesn’t teach violence any more than the Bible or Torah.
I discuss this very common argument at length in my book Religion of Peace?; suffice it to say here that van der Galiën's statement, that the Qur'an doesn’t teach violence any more than the "Bible or Torah" is flatly false. For while the Bible contains descriptions of violent acts committed in the name of God, nowhere does it teach believers to imitate that violence. Where people are commanded to commit acts of violence, these are commands directed to specific individuals or groups in particular situations; they are not universal commands.

The Qur'an, on the other hand, quite clearly does teach believers to commit acts of violence against unbelievers -- see 2:190-193, 9:5, 9:29, 47:4, etc. There are no equivalents to such open-ended and universal commands, addressed to all believers to fight unbelievers, in the Bible. Of course, van der Galiën would respond that such passages have not been understood as such by all Muslims throughout history, and that is no doubt true. We'll discuss that in more detail in a moment. But it is not the point here, for when he says that the Qur'an "doesn’t teach violence any more than the Bible or Torah," he is not talking about interpretative traditions, but the content of the text.
In fact, I’d say, the only way for people to defend terrorism or violence by the Koran is by quoting passages in it completely out of context and to ignore the spirit of the Koran, which is peaceful.
Unfortunately for van der Galiën, there is not a single traditional school of Islamic jurisprudence that would agree with his assessment here, for all of the schools that are considered orthodox teach, as part of the obligation of the Muslim community, warfare against and the subjugation of unbelievers.

Shafi'i school: A Shafi'i manual of Islamic law that was certified in 1991 by the clerics at Al-Azhar University, one of the leading authorities in the Islamic world, as a reliable guide to Sunni orthodoxy, stipulates that “the caliph makes war upon Jews, Christians, and Zoroastrians...until they become Muslim or pay the non-Muslim poll tax.” It adds a comment by Sheikh Nuh ‘Ali Salman, a Jordanian expert on Islamic jurisprudence: the caliph wages this war only “provided that he has first invited [Jews, Christians, and Zoroastrians] to enter Islam in faith and practice, and if they will not, then invited them to enter the social order of Islam by paying the non-Muslim poll tax (jizya)...while remaining in their ancestral religions.” ('Umdat al-Salik, o9.8).

Of course, there is no caliph today, and hence the oft-repeated claim that Osama et al are waging jihad illegitimately, as no state authority has authorized their jihad. But they explain their actions in terms of defensive jihad, which needs no state authority to call it, and becomes "obligatory for everyone" ('Umdat al-Salik, o9.3) if a Muslim land is attacked. The end of the defensive jihad, however, is not peaceful coexistence with non-Muslims as equals: 'Umdat al-Salik specifies that the warfare against non-Muslims must continue until "the final descent of Jesus." After that, "nothing but Islam will be accepted from them, for taking the poll tax is only effective until Jesus' descent" (o9.8).

Hanafi school: A Hanafi manual of Islamic law repeats the same injunctions. It insists that people must be called to embrace Islam before being fought, “because the Prophet so instructed his commanders, directing them to call the infidels to the faith.” It emphasizes that jihad must not be waged for economic gain, but solely for religious reasons: from the call to Islam “the people will hence perceive that they are attacked for the sake of religion, and not for the sake of taking their property, or making slaves of their children, and on this consideration it is possible that they may be induced to agree to the call, in order to save themselves from the troubles of war.”

However, “if the infidels, upon receiving the call, neither consent to it nor agree to pay capitation tax [jizya], it is then incumbent on the Muslims to call upon God for assistance, and to make war upon them, because God is the assistant of those who serve Him, and the destroyer of His enemies, the infidels, and it is necessary to implore His aid upon every occasion; the Prophet, moreover, commands us so to do.” (Al-Hidayah, II.140)

Maliki school: Ibn Khaldun (1332-1406), a pioneering historian and philosopher, was also a Maliki legal theorist. In his renowned Muqaddimah, the first work of historical theory, he notes that “in the Muslim community, the holy war is a religious duty, because of the universalism of the Muslim mission and (the obligation to) convert everybody to Islam either by persuasion or by force.” In Islam, the person in charge of religious affairs is concerned with “power politics,” because Islam is “under obligation to gain power over other nations.”

Hanbali school: The great medieval theorist of what is commonly known today as radical or fundamentalist Islam, Ibn Taymiyya (Taqi al-Din Ahmad Ibn Taymiyya, 1263-1328), was a Hanbali jurist. He directed that “since lawful warfare is essentially jihad and since its aim is that the religion is God’s entirely and God’s word is uppermost, therefore according to all Muslims, those who stand in the way of this aim must be fought.”

Of course, these are all extremely old authorities -- such that one might reasonably assume that whatever they say couldn’t possibly still be the consensus of the Islamic mainstream. The laws of the United States have evolved considerably since the adoption of the Constitution, which itself has been amended. So why shouldn’t this be true of Islamic law as well? Many observers assume that it must be, and that contemporary jihadists' departure from mainstream Islam must be located in its preference for the writings of ancient jurists rather than modern ones. But in this, unfortunately, they fail to reckon with the implications of the closing of the gates of ijtihad.

Ijtihad is the process of arriving at a decision on a point of Islamic law through study of the Qur’an and Sunnah. From the beginning of Islam, the authoritative study of such sources was reserved to a select number of scholars who fulfilled certain qualifications, including a comprehensive knowledge of the Qur’an and Sunnah, as well as knowledge of the principle of analogical reasoning (qiyas) by which legal decisions are made; knowledge of the consensus (ijma) on any given question of Muhammad, his closest companions, and the scholars of the past; and more, including living a blameless life.

The founders of the schools of Islamic jurisprudence are among the small number of scholars -- mujtahedin -- thus qualified to perform ijithad. But they all lived very long ago; for many centuries, independent study of the Qur’an and Sunnah has been discouraged among Muslims, who are instead expected to adhere to the rulings of one of those established schools. Since the death of Ahmed ibn Hanbal, from whom the Hanbali school takes its name, in 855 A.D., no one has been recognized by the Sunni Muslim community as a mujtahid of the first class -- that is, someone who is qualified to originate legislation of his own, based on the Qur’an and Sunnah but not upon the findings of earlier mujtahedin.

Islamic scholar Cyril Glasse notes that “‘the door of ijtihad is closed’ as of some nine hundred years, and since then the tendency of jurisprudence (fiqh) has been to produce only commentaries upon commentaries and marginalia.” Shi’ite Muslims have never accepted that ijtihad is a thing of the past. Thus it is with a slight tone of disapproval that the Shi’ite scholar Murtada Mutahhari notes of the Sunnis:
The right of ijtihad did not last for long among the Sunnis. Perhaps the cause of this was the difficulty which occurred in practice: for if such a right were to continue [for any great length of time], especially if ta`awwul and the precedence of something over the texts were to be permitted, and everyone were permitted to change or interpret according to his own opinion, nothing would remain of the way of Islam (din al islam).

Perhaps it is for this reason that the right of independent ijtihad was gradually withdrawn, and the view of the Sunni `ulama became that they instructed people to practice taqlid of only the four mujtahids, the four famous Imams - Abu Hanifa [d.150/767], al Shafi`i; [d.204/820], Malik b. Anas [d.179/795] and Ahmad b. Hanbal [d.241/855] - and forbade people to follow anyone apart from these four persons. This measure was first taken in Egypt in the seventh hijri century, and then taken up in the rest of the lands of Islam.
The Imam Hassan Qazwini, director of the Islamic Center of America, considers this closing off of new interpretations of Islamic law to be a serious error. According to David Smock, director of the Religion and Peacemaking Initiative of the United States Institute of Peace:
One of the gravest mistakes Muslims have committed, according to Qazwini, is closing the doors of ijtihad. They have limited legal interpretation to only four prominent scholars: Malik Ibn Anas, Abu Hanifa al-No‘man, Muhammad Ibn Idris al-Shafi‘i, and Ahmad Ibn Hambal—the heads of the Maliki, Hanafi, Shafi‘i, and Hambali [sic] schools of thought. The motivation for this was political. During the Abbasid Dynasty (750–1258 CE), the Abbasids decided to outlaw all other sects in order to strictly control religion and worship, as well as political matters.

Closing the doors of ijtihad has had extremely detrimental ramifications for the Muslim world. According to Qazwini, this decision has resulted in chronic intellectual stagnation, as thousands of potential mujtahids and scholars have been prohibited from offering workable solutions to newly emerging problems. Muslim thinkers have become captive to rules that were made long ago, leaving little scope for liberal or innovative thought.
Other Muslims, however, disagree. Seyyed Hossein Nasr of George Washington University, in his consideration of Islam and modernity, Ideals and Realities of Islam, says: “Certain modernists over the past century have tried to change the Shari‘ah, to reopen the gate of ijtihad, with the aim of incorporating modern practices into the Law and limiting the function of Shari‘ah to personal life.

All of these activities emanate from a particular attitude of spiritual weakness vis-à-vis the world and surrender to the world. Those who are conquered by such a mentality want to make the Shari‘ah ‘conform to the times,’ which means to the whims and fancies of men and the ever changing human nature which has made ‘the times.’ They do not realize that it is the Shari‘ah according to which society should be modeled not vice versa.” In any case, whether it is a manifestation of “chronic intellectual stagnation” or fidelity to the Sharia, along with the stasis in other areas there has been a lack of development in the doctrines of jihad.

Even Islamic apologist Karen Armstrong admits that “Muslim jurists...taught that, because there was only one God, the whole world should be united in one polity and it was the duty of all Muslims to engage in a continued struggle to make the world accept the divine principles and create a just society.” Non-Muslims “should be made to surrender to God’s rule. Until this had been achieved, Islam must engage in a perpetual warlike effort.” But, she says, “this martial theology was laid aside in practice and became a dead letter once it was clear that the Islamic empire had reached the limits of its expansion about a hundred years after Muhammad’s death.”

The problem is that however much of a dead letter it became in practice during times of weakness in the Islamic world, this doctrine of Islamic supremacism was never reformed or rejected. No one seems to have told the warriors of jihad who besieged Europe through the seventeenth century that the Islamic empire had already reached the limits of its expansion centuries before. No one seems to have told the modern-day warriors of Islam from Bosnia to the Philippines that jihad is a dead letter, and that Islam isn’t doing any more expanding.

The Saudi Sheikh Muhammad Saalih al-Munajid (1962-), whose lectures and Islamic rulings (fatawa) circulate widely throughout the Islamic world, demonstrates this in a discussion of whether Muslims should force others to accept Islam. In considering Qur’an 2:256 (“There is no compulsion in religion,”) the Sheikh quotes Qur’an 9:29, as well as 8:39 (“And fight them until there is no more Fitnah (disbelief and polytheism, i.e. worshipping others besides Allaah), and the religion (worship) will all be for Allaah Alone [in the whole of the world]”), and the Verse of the Sword. Of the latter, Sheikh Muhammad says simply: “This verse is known as Ayat al-Sayf (the verse of the sword). These and similar verses abrogate the verses which say that there is no compulsion to become Muslim.”

Other modern writers agree. The Pakistani Brigadier S. K. Malik’s 1979 book The Qur’anic Concept of War (a book that made its way to the American mujahedin Jeffrey Leon Battle and October Martinique Lewis, and which carried a glowing endorsement from Pakistan’s then-future President Muhammad Zia-ul-Haq, who said that it explained “the ONLY pattern of war” that a Muslim country could legitimately wage) delineates the same stages in the Qur’anic teaching about jihad: “The Muslim migration to Medina brought in its wake events and decisions of far-reaching significance and consequence for them. While in Mecca, they had neither been proclaimed an Ummah [community] nor were they granted the permission to take up arms against their oppressors. In Medina, a divine revelation proclaimed them an ‘Ummah’ and granted them the permission to take up arms against their oppressors. The permission was soon afterwards converted into a divine command making war a religious obligation for the faithful.”

Muhammad Sa’id Ramadan al-Buti, a theology professor at Damascus University, echoes the classic Islamic legal tenet that Muslims can legitimately wage war against those who resist the proclamation of Islam in his book Jihad in Islam: How to Understand and Practice It. Al-Buti considers at great length the question of whether this armed struggle can be undertaken “to avert belligerency” or “to put an end to infidelity.” In other words, is jihad purely defensive, or can it be offensive? (Al-Buti, however, carefully defines “to avert belligerency” to allow for a pre-emptive strike against a perceived imminent attack.)

Al-Buti bases his discussion of this question on the Qur’an and Islamic traditions. After a thorough discussion of these hadiths and other elements of Muslim tradition, al-Buti concludes that Muslim forces shouldn’t attack unbelievers. They should fight when attacked, or when an attack seems imminent, but that’s all. In this conclusion he notes that he is siding with three of the four major Sunni schools of Islamic jurisprudence, the Hanafi, Maliki, and Hanbali: all agree, by his account, that military jihad should only be undertaken to ward off an attack or potential attack.

Of course, such restrictions can be and have been interpreted with great elasticity, but the fourth Sunni school school of jurisprudence (madhhab) goes even farther: the Shafi’is, as well as the minor Zahiri school, favor offensive jihad. The Shafi’is and Zahiris, according to al-Buti, “proclaimed that the fundamental cause of Jihad is to terminate Paganism.”

Imran Ahsan Khan Nyazee, Assistant Professor on the Faculty of Shari’ah and Law of the International Islamic University in Islamabad, in a 1994 book on Islamic law quotes the twelfth century Maliki jurist Abu al-Walid Muhammad ibn Ahmad Ibn Rushd. Ibn Rushd reports on a consensus (ijma) among Muslim scholars on jihad warfare – and in traditional Islamic legal terms a consensus among scholars, once reached, cannot be modified. “Why wage war?” asks Ibn Rushd, and then he answers his own question: “Muslim jurists agreed that the purpose of fighting with the People of the Book…is one of two things: it is either their conversion to Islam or the payment of jizyah.”

Nyazee concludes: “This leaves no doubt that the primary goal of the Muslim community, in the eyes of its jurists, is to spread the word of Allah through jihad, and the option of poll-tax [jizya] is to be exercised only after subjugation” of non-Muslims. But if this is so, why hasn’t the worldwide Islamic community been waging jihad on a large scale up until relatively recently? Nyazee says it is only because they have not been able to do so: “the Muslim community may be considered to be passing through a period of truce. In its present state of weakness, there is nothing much it can do about it.”

In this view, then, the jihad must continue as long as there are unbelievers, and only falls into abeyance when Muslims do not have the military strength to press forward with it. Making war on unbelievers is one of the responsibilities of the Muslim umma. That the three stages of jihad, culminating in offensive warfare to establish the hegemony of Islamic law – which stage is normative for all time -- can be found not only in the writings of contemporary Islamic jihadists, but also in ancient Muslim scholars, underscores the traditionalist character of contemporary Islamic jihad activity. Modern mujahedin are, in their own view, not “hijacking” Islam; they are restoring its proper interpretation – and they are successfully convincing peaceful Muslims around the world that they are correct in this.

For this to end, peaceful Muslims around the world would have to confront the fact that bin Laden and other jihad terrorists are regularly justifying their violence by reference to passages of the Qur’an and the words and deeds of Muhammad. If they don’t acknowledge this and formulate new and non-literalist ways of understanding this material, it will continue to be used to incite violence. In other words, the use that jihadists make of elements of the Qur’an and Muhammad’s teaching makes it incumbent upon peaceful Muslims to perform a searching reevaluation of how they understand those elements, so as to neutralize their capacity to set Muslims against non-Muslims.

People will do evil in all kinds of circumstances, and use all manner of justification for it; but the violent passages in the Bible are not equivalent to those in the Qur’an in content, in mainstream interpretation, or in the effect they have had on believers through the ages. The fact that in Islam violence against unbelievers has divine sanction in a way that it does not in Christianity makes religious violence more prevalent and harder to eradicate in Islam than it has ever been in Christianity. To equate it to a jumble of passages from the Bible to which no one would otherwise be paying any attention at all, at least as direct marching orders for twenty-first century warriors, is specious and dangerously misleading. Back to van der Galiën:
As regards to Islamic law: Jeb’s completely right. Throughout the history of Islam there have been debates about what Islam means, what Islamic law should look like, etc. To Robert Spencer I would like to say one thing, one word: Mevlana.
Certainly there has been and is diversity of Islamic law, but as I have shown above, there has been consensus on the necessity to wage war against and subjugate unbelievers. I would ask van der Galiën or Koogler to produce one orthodox school of Islamic jurisprudence, or one scholar recognized as orthodox, who explicitly rejected this necessity. Mevlana? That's Rumi, folks, the Persian poet and mystic. Rumi was a terrific poet, and a great mystic, but does Islamic mysticism in general preclude a proclivity for jihad warfare? Unfortunately, no. Here is a quote from the pioneering Sufi mystic Al-Ghazali:
[O]ne must go on jihad (i.e., warlike razzias or raids) at least once a year...one may use a catapult against them [non-Muslims] when they are in a fortress, even if among them are women and children. One may set fire to them and/or drown them...If a person of the Ahl al-Kitab [People of The Book – primarily Jews and Christians] is enslaved, his marriage is [automatically] revoked…One may cut down their trees...One must destroy their useless books. Jihadists may take as booty whatever they decide...they may steal as much food as they need...

[T]he dhimmi is obliged not to mention Allah or His Apostle…Jews, Christians, and Majians must pay the jizya [poll tax on non-Muslims]…on offering up the jizya, the dhimmi must hang his head while the official takes hold of his beard and hits [the dhimmi] on the protruberant bone beneath his ear [i.e., the mandible]… They are not permitted to ostentatiously display their wine or church bells…their houses may not be higher than the Muslim’s, no matter how low that is. The dhimmi may not ride an elegant horse or mule; he may ride a donkey only if the saddle[-work] is of wood. He may not walk on the good part of the road. They [the dhimmis] have to wear [an identifying] patch [on their clothing], even women, and even in the [public] baths…[dhimmis] must hold their tongue…. [2] (From the Wagjiz, written in 1101 A.D.)
There are other Sufi authorities who speak in the same vein.
In his response to Jeb Robert Spencer (whom Jeb criticized) writes: “I spoke of the oppression of their fellow Muslims by Salafists, and discussed at some length the fact that ‘the overwhelming majority of Muslims don’t actually follow the passages that [I] cited’.” This, of course, sounds better, but it still ignores the larger point, namely that these Muslims don’t ‘ignore’ the passages in the Koran that speak about using violence against unbelievers, but that they interprete them in their context. In other words, they don’t just look at such a passage and say “ah yes, kiell the infidel!,” they look at the entire Koran and understand that they shouldn’t use violence but should preach and practice peace and tolerance.
Actually, I have never denied that alternative interpretations of the Qur'an exist. And I am all for them -- in fact, we need more. But what we really need are ones that are effective enough to begin to seize the intellectual vanguard away from the jihadists, who make recruits among peaceful Muslims by presenting their perspective as "pure Islam." Until this is effectively countered by peaceful Muslims, that recruitment will continue successfully.
This means that Spencer et al. should stop arguing that ‘pure Islam’ is such and so. That’s not up to them to say. Pure Islam is whatever you want it to be. Rumi’s supporters thought and think that they are living true “Islamic” (or Muslim) lives. Bin Laden disagrees and would kill them if he could. Ahmadinejad thinks that what he preaches is the ‘pure’ Islam, Ali Eteraz disagrees and offers ‘his’ ‘pure’ version of Islam.
Here van der Galiën gets me flatly wrong, as I have never said that the jihadist version of Islam is "pure Islam." I have said that the jihadists say it is, and that they appeal to broad support within the Qur'an and Sunnah and Islamic jurisprudence, as I've shown above. But does all that support mean that they're correct in saying that theirs is the "pure Islam"? No, and I have never said otherwise. If someone, even Ali Eteraz, could construct a version of Islam that could convince Muslims that the jihadists did not represent "pure Islam," no one would be happier than I. But I don't think they will succeed in doing that by denying the scope of the problem and playing fast and loose with the facts, like Eteraz. Reform doesn't occur by denying the need for reform. It occurs by confronting what needs reforming, and opposing it.
Muslims should decide what ‘pure’ or ‘true’ Islam is and what’s not.
Quite so. That's exactly what I've been calling upon peaceful Muslims to do for years now.
And with regards to all religions, those who argue that it’s not about the letter but about the spirit usually have a stronger case than those who argue the opposite. We would do well to remember that. For instance when Spencer talks about how Islamic law has condoned the stoning of women. Or how Islamic law has grown to oppress women, etc. All true. From a modern Western perspective that is. If you look at what life was like before Mohammed came to power and before he established the new religion, you’ll see that Islam actually meant progress for Arabic women. You will also see that Mohammed treated his wives with kindness and depended on them (for advise, etc.). That’s the spirit of the Koran and of Mohammed’s life. If you copy the spirit you’ll get an entirely different result today, then when you only copy the letter.
All true only from a modern Western perspective? So would van der Galiën deny that there are women awaiting death by stoning in Iran today? I suppose I, with my modern Western perspective, put them there? It may be wonderfully true that Muhammad liberated women in his day, but the application of the letter of his law is oppressing and killing women today. Van der Galiën can speak loftily about the spirit of that law all he wants, but that isn't preventing those women in Iran from being stoned to death. And I am not going to stop speaking out on their behalf, and for the human rights of women and religious minorities in the Islamic world, because Muhammad was ahead of his time in the treatment of women. It's time for all those who believe in the human dignity of all people, whether they are Muslim or non-Muslim, to stand up against this oppression. I hope that ultimately van der Galiën will join us in this stand, rather than making excuses for the oppressors.

Thursday, November 8, 2007

Signs? What signs? Only the leader of the free world appeasing the Religion of Death

So it appears those head coverings really are symbols of slavery and death. From where do Muslims get such tyrannical and bloodthirsty ideas?

Isn't Islam a "great world religion of peace"?

Perhaps rabello can explain to these wretches that they don't understand Islam.

From WND:
"Once Islam dominates, anyone living inside the Islamic state must abide by our rules. There is no choice. You will abide or face the punishment," said Muhammad Abdel-El, the spokesman and a senior leader of the Popular Resistance Committees terror organization. Sheik Abu Saqer, a prominent Gaza-based preacher, a founder of the Sword of Islam terror group and a subscriber to the ideology of al-Qaida, explained if Islam controls the U.S., all American women, whether Muslim or not, must cover their hair. "This is the demand of our religion. Being and walking naked doesn't mean that you are enjoying more freedom; it means that you are going against Allah's laws and you are serving the enemies of Islam who want to empty our Islamic society from its values. Uncovered heads is a form of nudity.

Yasser Hamad, a cleric and a Hamas leader in the northern West Bank, explained in "Schmoozing" Islamic law enforcers would at first try to persuade American woman to cover their heads, but eventually females would be forced. Those women who refuse may be stoned. Asked by Klein whether stoning was too harsh a punishment, Hamad replied: "If you don't respect the local law in America, if you don't pay taxes, if you drive on a red light, aren't there sanctions used against you by your government? Of course there are and it's okay with you. Why is there a problem when it comes to the Islamic state that wants to impose its rules?"
Yes, jaywalkers are routinely executed in America, especially if they're wearing the wrong hat.
Hamad and other terror leaders stated all Jews and Christians living in the U.S. once Islam takes over would need to pay the jizya – a special protection tax – and other special taxes for non-Muslims, including one for the right to cultivate land.
Which of course echoes the word of Allah and the example of Mohammed, both of which are directly responsible for the raping, enslaving, and slaughtering of hundreds of millions (billions?) of non-Muslims over the last nearly fourteen hundred years:
"Fight those who believe not in Allah nor the Last Day, nor hold that forbidden which hath been forbidden by Allah and His Messenger, nor acknowledge the religion of Truth, (even if they are) of the People of the Book, until they pay the Jizya with willing submission, and feel themselves subdued" (Qur'an 9:29).

"the Messenger of Allah . . . would say: 'Fight in the name of Allah and in the way of Allah. Fight against those who disbelieve in Allah. Make a holy war. . . . When you meet your enemies who are polytheists, invite them to three courses of action. . . . Invite them to (accept) Islam; if they respond to you, accept it from them and desist from fighting against them. . . . If they refuse to accept Islam, demand from them the Jizya. If they agree to pay, accept it from them and hold off your hands. If they refuse to pay the tax, seek Allah's help and fight them . . .'" (Muslim Book 19, Number 4294).
The article continues:
Non-Muslims cannot own land themselves. Saqer said no new synagogues or churches can be built in the Islamic state. Existing houses of worship may remain, but services cannot be conducted loudly or in any public fashion. The ringing of church bells or blowing of the ceremonial Jewish shofar would be forbidden, the terror leaders said.

Asked about crime and punishment, Hamad explained, "For every sin and crime there is a sanction:" "Prostitution: one hundred whippings; if the prostitute was married, he or she will be stoned until death; for a thief, his hand will be cut. But before enjoying the primitive nature of Islam and before you express how much you are shocked by our rules, I must say that these are not immediate sanctions, but they are used only if the person was warned."

Hamad explained prostitution doesn't mean selling sex; he said the Islamic definition applies the term to all extramarital sexual relations. But he boasted Islam's allowing men to marry many women was a perfect remedy for prostitution.

"In order to prevent prostitution and before reaching the sanctions of stoning or whipping, we will marry all our unmarried young. By the way, Islam allows the man to marry four women, so if he or she keeps practicing sex outside marriage and prostitution, in this case the sanctions mentioned in Quran will be used."

The terror leaders all said alcohol would be banned and American movies and television would be shut down. "American culture is very cheap and very corrupting. Your American culture is based on capitalism, on democracy, sex, and other principles that go against the nature of human beings as Allah created. We will fight all that this culture represents and promotes," said sheik Saleh Faraj, one of the main leaders of the Islamic Liberation Party in the West Bank.
Allah doesn't create human beings, he creates monsters, as powerfully demonstrated here.

There is much about American pop culture that is repulsive and immoral. Unfortunately, Islam's definition of "corruption" includes anything contrary to the rule of Allah, including the Bill of Rights.

Here comes Newspeak worthy of the Nazis, Soviets, and other totalitarian regimes:
What about freedom of the press in the American Islamic state? The terrorists said once Islam rules us, American media outlets that don't conform to disseminating Islamic messages will be closed. They said the NY Times, CNN, the Washington Post would all be banned. "The media will be closed not because there will be no freedom but because what is the logic of allowing the activity of media that can endanger the political and social stability of our state?" said Nasser Abu Aziz, no. 2 of the Al Aqsa Martyrs Brigades terror group in the northern West Bank.

The terrorists took particular offense at the FOX News Channel, which some called a "network of evil." Abu Abdullah said, "The evil FOX encourages a lack of respect to Islam and resistance movements and will cause moral confusion and negative political influence."

There is a possibility American music may be altogether banned if Islam takes over . . . Asked about American pop music icons, multiple terror leaders . . . said they were all familiar with Madonna and Britney Spears. "Unfortunately, I heard the names of Madonna and Spears on [Arab] television when parents complain that their children neglect their studies and their values because they are influenced by your cheap American music that you call culture," said Saqer.

Hamas's Abu Abdullah said, "At the beginning, we will try to convince Madonna and Britney Spears to follow Allah's way. But I honestly don't think they will follow. If they persist with their whoring music, we will prevent them by force. I don't think that I can be in the same place with these singers. They might be killed if they do not respect our laws."

The Committee's Abdel-El, whose group previously bombed Americans, said, "Their music video clips will be forbidden and these whores Madonna and Spears will be thrown in jail until they admit they made sins and return to the moral way. If they don't, they will be stoned to death or eighty times hit with a belt."

Abdel-El said even before Islam takes over America, he would personally kill Madonna and Spears if he ran into them. "If I meet these whores I will have the honor – I repeat, I will have the honor – to be the first one to cut the heads of Madonna and Britney Spears."
Can you feel the love? There must be a music video in there somewhere.

Lamentably, the following assessment seems accurate. Worst of all, our president's willful and stubborn ignorance of Islam accelerates the process.
In "Schmoozing," the terrorists stress repeatedly their goal is a worldwide Islamic caliphate. "We see already in America a nucleus of Islam, a base for Islam. This will become bigger, stronger, more important, until Islam will take control and will seize the power in America and the world," said Faraj. Abdel-El affirmed, "America will be overthrown. We are seeing more and more signs that prove that the process had already started."

President Bush ought to be exposing and opposing the Islamic imperatives to convert, subdue and humiliate, and kill non-Muslims.

Instead, the leader of the free world appeases the Religion of Death by:
  • hosting dinners for the religion that slaughtered three thousand of his own people,
  • making his wife and female members of his administration cover their heads in vile submission to the misogyny of Allah,
  • advocating (at least until recently) an independent Kosovo -- a Muslim stronghold in the heart of Europe,
  • skittishly avoiding using the term, "Islamo-fascism" to describe . . . Islamo-fascism,
  • equating the "words of the Qur'an" with The Ten Commandments and The Sermon on the Mount in an inaugural address as President of the United States of America,
  • using American blood and treasure to enshrine Islam in the constitutions of Afghanistan and Iraq, and,
  • urging Musharraf -- the only thing standing between jihad and Pakistan's nuclear arsenal -- to hold free elections among a population demanding Shari'a and jihad.
What signs?

Wednesday, November 7, 2007

Defending in arrogant ignorance those who would enslave and destroy all you hold dear deserves no praise

In response to rabello, from here:
I do find blatant negative stereotyping and blanket condemnation of human beings just because of their religion extemely distasteful, however.
Who is responsible for the "negative stereotyping," those who disapprove of slaughtering innocents to shouts of "allahu akbar!" or those who actually carry out the slaughter?

Why do you not find instead their barbarism "extemely distasteful"?
Discerning readers would note that I have not defended, nor condemned for that matter, "Islam," as I --like most non-Muslims who fight (as opposed to discuss) here --have no knowledgeable basis for doing so.
If you know nothing of Islam (still bragging about that, I see!), then how can you criticize others who do know?

What makes you think that defending evil out of ignorance is meritorious?
I do, however, try to confront bigotry, hatred, blatant negative stereotyping and blanket condemnation of human beings based on their religion
Except when Mohammed does it.

It must take a lot of courage to remain absolutely ignorant of the ideology responsible for hundreds of millions (billions?) of Infidel deaths over the last fourteen centuries (and nearly 10,000 attacks since 9/11).
I do not agree that the basic tenets of Islam are "convertion (sic) of the infidel to its beliefs or the destruction of everything the infidel holds dear."
Either you know what Qur'an and Sunnah state, or you do not.

If you do not, then you are completely unqualified to offer any opinion at all.
That would equal blatant negative stereotyping and blanket condemnation of human beings based on their religion, which as I've said, I find repulsive.
Which is exactly why "discerning readers" find your obtuseness inexplicable.
For all the "quotes" from the Koran put forth by non-Muslims on this and the old board
So, who quotes Qur'an determines whether or not the words are actually there? That's nonsense.

To argue that one must be Muslim to accurately cite Islam's texts is logically fallacious.

What makes a person qualified to cite Qur'an and Sunnah? The ability to read.
not one piece of real evidence has ever been presented that *proves* what Islam and Muslims are constantly accused of. It all comes down to personal opinion, based on what?
"Personal opinion" is a convenient but craven way of avoiding addressing the point, which is: What did Mohammed actually say and practice?

With regard to jihad, here's a snip:
"the Messenger of Allah . . . would say: 'Fight in the name of Allah and in the way of Allah. Fight against those who disbelieve in Allah. Make a holy war. . . . When you meet your enemies who are polytheists, invite them to three courses of action. . . . Invite them to (accept) Islam; if they respond to you, accept it from them and desist from fighting against them. . . . If they refuse to accept Islam, demand from them the Jizya. If they agree to pay, accept it from them and hold off your hands. If they refuse to pay the tax, seek Allah's help and fight them . . .'" (Muslim Book 19, Number 4294).

"fight and slay the Pagans wherever ye find them, and seize them, beleaguer them, and lie in wait for them in every stratagem (of war) . . . " (Qur’an 9:5).

"Fight those who believe not in Allah nor the Last Day, nor hold that forbidden which hath been forbidden by Allah and His Messenger, nor acknowledge the religion of Truth, (even if they are) of the People of the Book, until they pay the Jizya with willing submission, and feel themselves subdued" (Qur'an 9:29).

"Allah's Apostle said: 'I have been ordered (by Allah) to fight against the people until they testify that none has the right to be worshipped but Allah and that Muhammad is Allah's Apostle . . . '" (Bukhari Volume 1, Book 2, Number 24).

“Allah’s Apostle said, ‘I have been made victorious with terror. The treasures of the world were brought to me and put in my hand’” (Bukhari Volume 4, Book 52, Number 220).
rabello continues,
Muslims, who should be able to come to this board to discuss their religion without being victimized by constant, mean-spirited, unfounded, totally personal attacks.
What is "victimizing, mean-spirited, unfounded, or personal" about citing the word of Allah and the example of his apostle?

And why won't you do Muslims the courtesy of allowing their god and prophet to speak for themselves?
My only agenda is to speak up for rational tolerance and peace.
There's a term for those who ignorantly and vigorously defend those struggling to convert, enslave, or destroy them and theirs.

"Rational" isn't it.

Monday, October 29, 2007

Never use a religion's authoritative texts in evaluating it. It's so much more edifying just to make things up!

To Lexa, from here:
various sects of Christians have been killing each other since long before the birth of . . . Muhammad, which is true. As for not knowing what I am talking about, this is a historical fact. I am sorry that my use of the term "Protestant" so confused you that you chose do discount my point entirely.
You ought to be apologizing for your historical illiteracy, not blaming others for it.

As to your "historical fact," since Christians were persecuted as a matter of policy until the fourth century and Mohammed was born in the sixth, what "sects" were killing each other during those two hundred years? Please be specific.
lagoMatamoros: I think that you are missing my point entirely. Just as I refuse to play what I refer to as "the Bible game" with conservative Christians, so will I refuse to play this game with you. I did not, and will not, debate specific passages of any revealed religious text. I believe that such efforts are both useless and futile.
Yes, never use facts in a debate/discussion, and whatever you do, never, ever use a religion's authoritative texts in analyzing that religion!

It's so much more edifying just to make things up.
My point, which you apparently did not get,
Again blaming the victim. How honest of you!
People have some strange desire to point out how much more intolerant Islam is than any other religion that could possibly be. I assert that this is not the case; rather, there are plenty of religions that are comperably intolerant. I chose Christianity because it is comperable to Islam both in size and geographical spread. I think that we have all agreed on this comparison, yes?
No, that's a tu quoque argument, a logical fallacy. If the topic is whether or not Islam is intolerant, discussing any other religion has absolutely no bearing whatsoever on determining an answer.

If you want to compare religions, you may, but if you rule out using their foundational documents to evaluate them, all you have left is human behavior which may or may not reflect accurately their gods' wills.

Feel free to argue from ignorance, but you will not find such a comparison beneficial to Islam since it has raped, enslaved, and slaughtered hundreds of millions (billions?) of non-Muslims in the name of Allah since Mohammed first began the bloodshed nearly fourteen hundred years ago.

And your Religionists of Peace have carried out around the world nearly 10,000 attacks since 9/11 alone.
To quote rabello
Do you really want to cite rabello? He was eviscerated by an exceptionally skilled (yet restrained) member in the "Why revile Muslims?" thread on the old board.
those who are so ready to point out the intolerance within Islam do no such justice to religions like Christianity.
That's because Christians are not running around raping, enslaving, and slaughtering non-Christians in the name of Jesus.

Neither do you find any commands from Christ to "kill the unbelievers wherever you find them" (Qur'an 9:5), or to, "Fight against the people . . . until they pay the jizya with willing submission and feel themselves subdued" (Qur'an 9:29).

Which is, of course, why you won't go to the texts. As long as you avoid addressing them, you can say, "What about McVeigh?" (not a Christian) in hopes that no one notices that for every Western nut violating Christ's commands, there are ten thousand Muslims obeying Allah and imitating Mohammed as they slaughter infidels.
I, and many others, call this discriminatory.
Which indicates that you've don't have any substantive (read, "fact-based") argument to make in defense of Islam.
If you want to flood the debate/discussion board with flame posts, fine, its your time and energy. But I will continue to disagree with you in principal until I see you posting like this on the board of every major religion.
That's several falsehoods in one.

First, I am not "flooding" the board.

Second, neither are my posts "flames." I cite the word of Allah and the example of Mohammed in explaining the teachings and practices of those who want to "fight until all religion is for Allah."

Third, it is illogical to say that one's criticism of A is invalid unless one criticizes similarly B through Z, whether or not the others deserve such criticism.

Fourth, to say "I will continue to disagree with you in principal until I see you posting like this on the board of every major religion." is an admission that your only basis for disagreeing is not what the religion actually teaches and practices, but emotion.
My question to you: what is so special about Islam that it deserves the dubious pleasure of all this attention? Why not devote this much anger to the sects of other religions that cause untold pain and suffering on a daily basis?
To answer your second question first: Name one religion that causes "untold pain and suffering on a daily basis." There's only one, and that's the one the god of which commands the faithful to "cause untold pain and suffering on a daily basis" until "all religion is for Allah."

And as for the first, the answer is noted above. The squeaky genocidal mass-murderer gets the grease.

No major religion's adherents rape, enslave, and slaughter those who refuse to convert or submit to their god but Islam.

Worse than that, the will of Allah and the example of Mohammed require such violence:
"the Messenger of Allah . . . would say: 'Fight in the name of Allah and in the way of Allah. Fight against those who disbelieve in Allah. Make a holy war. . . . When you meet your enemies who are polytheists, invite them to three courses of action. . . . Invite them to (accept) Islam . . . If they refuse to accept Islam, demand from them the Jizya . . . If they refuse to pay the tax, seek Allah's help and fight them . . .'" (Muslim Book 19, Number 4294).

"fight and slay the Pagans wherever ye find them, and seize them, beleaguer them, and lie in wait for them in every stratagem (of war) . . . " (Qur’an 9:5).

"Fight those who believe not in Allah nor the Last Day, nor hold that forbidden which hath been forbidden by Allah and His Messenger, nor acknowledge the religion of Truth, (even if they are) of the People of the Book, until they pay the Jizya with willing submission, and feel themselves subdued" (Qur'an 9:29).

"Allah's Apostle said: 'I have been ordered (by Allah) to fight against the people until they testify that none has the right to be worshipped but Allah and that Muhammad is Allah's Apostle . . . '" (Bukhari Volume 1, Book 2, Number 24).

“Allah’s Apostle said, ‘I have been made victorious with terror.’” (Bukhari Volume 4, Book 52, Number 220).

Thursday, October 4, 2007

Not "reviling Muslims," just pointing out the commands of Allah and the example of his apostle

From here (at least for a while):
PM,
"Iago, you're off-base."
Let's see . . . .
"The religions 'of the book'"
This is a false Islamic construct used by Mohammed and his followers to try to persuade Jews and Christians to "revert" to Islam. That it also misleads those ignorant of the religions' authoritative texts into believing that Islam and Christianity are morally equivalent is amply demonstrated here.
"have a conundrum because 'the book' (no matter which one you're using) is riddled with contradictory statements, layers of history and dubious authorship."
A demonstration of that false moral equivalence just noted. Only the ignorant and the deceitful can make such a claim.

What statements from the Bible are contradictory? On what basis do you characterize either religion has having "dubious authorship"? What does the phrase "layers of history" mean?
"The b-i-b-l-e is so full of violent calls to holy war it's astounding. . . . Ephesians 6:10 - 13 . . . A close reading of this text will reveal that this is spiritual warfare . . . ."
As you admit, this is no call to "holy war," so you've already contradicted yourself and failed to support your charge.

Neither does this text require "a close reading" to understand it is speaking of spiritual matters, since it plainly says it!

More importantly (and to the point), do you have any Biblical passage that actually commands offensive warfare to make the world Hebrew? Christian?

No.

I've shared a few from Qur'an and Hadith. Unless you can produce the equivalent from Holy Writ, it must be concluded you're just making things up.
"Well... since the crusades, I guess."
Another false equivalence built on a foundation of historical illiteracy.

The essential difference between the Crusades and jihad is that the first Crusade was called in response to a desperate plea for help by eastern Christians under attack by . . . Islam.
"The same is true of the Quran. A close reading of the Arabic, in context, reveals the spiritual nature of the quotes you pulled (a reading neither you nor I are qualified to make, imho)."
So, you are not qualified to make such a call, yet you make the call.

Demonstrate from the texts where I've misrepresented any of them.
"Moreover, those statements are directly contradicted in other sections of the Quran. It is up to the devout to understand which excerpt to apply when, and to what extent."
And the devout resolving such contradictions would end up with what? Do you know?

The doctrine of Naskh, or Abrogation. Islam has traditionally interpreted the later revelations for offensive jihad to have abrogated the earlier verses speaking of cooperation and peace.
"The fact is that religious and philosophical communities are inspired and directed by flesh and blood leaders in real-time."
That is true. And any person or community of people may or may not accurately represent their religion. This is exactly why a person must go to a religion's founder and sacred texts if they want to have an accurate portrait of that faith.
"And in our current historical context, there are two men who can be "thanked" for the fundamentalism prevalent in both western and muslim society. . . For Islam there was Sayyid Qutb."
From where did Qutb derive his doctrines? How is it possible to call his ideology "fundamentalism" unless those teachings are "fundamentals" of Islam?
"The statement that this is a conspiracy theory not worthy for this board is ridiculous. The notion that Shiite and Sunnis have spilled more blood than Protestants and Catholics is... childish and unreal and blind to the facts."
Speaking of childish, unreal, and blind . . . for how long have Sunni and Shia slaughtered each other? Catholics and Protestants? From where do the sources of such conflict derive?

The split in Islam occurred after Mohammed's death over 1300 years ago. There was no Catholic/Protestant split until the sixteenth century.

Allah commands "kill the unbeliever wherever you find them . . . ," but Christ commands, "Love your enemies."
"There is no ideological basis for the current conflict."
You've never read Qur'an, Sira, or Hadith. How can you make such a claim? Rather than propagate your own enlightenment to receive praise from others equally unfamiliar with the texts, why not study?

Since 9/11 Muslims have carried out over 9,000 terrorist attacks around the world. For 1350 years before that event, Islam has enslaved and murdered Jews, Christians, Zoroastrians, Hindus, Buddhists, animists, and assorted other pagans throughout Arabia, the Holy Land, the Middle East, Western and Eastern Europe, North Africa, and Asia.
"There is a hyped-up fear-mongering propaganda campaign, equally enacted on both sides for the identical reason."
You dismiss the clear word of Allah and the example of his apostle, muddy-up the clear word of Christ, and then claim "both sides" are "identical."
"Why Revile Muslims?"
Don't. Tell the truth about the Source and Sustenance of nearly fourteen centuries of offensive jihad to make the world Islam: the command of Allah and the words and deeds of his apostle.
"And until we get over this animalistic fight-or-flight response, we are enslaved."
Unless we wake up to the threat posed by jihad in service of Shari'a, we will end up with the same fate as countless non-Muslim civilizations before us -- enslaved or dead.
"A core tenant of post modernism (and beliefnet) is the understanding that every individual perspective (or "truth claim") IS equivalent."
That's false on several counts.

First, you're arguing that "All claims of truth are equivalent" IS equivalent to "All claims of truth are not equivalent." Second, BeliefNet bans people for posting Islamic texts. Third, how can you have any meaningful "debate" if everyone is right?

Finally, Allah calls non-Muslims like you "accursed," fodder for "hell-fire" (Muslim Book 37, Number 6666), and worth only a third of a Muslim (Muwatta Book 43, Number 43.15.8b). If you're a Jew, it's even worse. In addition to all that, you're also descended from apes and swine (Qur'an 2:65).

But, hey, everyone's right, right?
"Accusing me of moral equivalency is therefore a compliment to my position."
'Nuff said.
"I find fault in your attacks on Islam."
Stating Islamic "sacred" texts is an "attack"?

What does that say for what *you* conclude about those passages? Are you some kind of Islamophobe?
"The notion that Islam may be "defeated" or "wiped out" is a dangerous one."
I just scanned my two previous posts. Where did I write that?
"It leads to wrong-headed avenues, hard-lined beliefs in an ultimate right and wrong. Eventually it leads to camps."
That's a problem with false moral equivalences. Try as you might, reality eventually leads to unavoidable questions of "ultimate right and wrong."

(And speaking of camps, what do you know about dar al-Islam and dar al-Harb? How can such a distinction arise at all if Islam is all about "peaceful inner-struggling"?)

So, was the Holocaust right or wrong? You (and, according to you, BeliefNet) would claim of course that Hitler's truth was just as true as the truths of those 6,000,000 innocents slaughtered by his hand.

Is the enslavement, rape, and slaughter of millions of Sudanese Christians, animists, and black Muslims by the Arab-Muslim government and its allies right or wrong? (You know what that "compliment to your position" requires you to say!)

What other sorts of crimes against humanity must you defend in order to maintain your enlightened posture of moral equivalence? Slavery? Rape? Infanticide? Pedophilia? Genocide? The Ten Commandments?
"For contradictions in the bible, just google those two words and be amazed."
Yes, Google is the final arbiter of truth. But I thought you said all truth is true?
"For one, find out who Joseph's father was. Matthew says one dude. Luke says another."
Have you compared the genealogies, or is that just what someone wrote?

(Don't you think one of those obviously deceitful, power-hungry Christians would have noticed this and fixed it sometime in the last two thousand years? And doesn't that argue for the Church's faithfulness in preserving the Texts?)

Are you aware that the major difference between the two genealogies to which you refer reflects their authors' intended audiences?

Matthew was writing to a Hebrew audience. He traces Christ's human ancestry through his step-father Joseph (His legal father) to Abraham, the father of the Hebrews. Luke, writing to a Gentile audience, traces back through Mary's side (His blood relative) to Adam, the father of all.

Are you also aware that the genealogies are not necessarily intended to be exhaustive? Matthew's traces 14 generations from Abraham to David, 14 from David to the Babylonian Exile, and 14 from the Exile to Christ. Genealogies in the ancient world served a purpose other than just to list names.

See the 10 names in the Genesis 5 genealogy and the 72,000-year reigns of three Sumerian kings.
"For dubious authorship, tell me who wrote which book."
Perhaps you've noticed that many of the New Testament documents have either the author's name in the title (i.e., the Gospels and several of the Epistles) or in their openings and/or closings. Paul and Peter confess authorship within the first few words of all their letters (except, perhaps, Hebrews).

The only New Testament document for which a solid attribution of authorship is difficult to make is Hebrews, but even there many think Paul may have been behind it.

The New Testament's authors (in the common order of the texts): Matthew, Mark, Luke, John, Luke, Paul, Paul, Paul, Paul, Paul, Paul, Paul, Paul, Paul, Paul, Paul, Paul, Paul, perhaps Paul, James, Peter, Peter, John, John, John, Jude, John.
"For 'layers of history,' tell me when each book was written. And what was the cut-off date?"
Within the lifetimes of their authors, which would put the last, Revelation, near the end of the first century, a.D. John writes that the revelation came to him when he was in exile on the Isle of Patmos.
"And how is it that some books are lying around, with the same cast of characters, but not included in the Canon?"
Do you refer to Apocrypha or the Gnostic gospels? Neither were considered Divinely-inspired by the Early Church. The Gnostic gospels did not appear until long after the last of the New Testament texts were composed.
"It's patently troublesome to base a belief system on a text."
I agree that just because something is written doesn't make it true. That doesn't mean, however, that all texts are false. Neither does it mean that we are unable to distinguish truth from falsehood (in a text or elsewhere).
"And its patently problematic to condemn a belief system based on texts you are not familiar with."
(Werent' you just doing that with the Bible? I guess consistency can be difficult for someone who wants truth to be true, unless he disagrees with it.)

I agree, which is why it is curious that you would argue from a position of -- as you admit regarding Qur'an and Sunnah -- ignorance.
"Your profile isn't much help, but I'm guessing you know as little about the Quran and Haditha as I do."
(Thanks for looking. Am I blushing?)

If I were willing to lie about Qur'an and Sunnah, why wouldn't I lie in my profile? If I wrote that I were a former Muslim with a doctorate in Islamic and Biblical studies, would you then believe me? If I were just an uneducated fisherman, would that make what I write less true?

You're engaging in an ad hominem argument. If what I write is false, prove it. Otherwise, let us reason together.
"I will handily demonstrate your false readings of the texts. Only two, because space is limited. I snagged them from about.com:"
Actually, you're falling on your own sword, as I am about to "handily" show. :)
"one verse (in its snipped version) reads: 'slay them wherever you catch them' (Qur'an 2:191). But who is this referring to? Who are 'they' that this verse discusses? The preceding and following verses give the correct context . . . . It is clear from the context that these verses are discussing a defensive war, when a Muslim community is attacked without reason, oppressed . . . ."
The only problem is I've not quoted Surah 2. That verse's context is specifically defensive (although it should be pointed out that "oppression" is often understood to include even the mere existence of non-Muslims and their unbelief).
PM added,
"Another similar verse can be found in chapter 9, verse 5 -- which in its snipped, out of context version could read: 'fight and slay the pagans wherever ye find them, and seize them, beleaguer them, and lie in wait for them in every stratagem (of war).' Again, the preceding and following verses give the context."
What is the actual context of 9:5? Have you read it? Do you know what this verse is commonly called?

It's called, "the Verse of the Sword." I wonder how it got that name?

When you read Sura 9, do you understand that the clause citing "immunity" was for *only* those who kept their treaties with Mohammed? That it was an *exception* to the command for the slaughter of non-Muslims and only until the terms of those agreements expired?

Do you realize that Sura 9 (and the command for war) is understood traditionally to refer to the entire non-Muslim world, including Jews and Christians? Maududi makes the following observations regarding the historical background of Sura 9:
"...to make the whole of Arabia a perfect Dar-ul-Islam," "...to extend the influence of Islam to the adjoining countries," "...to crush the mischiefs of the hypocrites," and "...to prepare the Muslims for Jihad against the non-Muslim world."

"Now that the administration of the whole of Arabia had come in the hands of the Believers, and all the opposing powers had become helpless, it was necessary to make a clear declaration of that policy which was to be adopted to make her a perfect Dar-ul-Islam."

"A clear declaration was made that all the treaties with the mushriks were abolished and the Muslims would be released from the treaty obligations with them after a respite of four months."

"...In order to enable the Muslims to extend the influence of Islam outside Arabia, they were enjoined to crush with sword the non-Muslim powers and to force them to accept the sovereignty of the Islamic State."

"...The object of Jihad was not to coerce them to accept Islam they were free to accept or not to accept it-but to prevent them from thrusting forcibly their deviations upon others and the coming generations. The Muslims were enjoined to tolerate their misguidance only to the extent that they might have the freedom to remain misguided, if they chose to be so, provided that they paid Jizyah (v. 29) as a sign of their subjugation to the Islamic State."

"...In order to prepare the Muslims for Jihad against the whole non-Muslim world, it was necessary to cure them even of that slight weakness of faith from which they were still suffering. For there could be no greater internal danger to the Islamic Community than the weakness of faith, especially where it was going to engage itself single-handed in a conflict with the whole non-Muslim world."

"...a clear declaration was made that in future the sole criterion of a Muslim's faith shall be the exertions he makes for the uplift of the Word of Allah and the role he plays in the conflict between Islam and kufr. Therefore, if anyone will show any hesitation in sacrificing his life, money, time and energies, his faith shall not be regarded as genuine."

"In this portion the Muslims have been urged to fight in the Way of Allah with the mushrik Arabs, the Jews and the Christians, who were duly warned of the consequences of their mischievous and inimical behaviour."

"In this discourse, the Muslims have been told clearly and explicitly that they will inherit the rewards promised by Allah only if they take active part in the conflict with kufr, for that is the criterion which distinguishes true Muslims from hypocrites. Therefore true Muslims should take active part in Jihad, without minding dangers, obstacles, difficulties, temptations and the like."
Do you know that the traditional position of all four Sunni schools of jurisprudence (85% of Islam), Sahih Muslim, Sahih Bukhari, and other Muslim experts say that offensive warfare against non-Muslims is the Qur'an's final word on the subject? That 9:5, "abrogated every agreement of peace between the Prophet and any idolater"?

Again, immunity from slaughter belonged only to those who kept their part of a contract with Mohammed, and only for as long as that agreement was in effect.

Outside of that -- even for the "People of the Book" -- only subjugation and humiliation or war exists.

What do you do with the rest of Allah's revelation and Mohammed's example? Consider:
"the Messenger of Allah . . . would say: 'Fight in the name of Allah and in the way of Allah. Fight against those who disbelieve in Allah. Make a holy war. . . . When you meet your enemies who are polytheists, invite them to three courses of action. . . . Invite them to (accept) Islam; if they respond to you, accept it from them and desist from fighting against them. . . . If they refuse to accept Islam, demand from them the Jizya. If they agree to pay, accept it from them and hold off your hands. If they refuse to pay the tax, seek Allah's help and fight them . . .'" (Muslim Book 19, Number 4294).

"Fight those who believe not in Allah nor the Last Day, nor hold that forbidden which hath been forbidden by Allah and His Messenger, nor acknowledge the religion of Truth, (even if they are) of the People of the Book, until they pay the Jizya with willing submission, and feel themselves subdued" (Qur'an 9:29).

"Allah's Apostle said: 'I have been ordered (by Allah) to fight against the people until they testify that none has the right to be worshipped but Allah and that Muhammad is Allah's Apostle . . . '" (Bukhari Volume 1, Book 2, Number 24).

“Allah’s Apostle said, ‘I have been made victorious with terror. The treasures of the world were brought to me and put in my hand’” (Bukhari Volume 4, Book 52, Number 220).
PM continued,
"Who are you to tell others what the truth is?"
But you said all truth is true. Doesn't that include my truth? Who are you to tell me what the truth is?

(Moral relativism is a double-edged sword, isn't it?) :)

Actually, what I've done is cite Qur'an and Hadith, and rather than demonstrate I've erred in that, you've only demonstrated an unfamiliarity with the Biblical and Islamic texts.
"Is Catholicism wrong on all counts because of the molestation? No. Is the molestation criminal? Yes."
A red herring. A tu quoque.

The obvious difference (sorry, obvious to those who reject Absolute Moral Relativism) is that molestation is not only illegal in Western societies, it is forbidden by Christ.

On the other hand, in Islam you've got Mohammed telling his favorite wife Aisha that he began raping her when she was nine because Allah ordained it (Tabari 9:131; Bukhari Volume 9, Book 87, Number 139-140; and many others).
"Is a Muslim wrong because his text can be taken piecemeal by sociopaths and twisted into perversions?"
You've not demonstrated yet that any mujahideen are taking any verses out-of-context. Do you have any evidence for that claim?

Do you have any evidence that I've misrepresented anything?
"No. The text isn't wrong. The sociopath is wrong."
But I thought everyone's truth was true?

So, there's nothing wrong with the texts just noted?
"And the way to remedy the situation is to BE FOR SOMETHING and not AGAINST ANYONE. That something is peace, tolerance, understanding... in a word: love."
"Love" lies about hellish commands to convert, enslave, and kill all non-Muslims to make the world Islam?

Perhaps it's time for a new definition of the word.
"Sure there are criminal Muslims. There are criminal Jews. There are criminal Blacks. . . ."
Islam is not a race, it is an ideology.

And as for the jihadist who kills non-Muslims because Allah and his apostle say "kill non-Muslims," who are you to call him "criminal"? Is he not just following his own equally-valid truth?
"Ask yourself: do I know who Leo Strauss is and what he stands for? Do I know who reveres his teachings and attempts to exert his world-view? Do I know who Bin Laden's mentor is? And his mentor's mentor?"
Instead ask yourself: Who is waging offensive warfare against those who reject their ideology in fulfillment of their deity's "sacred" texts?
"How did this madness begin? It didn't begin in the book. It began in the men, and the men went and found what they needed in the book."
But I thought you said men wrote the books. And I thought you said their truth is also true.

Who are you to call their truth "madness"?
"What is your beef with moral equivalency? I really want to know. You use it like an insult and I just don't get it? Don't we use metaphors and historical allusions to... you know... learn and not repeat mistakes?"
True is true. False is false. We can and *should* learn from the past.

Ironically, you have been advocating ignoring jihad's past (and present) in Qur'an and Sunnah by attributing it to madmen and sociopaths taking verses out-of-context.
"and pps I hope nobody takes down your post. I found it insightful, on topic, all that good stuff. It's very instructive to hear the other side on this issue."
Thanks for the kind words. I hope we can continue this discussion.
Later,
"First, a critical distinction should be made. . . . swirling around the spiritual world of truth."
You have no evidence for that.

I agree that there is a difference between the physical and the spiritual realms, but I vigorously oppose the idea that there are different, contradictory "truths." Objective Truth is true regardless of whether many, one, or none confess it.

When I've heard that particular argument before it has been used by those seeking to dismiss Christ's claims to being the Truth.

(This is one reason that the Neo-Darwinian creation myth is both so popular and so dangerous. Either YHWH created all that exists as He says He did, or it came about by accident, disease, and death as Neo-Darwinism claims.)
"Spiritual texts are a bridge to get the physical onto a philosophical track. All the religious paths lead to the truth."
So, those who worshiped Teutates by drowning their human sacrifices, their path led to truth?

Followers of Molech, who as part of their devotion offered their little children to a fiery death in the arms of their god, their path led to truth?

Those who wage offensive warfare against non-Muslims who refuse to convert or submit to degradation and humiliation as commanded by Mohammed (Muslim Book 19, Number 4294), their path leads to truth?

Those who believe absolutely, "Allah's Apostle said, 'The Hour will not be established until you fight with the Jews, and the stone behind which a Jew will be hiding will say. "O Muslim! There is a Jew hiding behind me, so kill him"'" (Bukhari Volume 4, Book 52, Number 177), their path leads to truth too?

Does this path lead to truth: "Say to the Unbelievers, if (now) they desist (from Unbelief), their past would be forgiven them; but if they persist, the punishment of those before them is already (a matter of warning for them). And fight them on until . . . there prevail . . . faith in Allah altogether and everywhere . . ." (Qur'an 8:38, 39)?

What about this: "Allah's Apostle said: 'I have been ordered (by Allah) to fight against the people until they testify that none has the right to be worshipped but Allah and that Muhammad is Allah's Apostle . . . '" (Bukhari Volume 1, Book 2, Number 24). Does that lead to truth?
"In physics, this same concept was discovered by Albert Einstein. Basically, there is no favored position or perspective. All perspectives are in motion. From foot the train is going by very quickly, in a car it is actually going backward. Both perspectives are "true." All it takes is understanding to see why one sees it this way and the other that."
This is an odd confusion of two different categories of phenomena. You are describing two possible physical perceptions of a physical event, but this is not analogous to your "all roads lead to truth.”

That for which you are actually arguing would be:
-From foot, the train is going by very quickly,

-From foot, the train is going by very slowly,

-From foot, the train is not moving at all,

-From foot, the train is moving backwards,

-From foot, the train is floating in the sky,

-From foot, the train fell into a chasm,

-From foot, the train ran over a pedestrian,

-From foot, -- what train?
All at the same time and in the same place.
"The physical world is ruled by inalienable rights of "life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness" or some wording thereof. To hinder those is a crime, and punishable as such as determined by the prevailing culture."
That is not true. In some cultures, such “rights” are alienable. In fact, they are not recognized at all (or for only a few).

(Besides, how can you call anything a “crime” since everyone is right? And who are you to condemn someone else's truth?)

Only one culture in the history of Man has formulated such a statement of belief, and that was the one founded on the Christian religion. Quite a few other cultures have no problem enslaving, raping, and murdering those who refuse to submit to their ideology (Communism, Nazism, and Islam, for example).
"There have always been, and will always be, corrupted and false teachers who distort spiritual and philosophical texts to justify crime."
If, as you say all religious paths lead to truth, how can you call anyone “corrupted” or “false”? If their truth is true, how can you call what they (allegedly) do to their texts “distortion” or a “justification of crime”?

(By the way, you've still not demonstrated the Islamic texts I've cited as having been misrepresented.)
"It will always be incumbent on the world spiritual community to point out and rectify the false understandings and penalize those involved in criminal activity."
A part of that "world spiritual community" believes it is their Allah-given duty to war against you if you refuse both the "invitation" to Islam and the demand to pay the jizya (just as Mohammed commanded. See Muslim Book 19, Number 4294).

In light of this, how can there be any consensus on what "criminality" means?

And if, as you say, their path also leads to truth and is beyond criticism, how can you call their understanding "false" or their activity “criminal”?
"There is an infinite tangle of paths . . . Each and every one leads without exception to the truth."
Really?

Does this one lead to truth: "Fight those who believe not in Allah nor the Last Day . . . until they pay the Jizya with willing submission, and feel themselves subdued" (Qur'an 9:29)?

How about this one: "O ye who believe! fight the unbelievers who gird you about, and let them find firmness in you: and know that Allah is with those who fear Him" (Qur'an 9:123)?

Or this one: "The punishment of those who . . . strive with might and main for mischief through the land is: execution, or crucifixion, or the cutting off of hands and feet from opposite sides, or exile from the land . . . " (Qur'an 5:33)?

Or this: "It is not for any prophet to have captives until he hath made slaughter in the land. Ye desire the lure of this world and Allah desireth (for you) the Hereafter, and Allah is Mighty, Wise" (Qur'an 8:67)?

How about this: "Whoever changed his Islamic religion, then kill him" (Bukhari Volume 9, Book 84, Number 57)?
"Every human has a legitimate and personal relationship with the ineffable source."
Really? What is your evidence for that?
"Don Miguel Ruiz puts it well . . . ."
Mr. Ruiz equates Christ and Allah. Are they really morally equivalent?

One God committed no sin, healed the sick, raised the dead, and commanded, "Love your enemies."

The other ordained the habitual raping of a nine-year-old child by his fifty-something-year-old prophet (Bukhari Volume 9, Book 87, Number 139-140), approved slavery, rape, theft, deceit, and murder, and commanded unending offensive warfare against all who refuse to submit to its rule (Bukhari Volume 1, Book 2, Number 24; etc.).

Defending the latter as "an unquestionably true path to truth" is itself a special kind of craven immorality, is it not?

Advocating obviously false moral equivalences causes those who should defend it to question whether or not the civilization that produced Shakespeare, Mozart, Michelangelo, the Moon Landing, the Declaration of Independence, and the Bill of Rights is even worth defending.

It makes a Republic that defends the unalienable Rights of all human beings to Life, Liberty, and the pursuit of Happiness no better than Ahmadinejad's child-raping, stoning-rape-victims-for-adultery, "Kill-the-Jews"-chanting hell.
Still later,
“You defended the bible, but not terribly well. Mark and Luke didn't even know Jesus.”
Thoroughly answering all your objections constitutes an inadequate defense?

The other authors of the New Testament – Matthew, John, Paul, James, Jude, and Peter – did know Him. That means you believe them, right?

Mark and Luke composed their Gospels from eyewitness accounts. Their relying on others' firsthand testimony is insufficient reason to reject them.

(Ironically, Moral Relativism is a belief system that rejects critical thought, judgment, logic, evidence, and moral courage. It's just a “swirling mass of unassailable spiritual truth to which all religious paths lead without exception – except, of course, for Christianity.”)
“There's a whole forum on here called the Jesus Seminar where they break down that basically everything we think Jesus said and did he didn't really say or do.”
So much for that “swirling mass of unquestionable truth.”

Where's the Mohammed Seminar where “they break down that basically everything we think Mohammed said and did he didn't really say or do”?

Isn't that an interesting illustration of the reality of our situation? If Christ is attacked, Christians forgive, tolerate, ignore, or refute it. If Mohammed is attacked, people die and buildings burn.

Why is it that the only time Muslims protest in large numbers it's not over their daily, global violence against non-Muslims, it's over cartoons about Mohammed or a quote from a fifteenth century emperor whose great city was under siege by their co-religionists, to whom it fell in just a few decades?

The Jesus Seminar has been around a long time. They make claims for which they have absolutely *no* evidence. Where are the documents from which they say the Gospels are derived?

They don't exist, yet we have several thousand ancient manuscript copies of entire and partial New Testament texts. Homer's Iliad, the second best-attested-to text from Antiquity, has only a few hundred.
“There are basic inconsistencies like the fact that Matthew 1:16 says Joseph's father is Jacob and Luke 3:23 says Joseph's father is Heli.”
Addressed [above].
“These are just a few of the hundreds of apparent contradictions in the bible. I say apparent and I mean it because someone within the tradition, using the bible as the tool to truth, can maneuver and interface with the text to get to the spirituality they're longing for.”
(“a few”? Not even one.)

Which implies they're being dishonest.

How is approaching the Biblical texts with careful attention to the historical, cultural, and linguistic factors that help us determine the texts' actual meanings “maneuvering”?

Do you see the bias, the hypocrisy? When Christians read their texts and find Christ, the Truth Who said, “Love your enemies,” they're “maneuvering.” When Muslims read their texts and find jihad, they're “distorting.”

Moral relativism is an enemy of truth.
“To an outsider, Leviticus is CRAZY. If a priest's daughter is a whore, she has to be stoned to death. In Exodus 'thou shalt not suffer a witch to live.'”
Capital punishment under the Mosaic Covenant was administered for a number of crimes that today are glorified in pop culture and defended as Constitutional rights.

It should be noted (for all who want to equate Islam with Israel) that those punishments were only for the Hebrews of Ancient Israel living under that Covenant who broke *their own* laws.
“And I can't count how many times in the old testament God helped the Israelites conquer other tribes through warfare.”
Sounds like someone who's actually read the Old Testament except that, you can count them.

Forty years after being delivered from slavery in Egypt, Israel was commanded to enter the land promised to their ancestors. They were commanded to kill everything in order to remove false theology, to demonstrate to the “My god is bigger than yours” nations around them that their God really was bigger, and to carry out Divine judgment against those peoples for their great wickedness.

Israel ended up disobeying, following Canaan's false gods, and being destroyed.

It is worth noting that, according to you, “Leviticus is CRAZY,” but “sociopaths distort Qur'an,” and, “All truth is true,” but there are “hundreds of contradictions in the bible [sic].”

Apparently, your moral relativism is only a single-edged sword. :)
“Now a well-versed Jew could explain to me why prostitutes today should not get the death penalty. There is probably a more relevant text later that supercedes the ancient Leviticus.”
“Probably”? If “probably,” how do you know a “well-versed Jew” can explain it?

(I did just a moment ago.)
“I know a Christian would say that Christ's new message of love trumps the old laws (although that book is still included in the Christian canon).”
Only if that Christian is ignorant of the Word of Christ.

The New Testament makes very clear that the Mosaic Covenant has been replaced (fulfilled) by the New One written in Christ's blood (an interesting, not coincidental connection between the ancient making of covenants, the sacrificial system under Moses, the our Lord's Supper, and His sacrificial death).

Recall the adulterous woman Christ saved from stoning. After pointing out the hypocrisy of her accusers, He only told her to stop sinning.
“An irresponsible critic would say 'The bible is false teaching!' because it contains these lines that can be taken out of context.”
How do you know those lines are taken out of context? By reading the texts. Still you have not demonstrated that I've misrepresented any of Islam's.
“To sum up, your point here and on your blog seems to be that Islam is a violent religion and worthy of revulsion.”
My point here has been, “This is what Allah commands. This is what Mohammed – described by Allah as a “beautiful pattern of conduct” -- commanded, practiced, and permitted.

The point on my 'blog has been, "We destroy arguments and every lofty opinion raised against the knowledge of God, and take every thought captive to obey Christ." -Paul of Tarsus, 1st century a.D.

One of those is Mohammed's blasphemy. Another is Moral Relativism.
“My argument is that this claim is based on ignorance and every instance of what appears to be textual proof of Islam's violent nature can, when placed in context, be revealed as wisdom.”
Prove it.

Whose claim is based on ignorance? I cite sura, ayah, and hadith, but you admit knowing nothing of Qur'an and Sunnah (and demonstrate no awareness of 1400 years of jihad to make the world Islam).

Demonstrate a Biblical contradiction. Show that I've misrepresented any of the Islamic texts I've cited.

If you do not (and you can't), then your arguments must be regarded as insubstantial as a “swirling mass of spiritual 'truth.'”

Good luck revealing the wisdom of: “Allah's Apostle said: 'I have been ordered (by Allah) to fight against the people until they testify that none has the right to be worshipped but Allah and that Muhammad is Allah's Apostle . . . '" (Bukhari Volume 1, Book 2, Number 24).
More from PM:
But I'd like to respond to the Mod that my main perspective is that there is a false argument which goes, "We SHOULD revile Muslims because it says ____ here on page ___."
It should be clear that I have actually spoken against reviling Muslims.

It would be a grievous logical error to infer that I advocate treating Muslims in any way other than the way that I would want to be treated.

There are decent, moderate Muslims. Some recognize the calls for jihad in their religious texts and tradition and work to modify Islamic understanding of them.

Islam itself, however, is not moderate, as evidenced by the command of Allah and the example of Mohammed.
"The problem with this argument is that you can go to ANY spiritual tradition's text and lift lines out of context that are OUTRAGEOUS."
That is true.

The problem with your argument is that you've NOT demonstrated at all that I've taken any Islamic texts out-of-context.

The best you've been able to do is make up stuff about the Bible.

Demonstrate from Qur'an and Hadith that the texts I've quoted do not mean what they actually say.

Show from them that Mohammed didn't actually steal, lie, enslave, assassinate, rape, slaughter, and wage offensive war against non-Muslims (or command the faithful to do the same).
". . . how to word a) what I think is happening (with the incorrect textual analysis) and b) what I think should happen . . . ."
In response to a): One needs to actually familiarize himself with the texts and Islamic theology, jurisprudence, and history to be able to determine whether it is the "tiny minority of extremists-ists" or the "Islam is peace-ers" who distort the word of Allah and the example of his apostle.

With regard to b): Name a world Muslim leader (or school) who rejects utterly offensive jihad against non-Muslims, the superiority of Muslims over non-Muslims, and the institutionalized subjugation and humiliation of non-Muslims under Shari'a.

If Allah and his prophet actually command believers to wage offensive war against non-Muslims who refuse either to convert or pay the jizya (they do), then no possible response should be rejected out-of-hand.

Admit what the Islamic texts say, what Mohammed did, and what his followers have done in obedience to him and Allah.
"Attempting to censor me from quoting the bible or any other text in this discussion isn't helpful, imho."
Quoting the Bible in a debate on Islam is a non sequitur, a red herring, a tu quoque argument. All are logical fallacies and therefore unbecoming someone claiming to seek truth.
"Basically Iago is saying that Islam IS worthy of revulsion on the basis of armchair textual analysis."
Please do me the courtesy of attributing to me only what I've actually written.

I am saying, "This is what Qur'an and Hadith say: . . . ."

Your revulsion at "divine" commands for (and approbation of) slavery, theft, rape, murder, extortion, pedophilia, and genocide is something you must reconcile with your own "all religious paths without exception lead to truth" creed.

(By the way, for someone who's written post after post impugning my knowledge of Qur'an and Sunnah though admitting he knows nothing of them, "armchair textual analysis" seems a little too ironic, doesn't it?)
"Basically I'm saying that no, if you run that level of analysis on any of the powerhouse spiritual texts you'll come up with a handful of problems."
Really? You've only attacked the Bible. Not Qur'an, not Hadith. And what "handful of problems" have you found? Mark and Luke didn't meet Jesus.

No open-ended, universal commands to war against all Gentiles to make the world Israel. Not even a suggestion of warfare from the One Who commanded, "Love your enemies," and, "Do good to those who persecute you."

Even "armchair textual analysis" should produce something better than that, shouldn't it?
"The REAL reason we're being fed the scary muslim fairy tale is . . . .
An odd, immoral equivalence between people who VOTE and those who SLAUGHTER INNOCENTS.

But everyone's truth is true, right?

Perhaps that "scary muslim fairy tale" has something to do with nearly one and one-half millennia of the enslavement, rape, and slaughter of non-Muslims to make the world Islam.

Or 9/11 and over nine thousand terrorist attacks around the world since then.
"Further, their students made successful use of this strategy during the cold war with the USSR."
Yes, the Soviets were pacifists. Unfortunately, American leaders were no more cognizant then of with whom they were dancing in the pale moonlight than they are today.

In light of Qur'an and Sunnah, who is truly the "father of Islamic fundamentalism?" Here's a hint:
"Allah's Apostle said: 'I have been ordered (by Allah) to fight against the people until they testify that none has the right to be worshipped but Allah and that Muhammad is Allah's Apostle . . . '" (Bukhari Volume 1, Book 2, Number 24).
From PM:
"It's obvious that Iago isn't down with lateral thinking - he shoots down my references to apparent contradictions without connecting the dots to realize how easily a real Muslim could shoot down his."
"Apparent contradiction" means it only appears to be a contradiction.

You've produced no Biblical contradictions. You've produced no contradictions in Islamic "sacred" texts, either.

First, if you know nothing of Qur'an and Sunnah, how do you know at all what a "real Muslim" can demonstrate? Or how "easy" it would be?

How can you even define what a "real Muslim" is?

Second, you mischaracterize my *quotations* of Islamic texts as "apparent contradictions," but I've never written of contradictions. I've only quoted texts!

Third, you've not demonstrated that I've taken anything out-of-context.

Fourth, there are actual -- not apparent -- contradictions to the commands for unmerciful offensive warfare against those who refuse to convert or submit to Allah's rule. What do you know about them?

Early in Mohammed's prophetic career, when his movement was numerically, politically, economically, and militarily weak, the revelations he received regarding warfare consisted of cooperation and peace with non-Muslims.

Later, as he grew in power, the revelations evolved from allowing defensive warfare to *requiring* it.

Finally, at the end of his career and at the height of his power, the last of Mohammed's revelations regarding warfare (Sura 9) demanded ruthless offensive combat against all who refuse to convert or submit to Allah.

How does Islam deal with those earlier, peaceful passages that conflict with commands like The Verse of the Sword? The doctrine of Naskh. (Look it up.)
"You chose to name yourself after St. James the Moor Slayer?! . . . I don't know much about Catholicism. Apparently there's another Saint who's known as the Indian Killer, too. That's real cool, you guys."
But I thought "everyone's truth is true"? Don't "all religious paths lead without exception to truth"? Who "are you to question [my] truth"?

Be careful, your historical illiteracy is showing.
"Man, you've got to explain to me how that's ok. What would you do if I called myself Paranoid the Killer of Christians? You'd hit the freakin roof! . . . James, the moor killer. We live in a funny world."
Truthfully, you don't know how I'd react.

Though you "don't know much about Catholicism" and "nothing about Qur'an and Hadith," you don't mind hysterically objecting to my nom de plume.

Other than the English translation of his name and that he is a Catholic saint, what do you know about Santiago Matamoros?

Do you know that he was the patron saint of Spain? Do you know that he was only St. James until something happened to Spain in the 8th century? Who were the Moors? Why would Spanish Catholics care at all about them? Why would they add such a violent appellation to one of their saint's names?

After Mohammed's death, the followers of his new religion, in obedience to his and his god's commands and acting in accord with his example, exploded out of Arabia and throughout the Holy Land, Middle East, North Africa, Asia, and both Western and Eastern Europe raping, enslaving, and slaughtering those who refused to convert or submit.

Spain is in Western Europe. It was one of Islam's victims. It is one of the few Infidel states to regain its freedom from Allah. That is why you've heard bin Laden and other "extremists" use Al-Andalus (Andalusia) as both a lament and a call to arms.

Contrary to [. . .] multiculturalist historical revisionism/Islamic propaganda, there was no [. . .] "Golden Age" of Islam there. The native, Christian Spaniards [. . .] fought for over seven hundred years before finally throwing off the yoke of their Islamic oppressors.

In other words, St. James was believed to have helped the Spanish in their resistance to Islam's tyranny.

Since we are today facing a resurgent global jihad, it seems neither "funny" nor "freakin" to choose as a nom de guerre the name of someone attributed with defending Christians against Allah.

Choosing "Santiago Matamoros" is no less reasonable, timely, or defiant in the face of tyranny than using Charles Martel, Jan III Sobieski, or Manuel II Palaeologus . . . .

Histrionics at the name is the equivalent of objecting to someone calling himself, "Winston Churchill" or "G. Washington."
"Now we're getting into territory that really intrigues me! Which is: what do we do when the basis of a culture has flaws?"
Which would be off-topic.
"In a sense, every human endeavor faces this issue. Even we, the USA, have to live up to the fact that our founding documents did not count as full human beings slaves or females."
Also off-topic.

(By the way, the Constitution made that compromise for the purposes of representation, not a qualitative evaluation of anyone's humanity.)
"For those within the flawed culture, there are basically two positions . . . ."
Sounds pretty limited for an "all religious paths lead to a swirling mass of spiritual truth" kind of guy.
"I know you hate the moral equivalence of analogies"
Actually, I am opposed to false moral equivalences.

Analogies are just comparisons and when accurate, can be quite useful.
"but I can't help it) What would have happened if, for instance, a foreign power had invaded the US during the Civil War . . . .?"
Americans were warring against Americans. No foreign power's uninvited intervention would have been justified.

Which is of course, NOT analogous to Iraq or Afghanistan.
"Given that we (humanity) are moving from a generally less to a generally more enlightened state"
Only if a dog returning to its vomit can be considered "enlightened."

What evidence do you have of our "enlightenment"?

In the twentieth century, hundreds of millions of human lives were sacrificed on the altars of Nazism, Communism, and Islam, all of which are a form of fascism and reject Christ.

Tens of millions of Americans have been exterminated over the last few decades and one of our two major political parties defends such barbarity as a Constitutional right.

The principles of human equality and God-given Rights to Life and Liberty expounded in the Declaration and codified in the Constitution have been so consistently violated that nearly all our major political parties' leading presidential candidates espouse Socialism to one degree or another.

The institutions nominally-responsible for intellectual inquiry and governmental accountability -- higher education and the media -- are predominantly propaganda arms for any enemy of the American Republic crafty enough to yell "Racism!" or "First Amendment!"

And the religious tradition that led to the West's greatness is increasingly ignored, ridiculed, and rejected by its heirs.
"basically still a message of hate."
"Message of hate"?

Muslims kill in the name of Allah because he says, "kill the unbelievers wherever you find them." I point out that fact, but mine is a "message of hate"?

Such a false moral equivalence calls into question the judgment of the one making it.
"And I think holding this position closes the door on the forward motion we're looking for in the Islamic world."
How does lying about what Qur'an and Sunnah teach "move forward" the Islamic world? How can one reform that which one denies needs reformation?

Real progress within Islam must begin with acknowledging that which retards it.
"I'd also like to point out that jihad is an appropriated term . . . ."
A half-truth designed to deceive ignorant and gullible Infidels into believing "Islam is peace."

Who best defines "Islam"? Who better than Allah and his apostle? I've already shared a significant portion of their thoughts on this whole "offensive warfare" issue.

Yes, "jihad" means "struggle." Yes, one questionable hadith has Mohammed referring to the "greater jihad" being a struggling against oneself.

Did your Islamic expert tell you what the word for combat is? Qital.

Let's put your new, "enlightened" definition of "jihad" into the context of Qur'an and Sunnah:
-Does, "kill the unbelievers wherever you find them," really mean, "struggle against your ego the unbelievers wherever you find them"?

-Does, "Fight against . . . the People of the Book [Jews and Christians] . . . until they pay the jizya . . . and feel themselves subdued," really mean, "Struggle against your ego . . . until they pay . . ."?

-Does, ". . . invite them to Islam . . . If they refuse, demand the jizya.. . . If they refuse that, then fight," really mean, ". . . If they refuse that, then struggle against your ego"?

-Does, "I have been ordered to fight against the people until all confess that no one has the right to be worshiped but Allah and Mohammed is his apostle," really mean, "I have ordered to struggle against my ego against the people until all confess . . ."?

-Does, ". . . fight until all religion is for Allah," really mean, ". . . struggle against your ego until all religion is for Allah"?

-Does, "they fight in His cause, and slay and are slain" really mean, "they struggle against their egos in his cause, and slay and are slain"?

-Does, "I have been made victorious with terror," really mean, "I have been made victorious with struggling against my ego"?
There's more. Shall I continue?
"those preaching violent jihad against "the West" are essentially snake-oil salesmen, appealing to the basest human fears in order to prop up their desire for power."
That may be, but to what do they appeal in recruiting members of that "large majority of moderates"? Qur'an and Sunnah.
"paint Islam as a violent and dangerous religion."
Who's painting Islam as violent and dangerous but Muslims themselves?

Do not 3/11 (Madrid), 7/7 (London), Bali, Mumbai, Israel, Sudan, Somalia, Indonesia, Thailand, the Philippines, and all the other more than nine thousand terrorist attacks since September 11th paint that picture?

Do not Allah and Mohammed paint that picture themselves?

You keep trying to blame Islamic terrorism on neo-Conservatives. That is grossly inaccurate and immoral.
"To me, a message of hate cannot be erased with an equal and opposite message of hate."
How is reporting a message of hate itself hate? Does not such a usage make the word meaningless?
"I feel that there must be a solution which involved empowering and supporting those with more legitimate views."
"feel"? While you're feeling, Shari'a advances not only through terrorism, but also by demographics, litigation, da'wa, and the ballot box.

As for "legitimate," didn't you say that, "All religious paths without exception lead to spiritual truth"?

Those Muslims with more legitimate views find themselves at the business end of apostasy law. Mohammed said, "If anyone changes his religion, then kill him."
"And, more than anything else, getting our act together when it comes to invasions and occupations in the Arab world."
Finally, we get to the point you've danced around these many posts. President Bush's occupation of Iraq is responsible for 9/11.

Amazing. Not only is he too dumb to be president but smart enough to deceive the entire Democratic party, he's also powerful enough to cause global warming and retroactive mass slaughter in the name of Allah and in accord with Islamic "sacred" texts!
"It's called "The Girls of Riyadh"
But you read it just for the articles, right?

If one wants to know about Islam's "sacred" texts, one ought to read Islam's "sacred" texts.
"You have no faith that this correct knowledge exists in Islam. That's a real problem, a core pessimism that doesn't dissolve the issues we're facing but only exacerbates them."
I would suggest you reread my posts. I've not addressed contradictions in Islamic texs, real or imagined, until one of my last posts, and that was not in the context to which you keep appealing.
"You are very intent on textual analysis of work we are not familiar with!"
Are you using the royal "we," or are you again projecting onto me your "total ignorance of Qur'an and Sunnah?"
"You simply do not choose to hear that this is problematic from the very beginning."
It should be clear from my replies that I've heard quite well everything you've written. :)
"I have no working knowledge whatsoever of how to approach the Islamic spiritual texts - how they are understood, which to take in what order, etc."
Rest assured, you've demonstrated that!

How 'bout working next on that little "out-of-context" libel?
"I don't know enough about its context to talk about the specific meaning. But I will throw up instead a contradictory one:"
If you don't know its meaning, how can you offer one in contradiction?

Why not just stick with, "What does Allah say? What did Mohammed say and do?"

That would be much more intellectually honest, productive, and (literally) life-affirming.
"And dispute ye not with the People of the Book"
Perhaps you didn't have a chance to read my earlier comments on those Qur'anic texts that are traditionally understood by Muslims to contradict the later Verses of Blood.
"So a real Muslim has a problem - which verse is true-er? And a real Muslim will have the answer, too."
But you don't know what that is, right? There is one. It's called the doctrine of Naskh.
"Why will you not be honest about this yourself?"
I brought this up first in an earlier post and again in this one.

Perhaps it's better to read what someone writes before stating something false about them (of course, you've been doing that even when you've read my comments).

You're confusing actual Islamic contradictions (addressed in Muslim theology) with only alleged Biblical contradictions fabricated by the ignorant and the antagonistic.
"I . . . would be happily surprised to find out otherwise."
Argumentum ad hominem, another logical fallacy.

How about we do the intellectually honest thing and look at the texts?
"In a certain sense, I have to confess it does not matter."
I thought so. At least that's honest.
"You ask me to show from the texts you quote that "Mohammed didn't actually steal, lie, enslave, assassinate, rape, slaughter, and wage offensive war against non-Muslims (or command the faithful to do the same)."

"Well. No. I can't do that. But I bet someone can.""
That's called "wishful thinking."

You admit you don't know anything about Islam's authoritative texts and then bet on the basis of that ignorance.
"Or else 1 billion people wouldn't devote their lives to this religion."
That is another false dichotomy ("Islam is peace or it wouldn't have so many adherents").
"I don't know how else to do it, but could you prove the same for the following: "You shall devour all the peoples that the LORD your God is giving over to you . . . from Deut 7:16"
From its context, Deuteronomy 7:16 is a command for Israel to completely wipe out the peoples of Canaan.

However, it is not an open-ended command for offensive warfare to make the world Hebrew, as apologists for jihad and their useful idiots usually argue.
"I know, Mod, I know! No fair to quote the OT!"
What's truly unfair is the false moral equivalence.

And World Citizen didn't say it was unfair, just off-topic.
"What I'm getting from the Moor Killer is hatred of Islam on the basis of quotes pulled out of context."
You're getting Islamic texts, but you've not yet demonstrated that I'm taking any of them "out of context."

Are you going to do the intellectually honest thing and demonstrate the truth of your assertions, or will you retract them?

To do anything else just hurts your credibility.
"the dedication to this cause that you have, Moor Killer, is disturbing."
Telling the truth is disturbing?
"You keep mentioning the 1400 years of violent jihad. They've been a rough period for all humanity, indeed!"
Another immoral equivalence. That makes it not so bad, right?
"I'm sitting this very moment on the site of the largest genocide produced in the history of earth, the systematic destruction of untold millions of lives and erasure of entire civilizations, all for the slogan "God, gold and glory!"
Really, the 70 to 80 million Hindus killed by Islam?

Again, the point you're hoping to make by this, another false moral equivalence, is that Christ is just as bad as Allah.

The essential distinction is that nominally-Christian nations engaged in imperialism had no Biblical basis for such behavior, while offensive jihad to make the world Islam is permitted by Allah and his apostle, it is a duty!

But that disintegrates your "mass of spiritual truth," doesn't it?
"attacking a religion you do not understand is not helping the situation."
How is quoting from Islam's foundational texts "attacking Islam"? What does that characterization say about YOUR opinion of those texts? Are you some kind of Islamophobe?
"If you really want to know the spiritual meaning behind any of the quotes you pulled"
If you know nothing about Qur'an and Sunnah, how can you imply I do not know what they mean?
"After all, who is this James if there is no Moor Killing to do?"
Historical illiteracy is an ugly thing. Civilizational self-loathing is even uglier.
"Islam is worthy of ____"
Telling the truth about its texts.

As for a "Sufi revival," be careful of what you wish:
"Sufism as practiced in the Indian subcontinent was quite intolerant of Hinduism, as documented by the Indian scholar K. S. Lal:
'The Muslim Mushaikh [Sufi spiritual leaders] were as keen on conversions as the Ulama, and contrary to general belief, in place of being kind to the Hindus as saints would, they too wished the Hindus to be accorded a second class citizenship if they were not converted. Only one instance, that of Shaikh Abdul Quddus Gangoh, need be cited because he belonged to the Chishtia Silsila considered to be the most tolerant of all Sufi groups. He wrote letters to the Sultan Sikandar Lodi, Babur, and Humayun to re-invigorate the Shariat [Sharia] and reduce the Hindus to payers of land tax and jizya. To Babur he wrote, "Extend utmost patronage and protection to theologians and mystics... that they should be maintained and subsidized by the state... No non-Muslim should be given any office or employment in the Diwan of Islam... Furthermore, in conformity with the principles of the Shariat they should be subjected to all types of indignities and humiliations. They should be made to pay the jizya...They should be disallowed from donning the dress of the Muslims and should be forced to keep their Kufr [infidelity] concealed and not to perform the ceremonies of their Kufr openly and freely. They should not be allowed to consider themselves the equal to the Muslims" (The Legacy of Muslim Rule in India [1992], p. 237).
"Since that time, while researching my forthcoming book, The Legacy of Jihad, I have discovered that there are many other influential Sufis who shared, and who share today, these bigoted views. Sufi intolerance is clear from, most importantly, never-before-published translations of the great Sufi Al-Ghazali himself . . . as well as from statements by an important contemporary Shi'ite Sufi ideologue, Sultanhussein Tabandeh (Andrew Bostom)."
PM adds,
"uh huh... So Christ was for slavery? Equality for all!! (except if you're black or a woman that is) If history has taught us anything its that a belief in God has NOTHING to do with morality. Religion is probably the most evil concept man has ever devised."
If by, "So Christ was for slavery?" you're implying that He was not, you are correct: "It is for freedom that Christ has set you free" (Galatians 5).

If the Son of God is for human freedom and He created (or completed) His own religion, then how can all religion be "probably the most evil concept" ever created?

If the Christian religion inspired the essential truth of the Declaration of Independence -- "all men are created equal . . . they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights . . . ," then how can all religions be evil?

"Love your enemies" (Matthew 5), "treat others the way you want to be treated" (Matthew 7), "as you did it to one of the least of these my brothers, you did it to me" (Matthew 25), "the law is not made for a righteous one, but for the lawless and disobedient, for the ungodly and for sinners, for . . . slave-traders . . . " (1 Timothy 1).

Despicable!

Using the hypocrisy of a nation that preached Liberty but allowed slavery as an excuse to indict the religion that inspired its ideals is not wisdom.

Despite what many il-liberal institutions of "higher learning" propagandize, Christianity is not the Source of All Evil. Slavery has existed for as long as one group of human beings were powerful enough to subjugate another.

Christ recognized slavery's ubiquitousness. In this context, He commanded His followers who did own slaves to treat them as "beloved brothers" (Philemon 1). He also encouraged His followers who were slaves to serve in a way that would honor Him (Ephesians 6) but to gain their freedom if they could (1 Corinthians 7).

Why did slavery in America end? Because its predominantly Christian citizens ended it.

Finally, it seems unwise to argue that the only other alternative to religion -- atheism -- encourages moral behavior. Atheism's lack of morality allowed it to slaughter tens of millions of people in the twentieth century alone.
wontgetfooledagain offers,
"Christianity has a brutal and oppresive history. It even tried to keep Galileo and other scientists from spreading 'lies' and would force them to admit the 'truth'.... or else."
Criminal and unjust behavior by Christians does not make the faith itself "evil," as any cursory examination of its texts would indicate.
"It's kind of funny really... You could be a backwoods hick..but if you read the bible (or have someone read it for you and tell you what's in it)"
Must have hit a nerve.
"then suddenly you are smarter than all the scientists in the world."
First, not all scientists accept that Darwin's creation myth is even possible.

Second, you want to call "ignorant" those who believe that an omnipotent, omniscient God directly created Life. Here are some questions with which you might be able to help a "backwoods hick":
-What scientific (observable, testable, repeatable) evidence do you have that Life arises apart from Life or Life's programs?

-What actual empirical evidence do you have that by random genetic mutations alone newer, more complex genetic program and physical structures and functions can arise in an organism?

-Is not your faith that Life arose suddenly from non-life by random, natural processes alone -- and then somehow managed to survive normally lethal genetic mutations to form all Life -- irrational?
In other words, what do you know is empirically true about Neo-Darwinian evolutionary theory?
"Not only that...Christianity also has the nerve to tell the Jews that they don't know who to interpret their own Torah and have decided they know more about the OT than Jews do and only THEY could really know what God was trying to say."
To imply that "Jew" and "Christian" are two mutually-exclusive categories is absolutely false and indicative of an unfamiliarity with history.
-The Christian New Testament. Who composed its texts? Jews.

-The first Christians. Who were they? Jews.

-The first witness to Christ's resurrection. Who was he? No one. She was a Jewish woman.

-The Apostles. Who were they? Jews.

-The Promised Messiah, the Son of God. Who was He? The King of the Jews.
Before his conversion, one of the New Testament's authors, the Apostle Paul, was a Pharisee and referred to himself as a "Hebrew of Hebrews." He warned Gentile (non-Jewish) Christians to avoid arrogance for they had been "grafted into" the vine, of which Jews were the natural branches.

If any Christian speaks arrogantly to anyone, they violate Christ's teachings.

Telling the truth is not arrogance.
"Intolerant Christians trying to force their views of morality onto others."
Are you not now expressing intolerance? Are you not "forcing your morality onto others?"

Every society follows (to whatever degree) a set of moral codes. The question then is: Whose morality do we follow? That of atheism? Nazism? Communism? Islam?

The One who created the Ten Commandments and the Golden Rule, Who never sinned but only did good healing the sick, raising the dead, dying for the sins of all, and then rising from the dead Himself -- His morality seems like a wise choice.
"lago, You're doing a great job of destroying PM's ridculous arguments but this is not the board to discuss the 'human rights' track record of Christianity (which is abysmal)."
Whose record is good? The Assyrians'? Romans'? Greeks'? Islam's? China's? Aztec's? Japan's? Atheism's?

You seem to suggest that today in the West we respect human rights. From where did that respect come? It did not arise in a vacuum. It came from no other religious or philosophical tradition than Christianity.

The behavior of a religion's adherents must always be evaluated in light of its sacred texts. Only then can one determine whether or not someone is representing that religion faithfully.

Like all people, Christians have committed evil. When the power of the State was united with the Church, abuses occurred. Nominally-Christian states engaged in wars of expansion.

All of that was contrary to the teachings of Christ. None of it can be justified by His words or deeds.
"If you would like to debate Christianity I would like to invite you over to the Christian debate board....you will find me there."
Thanks for the invitation. I'll see how things go here. It looks like PM has replied. :)

Regards,

Iago
PM rejoins,
"I've put my points down pretty firmly, but no one with an ounce of humility is reading this post."
I imagine that's a jab at me.

Competence is not arrogance.

If you want to make a point in a debate, facts are often helpful.
"I'm happy to admit my deficiency in the Koran. I've read as much as will satisfy my curiousity and no more."
You admit to knowing nothing of Qur'an and Hadith. And now your curiosity is satisfied.

I would be happy to explain some of the basics in dealing with that material. No one reading it for the first time without the necessary background can be successful with it.
"Moreover, I haven't lived and learned from those practicing Islam, other than to know that many in the world do practice it, with success, and count Islam as their path to truth."
What is "success" in Islam? Must not it be defined in a way consistent with Mohammed's words and deeds?

When he says, "Fight . . . until all religion is for Allah," how does "success" look?

Are you really sure you want to subscribe to Mohammed's definition of it?
"The Moor Killer"
Are you unwilling or unable to appreciate the timeliness of recalling a hero of the West's resistance against jihad?
"To him, he is a full authority on the Koran and understands without fail every line."
Perhaps only in comparison to someone who knows "nothing" about it and refuses to learn but argues anyway.

Will you demonstrate where I've misrepresented any Islamic texts? If not, will you retract?
"Every line is to be taken at face value, with the translation given."
If you actually knew any of those "successful Muslims," you'd know that the texts are taken pretty much literally.
"That textual analysis of historical documents is not easy and shouldn't be done in a vacuum"
I agree.

But you're trying to do it without the documents.
"The Moor Killer has found troubling passages relating to violence. How will he resolve this difficulty? Will he engage with a Quranic scholar, work on gleaning the truth from the text, actually learn what the spiritual people have to say and separate the temporal historical topical meaning from the timeless wisdom?"
Have you?

As you admit, you don't know Qur'an and you don't care to learn. How then can you talk about doing anything with "timelessly wise Qur'anic scholars"?
"He'll get on the bullhorn and post like the authority he is."
Facts are to moral relativism as light is to darkness.
"Islam demands violence!"
I've cited Islamic texts.

Again, please have the courtesy to refer to what I've actually written.
"I've made references to Christian genocides, many of which had a baloney "scriptural" basis, in reaction to his references of Muslim genocides."
Making red herring and tu quoque arguments is not something about which to brag.
"His response is: 'Again, the point you're hoping to make by this, another false moral equivalence, is that Christ is just as bad as Allah.'"
Finally.
"Allah isn't bad. Evil men have misused these genuine spiritual paths for evil ends."
Mohammed confessed, "I have been made victorious with terror." Is that "genuinely spiritual" terror?

You're not saying Mohammed was "evil," are you?
"Hindu genocide is gnarly and unacceptable. Native American genocide is gnarly and unacceptable."
The former commanded by Allah and his apostle, the latter diametric to the person, work, and word of Christ.
"Take your name, the Moor Killer. To me, on the surface, that's an awful and hateful name. But there's a historical conflict I'm "illiterate" of, and from one perspective at least some Moors did need killing at a certain point in time, and there are meanings and references and layers of identity at work here and it's also mostly metaphorical and probably St. James would never ACTUALLY kill a guy, unless they REALLY deserve it, and on and on."
The actual St. James was an Apostle of Christ. Tradition has it that all the Apostles but John died violent deaths for their testimony. I too doubt he killed anyone.

As to being unfamiliar with the historical context of Matamoros, there's no shame in not knowing. All of us start there. The challenge you face here is now that you know the truth, will you admit it or persist in suicidal fiction?
"Without the subtext and footnotes, the name is pure hate"
In other words, "To the ignorant, the name is pure hate."
"Wishful thinking here: we've got to move this dialogue forward. We've got to understand that a few snipped sentences don't sum up an entire religion."
You've still not demonstrated I've "snipped" some sentences, and considering your admission of surrender to Qur'anic illiteracy above, I doubt you will.

(I would like to point out that I've never said that Allah and Mohammed's commands to war to make the world Islam "sums up the entire religion." It only sums up the parts relevant to non-Muslims' Rights to Life, Liberty, and the pursuit of Happiness.

And the structural integrity of their throats.)
"And super wishful thinking is that we could get onto the REAL topic: who benefits from the hateful attitude, here and abroad? Who taught them this very effective method of division? Where will it be played next?"
Allah,

Mohammed,

and everywhere, of course.
"There is - it's called love."
Love is not ignorance, nor is it silence in the face of evil.
"The question must be asked because websites like this exist:

www.littlegreenfootballs.com/weblog/"
Reporting on Islamic terrorism is "reviling Muslims"? That's an odd way of blaming the victim.

If Muslims stop slaughtering innocents in the name of Allah, then reports of their barbarism will cease.
"In responding to the slave-friendly nature of the Christian-inspired founding fathers"
Only some supported the institution. Political compromise was necessary to achieve unity in the struggle for independence against Great Britain.
"Now I'm pulling a number of your lines and placing them, out of context, side by side. I find it compelling . . . ."
That's intellectually honest.

Ever find evidence of my misrepresenting Qur'an and Sunnah?
"Criminal behavior does not make the faith itself evil. This is so difficult and so real. When the Inquisition is on, how can someone of conscience NOT consider Christianity evil?"
According to you, when a Christian does evil -- such behavior being DIAMETRIC to the command of Christ -- the religion is evil.

When Muslims enslave, rape, and slaughter non-Muslims to make the world Islam -- in FULFILLMENT of Allah's command and Mohammed's example -- it's "a religious path leading without exception to a swirling mass of truth."
"How can someone NOT believe that the texts themselves condone and even command the criminal?"
Read them.
"find the false understanding, find the bad teaching, and resolve it, refocus attention, and get over the madness. That activity has to take place from within the tradition, at a critical distance from the crime. The prevalent mind control has to be busted up, by those with an interest in improving and retooling the system."
How is that possible when Allah commands genocide and his "beautiful pattern of conduct" Mohammed preached and practiced it?
"Despite my latest appeal regarding the nature of textual analysis from outside a tradition, Iago would like to play the tit for tat game."
If it is impossible to understand a religious text unless you are a devotee of that religion, then it is impossible for you to make that argument since you wouldn't understand the texts well enough to know that no one else did either.

What you call "tit for tat" is actually addressing the facts.
"Give me the number one, bulletproof, surefire "Allah commands violence" piece of text."
I've provided not a few of them in this thread.

I thought you read my posts.
"I did this a little bit once, and you said I chose the wrong one and debunking it didn't mean anything. I've picked out an expert to consult with. I'll come back with the proper reading and shoot the surefire "Allah commands love" response."
You chose a passage on defensive warfare, and citing propaganda sympathetic to jihad meant to obfuscate it and The Verse of the Sword to non-Muslims is not "debunking."

As for your expert, is this person of a greater authority than Allah? Mohammed? Will he report accurately what Islam has traditionally understood and practiced regarding offensive warfare against non-Muslims, Shari'a, and dhimma? Will he admit that no major school of Islamic jurisprudence rejects offensive warfare to establish the tyranny of Allah over all mankind or the superiority of Muslims over non-Muslims?

Not even Sufism -- a revival of its ideology for which you expressed a fervent desire -- does that. I shared some information on this point with you earlier. Here's a little more:

Al-Ghazali was “acclaimed in both the East and West as the greatest Muslim after Muhammad."

Al-Ghazali on jihad and dhimma:
"[O]ne must go on jihad (i.e., warlike razzias or raids) at least once a year . . . one may use a catapult against them [non-Muslims] when they are in a fortress, even if among them are women and children. One may set fire to them and/or drown them...If a person of the Ahl al-Kitab [People of The Book – primarily Jews and Christians] is enslaved, his marriage is [automatically] revoked . . . One may cut down their trees . . . One must destroy their useless books. Jihadists may take as booty whatever they decide . . . they may steal as much food as they need . . . .

"[T]he dhimmi is obliged not to mention Allah or His Apostle . . . Jews, Christians, and Majians must pay the jizya [poll tax on non-Muslims] . . . on offering up the jizya, the dhimmi must hang his head while the official takes hold of his beard and hits [the dhimmi] on the protruberant [sic] bone beneath his ear [i.e., the mandible] . . . They are not permitted to ostentatiously display their wine or church bells . . . their houses may not be higher than the Muslim’s, no matter how low that is. The dhimmi may not ride an elegant horse or mule; he may ride a donkey only if the saddle[-work] is of wood. He may not walk on the good part of the road. They [the dhimmis] have to wear [an identifying] patch [on their clothing], even women, and even in the [public] baths…[dhimmis] must hold their tongue…. [2] (From the Wagjiz, written in 1101 A.D)" --Bostom
PM continues,
"We can do that for all your ammo. But one at a time, 'cuz I have a day job."
So, if you were independently wealthy, you'd somehow discover a curiosity for Qur'an and Hadith and then demonstrate that all the Islamic texts that command the slavery and slaughter of non-Muslims are really just talking about "peacefully struggling inwardly" toward that "swirling mass of truth"?

Note the Islamic Newspeak in this brief bit from scholar Bassam Tibi on how Muslims have traditionally understood Islam:
"At its core, Islam is a religious mission to all humanity. Muslims are religiously obliged to disseminate the Islamic faith throughout the world. “We have sent you forth to all mankind” (Q. 34:28). If non-Muslims submit to conversion or subjugation, this call (da’wa) can be pursued peacefully. If they do not, Muslims are obliged to wage war against them. In Islam, peace requires that non-Muslims submit to the call of Islam, either by converting or by accepting the status of a religious minority (dhimmi) and paying the imposed poll tax, jizya. World peace, the final stage of the da’wa, is reached only with the conversion or submission of all mankind to Islam…Muslims believe that expansion through war is not aggression but a fulfillment of the Qur’anic command to spread Islam as a way to peace. The resort to force to disseminate Islam is not war (harb), a word that is used only to describe the use of force by non-Muslims. Islamic wars are not hurub (the plural of harb) but rather futuhat, acts of “opening” the world to Islam and expressing Islamic jihad. Relations between dar al-Islam, the home of peace, and dar al-harb, the world of unbelievers, nevertheless take place in a state of war, according to the Qur’an and to the authoritative commentaries of Islamic jurists. Unbelievers who stand in the way, creating obstacles for the da’wa, are blamed for this state of war, for the da’wa can be pursued peacefully if others submit to it. In other words, those who resist Islam cause wars and are responsible for them. Only when Muslim power is weak is “temporary truce” (hudna) allowed (Islamic jurists differ on the definition of “temporary”)."
More from the thread . . . .
"Smell the bacon"
Pork.

Being an authority on Islam, you undoubtedly recognize such a remark as offensive to Muslims. Is that an Islamophobo-Freudian slip?
"There is a myth at work . . . The new bad guy . . . is the Islamic fundamentalist."
Those who preach and practice the slaughter of innocents is *not* a "bad guy"?

Shameful.

According to you, no 9/11. No Beslan. No London 7/7. No Madrid 3/11. No Bali. No Mumbai.

No genocide against the Black Christians, animists, and Muslims of Sudan. No Buddhist monks murdered. No Armenian Genocide. No nuns killed over a cartoon. No Pakistanis gunned down in front of their students for teaching females. No Indonesian Christian school girls beheaded for Allah.

No Copt teenage daughters kidnapped, raped, forcibly converted, and married into Islam whose fathers are greeted at police stations with "Don't worry. She's in the arms of Islam now." No journalists forced to confess their and their mother's Jewish ethnicity before having their heads torn from their necks.

No raping of the nuns dead on the floors of the Hagia Sofia. No Janissaries. No Banu Qurayza. No Asma bint Marwan. No Al-Andalus. No Siege of Vienna. No Battle of Tours. No Barbary Pirates. No Reconquista.

No jihad. No Shari'a. No dhimma.

No commands to, "Invite . . . demand the jizya . . . [or] fight" (Muslim Book 19, Number 4294).

No confession from Islam's "Ideal Man" that, "I have been ordered to fight against the people until they testify that none has the right to be worshiped but Allah and Mohammed is his apostle" (Bukhari Volume 1, Book 2, Number 24).

It's just one 1400-year-old, gigantic, worldwide myth aimed at defaming Islam.

If they had any decency, those Infidels would stop getting killed by Muslims. It's making Islam look bad.
"AM radio . . . LGF . . . every event or statement regarding Muslims into proof that they are evil and to be reviled."
Almost *no one* on AM radio has the intellectual integrity or moral fortitude to even approach the Islamic texts. LGF links to *news* agencies' reports on what Muslims do and say.

If they don't want others to know about their slaughtering Infidels, they ought to start killing in private.
"the Empire State building . . . lit be green for one night in honor of Ramadan. For people of the hateful mindset, even a simple gesture of inclusion like that"
Whose got a "hateful mindset," those protesting the honoring the ideology that slaughtered nearly 3,000 fellow New Yorkers just down the street, or those who support that bloodshed?
"innocent German citizen . . . the myth of the Islamic fundamentalist jihadist masses."
A billion people claim fealty to a god and prophet commanding them to wage offensive warfare against all who refuse to convert or submit (that many do not is attributable to ignorance, cowardice, apathy, and a lack of resources).

In every nation where Muslims have the power to vote, they choose Jihad.
"In my last post I offered an olive branch and opportunity to study with me to Moor Killer #1. And he won't have it!"
You know that is false, as does anyone who's read our exchange.

You asked me for "One verse, just one verse!" to dismantle with your Islamic "expert."

I've already given you not only many passages from Qur'an and Hadith, I've provided Islamic scholars much more authoritative, influential, and representative of traditional Islamic orthodoxy than any you could possibly find.

Unsurprisingly, you address none of that but instead choose to (again) falsely accuse me of wrongdoing.
"illegal conduct which masquerades as spiritual truth"
In Christianity, "illegal conduct" is recognized as "masquerading" because the Biblical texts prove it to be immoral.

In Islam, what you call "illegal conduct" (offensive jihad to subjugate the world to Allah) is not only permissible, it is required.
"I'm still waiting for one quote you'd like me debunk. I don't want to pick my own because when I did that the last time I picked the 'wrong one.'"
The quotation marks implying that it wasn't really wrong. You tried to use a verse on defensive jihad to prove I was taking out-of-context a verse on offensive jihad.

Your aversion to supporting your "argument" is becoming tedious. First, it was, "All religious paths lead without exception to a swirling mass of spiritual truth -- except yours." Then, it was, "You're taking verses out-of-context" (which is your admission that I've already given you the verses you claim now I'm withholding). Most recently, it's, "I want to study, but he won't!"

It's like Steve Martin from The Man with Two Brains, asking his dead wife for a sign that he shouldn't get involved with Kathleen Turner:
Martin: "Just give me a sign."

Dead wife: "No!" "No!" "NO!!!" "NOOOOOOOOOO!!!" [Painting spins violently on wall, lights flicker, house shakes.]

Martin: "Just any kind of sign. I'll keep on the lookout for it. Meanwhile, I'll just put you in the closet."
rabello jumps into the fray with . . .
"Sorry, IagoMatamoros, you are the one making nonstop, scurrilous charges against all Muslims, and all of Islam, itself"
Scurrilous? There is coarse, vulgar, and abusive language in my posts, but those are not my words; as you concede, I am just quoting Allah and his apostle.

And if I am quoting Islamic texts, how am I making "vulgar and abusive" charges against "all Muslims"? What does that say for what you believe about those passages?

Are you some kind of Islamophobe?
"with your repetitive copy/pastes of passages from the Qur'an that you've found somewhere"
Where? Qur'an and Sunnah.

First you accuse Allah and Mohammed of making "scurrilous" revelations; now you accuse me of not doing my own homework. How dishonest.

Without the knowledge to prove it (or the courage to admit your error), you falsely accuse me of misrepresenting Islam's "sacred" texts.

As for the repetition, that's called using relevant evidence to support your arguments.

You want to prove your tolerance and enlightenment by defending "divine" commands for offensive warfare until the whole world is subjugated to Allah.

That is scurrilous.
"The onus remains on YOU to prove that your interpretations of those copy/pasted passages are the ONLY correct interpretations in all of the world."
A red herring.

As you and PM have ably demonstrated, anyone totally ignorant of Qur'an, Sunnah, and 1400 years of jihad can interpret a confession like, "I have been ordered to fight against the people until they testify that none has the right to be worshiped but Allah and Mohammed is his apostle," to mean, "I have been ordered to peacefully struggle inwardly toward a swirling mass of spiritual truth until everyone confesses that all cars drive to Cleveland."

Next, you'll argue that when Mohammed bragged, "I have been made victorious with terror," he really meant, "I have been made victorious by baking cookies. Aren't cookies delicious?"
"The majority of Muslims across the world aren't doing that either. But why are we in Iraq, again?"
Another non sequitur. Have you ever met a logical fallacy you didn't want to use immediately to defend calls to genocide?

You can talk about numbers all you want. Because a person's behavior does not necessarily tell you anything about his religion, one must go to that religion's sacred texts and founder to understand the faith the way its god intended.

By one count, since 9/11 there have been nearly ten thousand terrorist attacks in the name of Allah. Is that a "tiny" number?

Of that large majority of Muslims who have not carried out offensive qital against non-Muslims, how many support it in other ways (financially, logistically, morally, spiritually, etc.)?

Of course, those numbers have not been my point. My point in citing Islam's authoritative texts relevant to the Life and Liberty of non-Muslims everywhere is . . . to cite those texts.
"We shall also conveniently ignore the war we brought onto the innocent people of Iraq"
Another non sequitur (with a hint of tu quoque), since I've not argued anything about Iraq. I've been reporting on Allah's commands and his prophet's example.

Saddam brought it. And we haven't warred against innocents. Saddam, his agents, and Muslim terrorists have been the targets.
"Abu Ghraib, Guantanamo, secret renditions"
Terrorists captured in battle. Hardly "innocent."
"all things that are certainly terrorizing to ordinary human beings."
They're not ordinary, they're monsters. If they don't want to be captured trying to kill Americans, perhaps they might stop trying to kill Americans.
"You think that NO Iraqi's were killed in Shock and Awe?"
The blood of innocent victims killed in our war against Saddam is on the hands of Saddam alone.

How morally courageous (and clear-headed) of you to blame victims of Islamic terrorism for defending themselves.

Unlike our enemy, it is not our policy to target innocents.

And that's just like Islam. Its devotees intimidate, coerce, inconvenience, enslave, rape, and slaughter non-Muslims around the world, but what do Muslims protest?

Cartoons.

Perhaps instead of blindly arguing (to your own chagrin), "It doesn't say that!" you should study the texts for yourself.

Again, demonstrate from Qur'an and Sunnah that I have misrepresented anything.

I'll be waiting.
santiago_matamoros wrote (great name, by the way!) . . .
"FAR too many Christian Iraqis have been killed by US forces. 1 is too many actually. And the fact is, Iraqi Christians, Mandeans and other minorities are the biggest victims in all of this (although the Azeris get whatever is coming to them). They will be swallowed up and forced to live under radicalized Sunni and Shi'ite militias and are being killed and harassed by them daily."
But I thought that Islam means "peace," and that all people have an innate desire for freedom?

You don't mean that democracy in Iraq was just a tool used to enshrine Shari'a in its constitution, do you?

Next, you'll be telling me that the president wants to establish a Muslim stronghold in the center of Europe by granting Kosovo independence.

I read something about Iraq's ancient Jewish population being reduced to almost nothing.

First, Clinton bombed Christians to aid Muslim terrorists. Now, President Bush not only hosts iftar dinners, he's again claiming that we all worship Allah and that Islam is peace.

Goodness.
In response to whirlinggal . . .
wg (is that for whirling dervish?). If so, that would be ironic!
"I want to thank the self-titled "Moor-killer" for spamming my thread--"
Are you and your co-ideologues unwilling to recognize this ancient historical refutation to your "Islam is peace" nonsense, or can you just not help yourselves?

Spain would have never attributed victories over Muslim invaders and overlords to its patron saint if Islam had not been invading and oppressing it.

And that's not "spamming." I posted from the word of Allah and the example of Mohammed. Others replied with assorted logical fallacies and outright falsehoods, and I addressed them.
"and proving my point."
Your point was that Allah's commands and Mohammed's words and deeds cause non-Muslims to revile the faithful?

Well done.
rabello continues . . .
I'll be waiting for your proof, Moor Killer, that your interpretation, which is really just a wordy opinion that sounds awfully hateful for a Christian, of the passages you copy/paste is the ONE AND ONLY correct one in all the world.
Another red herring? Unable to support your base and scurrilously false accusations, it appears.

Are you unwilling or unable to address this topic and my words openly and honestly?

My argument has been: "This is what Allah commands. This is what Mohammed said and did."

I proved this by referring to Allah's commands and Mohammed's words and actions.

Your (false) charge has been that I've misrepresented those Islamic texts. Now it is your turn to prove it.

If you cannot, then you should retract.

Quoting Islamic "sacred" texts and renowed Islamic scholars does require words; however, those statements are not *my* opinions, they are Allah's.

As for "hate"? I cite plainly the words of Qur'an and Sunnah, but you defend calls for unrelenting offensive warfare against non-Muslims to enslave or kill all who refuse to submit to Allah.

Which is truly hateful?

The fact you require the question to be asked should give you pause.
In response to whirlinggal,
WGal,

It looks like you're a fan of irony. :)
Self-proclaimed "Moor-Killer" says--

'wg (is that for whirling dervish?). If so, that would be ironic!'

I take it you're not a fan of mysticism?
What's in a name?

If yours is derived from "whirling dervish" (you neither affirmed nor denied it), it would be doubly ironic for my nom de guerre recalls one attributed with the defense of non-Muslims against Allah, while yours is tied to the very ideology making necessary that defense in the first place.
Self-proclaimed "Moor-Killer" says

"Are you and your co-ideologues unwilling to recognize this ancient historical refutation to your "Islam is peace" nonsense, or can you just not help yourselves?"

More unquestioning prejudice rears its unknowing head.
That's also ironic, for I've said, "Don't revile Muslims." I've quoted and referenced Islam's god, founder, "sacred" texts, and scholars.

Your accusing me of, "unknowing, unquestioning prejudice," looks more like projection than description.
Kill them all and let G-d sort them out?
That uncharitable and baseless suggestion is the most unfunny irony of all, for Mohammed commanded:
". . . Fight in the name of Allah and in the way of Allah. Fight against those who disbelieve in Allah. Make a holy war. . . . When you meet your enemies who are polytheists, invite them to three courses of action. . . . Invite them to (accept) Islam; if they respond to you, accept it from them and desist from fighting against them. . . . If they refuse to accept Islam, demand from them the Jizya. If they agree to pay, accept it from them and hold off your hands. If they refuse to pay the tax, seek Allah's help and fight them . . .'" (Muslim Book 19, Number 4294).
rabello added . . .
"What proof? That's the whole problem."
[Proof:]
"Fight those who believe not in Allah nor the Last Day, nor hold that forbidden which hath been forbidden by Allah and His Messenger, nor acknowledge the religion of Truth, (even if they are) of the People of the Book, until they pay the Jizya with willing submission, and feel themselves subdued" (Qur'an 9:29).

"fight and slay the Pagans wherever ye find them, and seize them, beleaguer them, and lie in wait for them in every stratagem (of war) . . . " (Qur’an 9:5).

"Allah's Apostle said: 'I have been ordered (by Allah) to fight against the people until they testify that none has the right to be worshipped but Allah and that Muhammad is Allah's Apostle . . . '" (Bukhari Volume 1, Book 2, Number 24).

“Allah’s Apostle said, ‘I have been made victorious with terror. The treasures of the world were brought to me and put in my hand’” (Bukhari Volume 4, Book 52, Number 220).

"Whoever changed his Islamic religion, then kill him" (Bukhari Volume 9, Book 84, Number 57).
[Not proof:]
"Sequential, overly verbose posts don't make 'a truth.' Opinion is an opinion. A biased opinion is a biased opinion."
You cannot refute the substance of what I've written, so you attack its length.

Be terse in your ignorance and I will be terse in its correction. Refrain from logical fallacies and libelous accusations, and I will spend no words refuting them.

By the way, everyone's opinion is biased, and "overly verbose" is redundant.
"I don't blame Iraqi people for 9/11 just because they're 'The Muslims' and whether 'targeted' or not, innocent children in Iraq have died because of our actions, over the past 15-16 years, just because they're 'The Muslims'"
A straw man. Who blames Iraqis for 9/11?

If innocent children are not targeted, then it can't be "because they're 'The Muslims.'" Neither can it be "because of our actions."
"Can you post opinions without personally attacking those who disagree with you?"
Can you produce anything substantive in supporting your (false) charge that I misrepresent Islamic texts?

All you've offered are ad hominem, red herring, straw man, and tu quoque "arguments."
you responded that yes, too many Christians have been killed in Iraq; even 1 is too many. You didn't include Muslim Iraqi's in your lament. See what you don't say is as revealing as what you do say.
Absence of evidence is evidence of absence?

Even if he did feel that, so what? That's not the point under discussion, so you're just throwing out another red herring.

In your defense of genocide in the furtherance of Islam, you attack, vilify, and demonize those illuminating the Source and Sustenance of that bloodlust.

If you want to be a moral person, stop defending the god and prophet who've wrought this:
". . . We were (sitting) in the mosque when the Messenger of Allah . . . came to us and said: (Let us) go to the Jews. We went out with him until we came to them. The Messenger of Allah . . . stood up and called out to them (saying): O ye assembly of Jews, accept Islam (and) you will be safe.

. . . .

"he killed their men, and distributed their women, children and properties among the Muslims, except that some of them had joined the Messenger of Allah . . . who granted them security. They embraced Islam. The Messenger of Allah . . . turned out all the Jews of Medlina. Banu Qainuqa' (the tribe of 'Abdullah b. Salim) and the Jews of Banu Haritha and every other Jew who was in Medina.

. . . .

"It has been narrated by 'Umar b. al-Khattib that he heard the Messenger of Allah . . . say: I will expel the Jews and Christians from the Arabian Peninsula and will not leave any but Muslim" (Muslim Book 19, Number 4363-4366).
Just added,
rabello,
ParanoidMystic has already pointed out the error of copy/pasting quotes from any religious text and presenting them as proof of something without any historical or scholarly or spiritual context.
Another red herring, for that's not what he's argued, and neither have you.

Instead you've claimed that I've misrepresented the texts I've posted.

You still have not proven from Qur'an and Sunnah that I've erred or lied. Not doing so only demonstrates a lack of competence and integrity.
You can find as many scary posts in the Qur'an that you want; none of it means that all Muslims are terrorists, "potentially," of course, which is the bottomline message of all your posts.
Another straw man, since that's not what I've written.

I've argued, "This is what Allah commands. This is Mohammed's example."

You are either unwilling or unable to refute this, so instead you attack the messenger, continually misrepresenting what I write in the process.

What does this say about your "spirituality"?
Well, yes, it was under discussion. It was you who put it into discussion. Somewhere you said that while Muslims terrorize us, we do not terrorize them; that in fact, they accuse us of terrorizing them to guilt trip "the west"
Are you outright lying and hoping no one will notice? Are you hoping that everyone is too busy or too lazy to go back through this thread to see who wrote what and when they wrote it?

Or are you really unable to keep straight even what you yourself have written?

For in post 304 you wrote in response to santiago:
Do you think that it's possible that people in the Muslim world feel equally terroized [sic] by all of us, seeing how many innocent people that have been killed in Iraq, alone, since March 2003, and could be saying the same things about "us" that you're saying about "them?"
My post 306 (which you bastardize above) was in reply to that.

The point of the thread was, "Why revile Muslims?" The point of my comments were, "This is what Allah says; this is Mohammed's example."
I said the war on Iraq, the loss of life OF COURSE TERRORIZES human beings, that the loss of life has been terrible
You were making a false moral equivalence between Islamic terrorism and American self-defense, blaming us for innocent Iraqi deaths.

santiago sufficiently addressed that last point.

Tenlionz,
Islam and Christianity have proven them selves to be destructive religions. How many have died in the name of your Gods?
The alternative to religious faith, atheism, slaughtered and enslaved hundreds of millions of people in the twentieth century. Are you really sure you want to appeal to irreligion?

As for your immoral, historically- and textually-illiterate false equivalence . . .

Jesus committed no sin, healed the sick, raised the dead, died for the sins of all, and rose from the dead. He taught, "Love your enemies," and "Do good to those who persecute you."

Mohammed lied, stole, enslaved, raped (including little Aisha beginning when she was nine), assassinated, slaughtered, and waged genocidal offensive warfare against non-Muslims (and commanded others to do the same). His Allah commanded, "kill the unbelievers wherever you find them," and, "Fight against those who believe not in Allah. Make a holy war . . . until they feel themselves subdued." Mohammed confessed, "I have been made victorious with terror."

As for allowing people to make their own, even immoral choices, that is one of risks of Liberty. There is no virtue in coercion.

You're rejecting a morally perfect God (Christ) for what? Anarchy?
ANNO DOMINI 2003-2026

the Amillennialist Contra Mundum